Yoshis Island DS is a great example of nostalgia done right.
While Yoshi's Island DS is the perfect way to retreat to those simpler gaming days, the fun in achieving that perfect score has been hampered by the difficulty in acquiring it. Of course getting one hundred percent should , by all means, be a pain, it seems unforgiving and more difficult than the original SNES version.
Graphics - 8.0
Cute and quirky, this game looks great for a 2d sidescroller. The only problem here, but a big one nonetheless, is the deviation from the "coloring book look." Instead of looking like a kids creative dream, it looks more like a cookie cutter cartoon.
Sound - 8.0
Spot on for the effects, forgettable for the music. The effects are very light and whimsical, fitting the mood of the game. (2.0 points off for the infamous unforgettable baby cries)
Overall - 8.5
Yoshi's Island DS still holds up very well next to the original, but with the added difficulty, deviating graphics and forgetful music this version goes from outstanding to just great. Oh yeah, where is, "Touch Fuzzy, Get Dizzy"?
Maybe next time Yoshi.