A good shooter, but not the best squad based shooter.
On the other hand, if you approach GRAW from a strictly first person tactical shooter, the game is very good and sufficiently challenging. The visuals are amazing, even on my non-hi-def tv. There is a great balance between having to shoot while on the move, and/or holding the left trigger so that you go into "aim" mode. You can still move, but much slower, but your aim is superb then. The cover mechanic is well implemented as well. All that a player has to do is "push" up against any object and the character will assume the appropriate cover stance. You can use this to look over low walls or around corners without fully exposing yourself. Shooting from behind cover is a must as well. While you are still vulnerable, you are much harder to hit, which makes the game that much more realistic. Along that line, because it is a realistic tactical shooter, you can die in just a few gunshots. Frustrating at times, but rewarding when you make it through a particularly difficult section without even being winged. One of the best parts of the game is the amount of technology available to you and your ghosts. The picture in a picture function is great (albeit too small to see much detail). This allows you to see what your squad sees, essentially letting you be in two places at the same time. Additionally, you can control a scout drone to identify targets coming up, you control Apache and Blackhawk helicopters for fire support, and even M1A1 Battle Tanks. All of the above give you large amounts of firepower, and make you feel like you really could take on the entire Mexican rebel army with just you, your squad, and few well placed support items. On the whole, GRAW was a fun game to play. As a first person tactical shooter, it is a game that keeps you on your toes, presents you with multiple angles to defeat enemy units, and gives you the feeling that you really are a super soldier of the future. Unfortunately, I was hoping for a better implemented squad. They do help, yes, but if you are looking to do any kind of cover fire, flanking, or other specific squad mechanic stuff, it won't be in GRAW. The squad is simple; they follow you around and shoot some extra stuff. So depending on what you want, GRAW may or may not be the game for you.