Don't let the gamespot review stop you from getting this game.
The old footage of matches and build ups just adds to this great game.Wrestlers look great,and look like they do in real life (some facial features are off in a few wrestlers but not a big deal)
The only downfall of this game is that Legend Killer mode is boring and seems pointless (though it's the only way to up the attributes on your CAW for online play) One more small thing is the lack of online matches available to play, most of the classic ones are there but my only beef is with more than 2 players you can only choose Tag Team or Triple Threat matches, you can't do the "gimmick" matches unless it's one on one.
All in all, great game with endless replay value and easy enough to learn for people new to wrestling games. Don't let the gamespot review sway you away from this game!!