Would you take the Xbox or Gamecubes Role-playing Library? (comparison)

GC. I'm a bigger fan of JRPGs and the GC has Skies of Arcadia, which is one of my favorite games ever.

that's an easy answer: Gamecube, why? because most of the Xbox RPGs you posted are on PCrilpas

I'd take the Gamecube's libary since I prefer those types of RPGs more.

xbox easily....the only game i want on that list that i don't have is fire emblem....

edit: oh and you forgot paper mario 2, thousand year door...that was an awesome game

[QUOTE="rilpas"]that's an easy answer: Gamecube, why? because most of the Xbox RPGs you posted are on PCAustralianpope

Xbox hands down.

Skies of Arcadia, Fire Emblem: PoR, Tales of Symphonia, Paper Mario: TTYD... any one of those 4 beats the entire Xbox line up for me. Lost Kingdoms II is also a guilty pleasure of mine (I actually just finished my second play through of the game a few hours ago). Crystal Chronicles was pretty good too, especially if you could get multiplayer going, even if it was just with one person although it's single player certainly wasn't bad.

By a far mile, XBox. Morrowind alone trumps every RPG on the Gamecube. Then you have Fable, Jade Empire, Arx Fatalis, Dungeons & Dragons: Heroes, Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic, Marvel: Ultimate Alliance, and others.

I pick the GC but only because I prefer JRPGs over WRPGs. KOTOR was great on the PC at least.

Still need to get KOTOR2 but on the superior PC.

By a far mile, XBox. Morrowind alone trumps every RPG on the Gamecube. Then you have Fable, Jade Empire, Arx Fatalis, Dungeons & Dragons: Heroes, Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic, Marvel: Ultimate Alliance, and others.

Emerald_Warrior

Morrowind is very boring IMO with terrible combat.

Zelda 1 had better combat then Morrowind

that's an easy answer: Gamecube, why? because most of the Xbox RPGs you posted are on PCrilpas

[QUOTE="rilpas"]that's an easy answer: Gamecube, why? because most of the Xbox RPGs you posted are on PCAustralianpope

actually, 7 out of 12: Kotor, Kotor 2, Morrowind, Fable, Jade Empire, Sudeki and Arx Fatalis

and yes, if all of the xbox games here were exclusive to the Xbox, I'd probably go with the Xbox library

[QUOTE="Australianpope"][QUOTE="rilpas"]that's an easy answer: Gamecube, why? because most of the Xbox RPGs you posted are on PCYoshiYogurt

there are a few non exclusives on the GC side as well, like virtua quest, summoner (which is also on PC BTW), Skies of Arcadia and Megaman X command mission

[QUOTE="YoshiYogurt"][QUOTE="Australianpope"] 5 out of 12 is most? Not only that, PC has nothing to do with this, PC or not, it's which library would you take, and going by your post here i would say you would take the Xbox's if the case of these two only being were indeed true.rilpas

there are a few non exclusives on the GC side as well, like virtua quest, summoner (which is also on PC BTW), Skies of Arcadia and Megaman X command mission

Not even all of those. Skies of Arcadia was on Dreamcast first. And who cares if those other games are also on PC. They AREN'T on Gamecube. So it doesn't make the Gamecube better. Just the same, it shouldn't matter that Gamecube's games are on Dreamcast, because they aren't on XBox.

I would take the XBox simply because it had KotOR. amari24

My reasoning as well.

I hate when ppl put PC in the equation whenever Xbox is being discussed but don't mention the fact that a lot of ps1 "exclusives" are also on the PC.Kaszilla

Also a lot of them are terrible ports *coughs* Final Fantasy 7 and 8* coughs*

[QUOTE="Kaszilla"]I hate when ppl put PC in the equation whenever Xbox is being discussed but don't mention the fact that a lot of ps1 "exclusives" are also on the PC.rilpas

Also a lot of them are terrible ports *coughs* Final Fantasy 7 and 8* coughs*

OP forgot about the two XBox JRPGs, Phantom Dust, and Crimson Sea, they're better than a lot of the games you brought up.

OP forgot about the two XBox JRPGs, Phantom Dust, and Crimson Sea, they're better than a lot of the games you brought up.

Domino_slayer

OP forgot about the two XBox JRPGs, Phantom Dust, and Crimson Sea, they're better than a lot of the games you brought up.

Domino_slayer

[QUOTE="Domino_slayer"]

OP forgot about the two XBox JRPGs, Phantom Dust, and Crimson Sea, they're better than a lot of the games you brought up.

Australianpope

Phantom Dust is considered to be a great RPG for the Xbox

also, if we're using multiplats, should Shenmue 2 be there as well?

[QUOTE="Australianpope"][QUOTE="Domino_slayer"]

OP forgot about the two XBox JRPGs, Phantom Dust, and Crimson Sea, they're better than a lot of the games you brought up.

rilpas

Phantom Dust is considered to be a great RPG for the Xbox

also, if we're using multiplats, should Shenmue 2 be there as well?

I can count KotOR but I honestly can not sit down and play Morrowind on the Xbox. I prefer JRPGs to WRPGs anyways though, so GC.

Also Shenmue is not an RPG.Australianpope

Its as much of an RPG as Harvest Moon is

[QUOTE="Australianpope"]Also Shenmue is not an RPG.Domino_slayer

Its as much of an RPG[ as Harvest Moon is

[QUOTE="rilpas"]

[QUOTE="Australianpope"] No and are they in English?Australianpope

Phantom Dust is considered to be a great RPG for the Xbox

also, if we're using multiplats, should Shenmue 2 be there as well?