Way overrated in my opinion. Something about the game just seems off.
Campaign:
O where to begin.... It felt like I was playing through an over the top action movie, which I didn't enjoy, but kept playing/watching for some reason. Everything is done for you, rather than you completing things on your own. Trying to solve a puzzle? Don't worry, the game will practically solve it for you in no time. Balancing on a high beam? No worries, you cannot fall unless you actually try to/jump off. Fighting a bad guy in hand to hand? Don't you worry about that either, when you need to counter a punch, the game will automatically slow time, and tell you when to push the triangle button so you don't get hit......it's really pathetic games came to this point in my opinion. Playing Arkham City or Sleeping Dogs before Uncharted 3 is kind of a mistake because the hand to hand combat is terrible in Uncharted 3 in comparison. It's like a watered down "kiddy" version of Sleeping Dogs and Arkham City's combat. Gunplay is really unsatisfying. Aiming and shooting seems a bit off. It feels clunky and very stiff to me for some reason. Enemy AI suck, and so does your AI companions. But the campaign is somewhat enjoyable when it decides to back off the cutscenes and hand holding and just lets you play.
Multiplayer:
I have mixed reaction about this part of the game. The aiming and shooting feels a bit off here too. It's stiff, clunky and seems like I have to shoot someone 20,000 times to get a kill. And the gun recoil is atrocious at times. It seems as if there is always someone shooting you from behind, and walking through doorways is a bad idea because you cannot see what or who is to the left or right until the camera follows you through. But I do give props to the devs for including a lot of game modes that offer a lot of variety of game types.
Co-op:
It 's always a plus for devs to inlcude a offline splitscreen mode. The splitscreen adventure is where I had most fun with this game. It's fun to buddy up with 3 people online to play this mode too.
Overall the game is slightly disappointing. Campaign is fed to you on a silver platter, MP is sketchy at times, but the co-op mode is fun.