Western RPG's

Any good western RPG's besides, The Elder Scrolls, Mass Effect, Dragon Age and The Witcher.

Knights of the Old Republic. Game is awesome. :)

I would say it is playable even if you are not a Star Wars fan.

Tons but it'd be better if you could be a bit more specific on what you're looking for. The genre is vast. Also platform of choice limits your selection a bit. Out of the top of my head, some great recent ones: Tyranny, Pillars of Eternity, Divinity: Original Sin, Shadowrun Returns, Shadowrun Dragonfall (the best of the three), Shadowrun Hong Kong, Path of Exile, Grim Dawn.

Gothic 2 - Truly a great rpg.

@darktruth007: I think Gothic 1 was a bit better. Yes it has unintuitive controls but I got used to them and played Gothic 2 on classic controls too. I think the setting was much more unique and interesting in Gothic 1 and I liked how you could become a dark mage. Still Gothic 2 is a great game and it's even better with night of the raven expansion installed (the Gothic 2 Gold edition includes the expansion and can be found on GoG). Still it's a bit old and that may be off-putting to younger players.

Horizon zero dawn next month :P

Kingdom of Amalur: Reckoning

Dragon's Dogma Dark Arisen, a great open world action rpg.

@darktruth007: nailed it

If you like role playing then I can point at some older games but if you do not care about role playing and just want pretend then you can stick with your list.

@knightofastora: Horizon: Zero Dawn doesn't seem like an RPG to me. It seems like an open-world action game instead.

i've got bad news for you, if your older rpgs are video games then they're just pretend too captain hardcore

@hammerthrust: Well, the developers are calling it an rpg so there is that, it has enough Rpg mechanics imo.

Haven't seen Fallout mentioned (I prefer the old ones). Also, X-com (new ones) is great (but weak in story imho).