I'm so tired of the Melee vs Brawl argument!

it's obvious you're tired of the argument.jnjreams76

Lol.

Well I haven't heard this argument much, but in my opinion Melee is better. I've played both of them to death, and I like them both a lot, it's just that Roy was my character! Now I've gotta settle for Marth.

I'm tired of it too.

But just ignore it.

I enjoy Brawl a lot more then Melee but I can see why people prefer Melee over Brawl.

Who's arguing? What are you talking about?

I haven't heard people argue over the two games since Brawl came out.

So what are you talking about? Were you making these arguments up in your head?

[QUOTE="jnjreams76"]it's obvious you're tired of the argument.randomwiiplayer

Lol.

Brawl does NOT have online. If you call that piece of crap, which takes 1/2 hour to find somebody to play, and then lags, online play than you are in denial. Even with the best connections, playing against my friends (who also had great connections) led to the whole screen freezing.

Brawl does NOT have online. If you call that piece of crap, which takes 1/2 hour to find somebody to play, and then lags, online play than you are in denial. Even with the best connections, playing against my friends (who also had great connections) led to the whole screen freezing.

Chargeagles1

[QUOTE="randomwiiplayer"]

[QUOTE="jnjreams76"]it's obvious you're tired of the argument.DeeDeeDee-er

Lol.

i third the lolling

[QUOTE="Chargeagles1"]

Brawl does NOT have online. If you call that piece of crap, which takes 1/2 hour to find somebody to play, and then lags, online play than you are in denial. Even with the best connections, playing against my friends (who also had great connections) led to the whole screen freezing.

blazingneo32089

It does have more content, but I wholly prefer the fast pace of Melee over brawl. I've played over 2,000 hours of melee, and only 390 hours of brawl. I hated how they made Jigglypuff's down b move useless, and how they made ganondorf slower and less powerful.

I played melee for probably 500 hours and was really excited for brawl but it sucks. Its like an updated port of melee and the new characters moves were horrible. The stage buldier and storymode were crap. Melee was so much better even if falco was way stronger than everybody else it made it fun

people dont argue about the game anymore........... do they?

people dont argue about the game anymore........... do they?

sman3579

[QUOTE="blazingneo32089"][QUOTE="Chargeagles1"]

Brawl does NOT have online. If you call that piece of crap, which takes 1/2 hour to find somebody to play, and then lags, online play than you are in denial. Even with the best connections, playing against my friends (who also had great connections) led to the whole screen freezing.

Chargeagles1

It does have more content, but I wholly prefer the fast pace of Melee over brawl. I've played over 2,000 hours of melee, and only 390 hours of brawl. I hated how they made Jigglypuff's down b move useless, and how they made ganondorf slower and less powerful.

some people still think counter strike is better the cs:s and they always will just because they one dont like change and two glorified it and when something elsecomes along it doesnt matter its almost the same game. newer isnt always better but its not always a bad thing either......

Lucas.

Well I haven't heard this argument much, but in my opinion Melee is better. I've played both of them to death, and I like them both a lot, it's just that Roy was my character! Now I've gotta settle for Marth.

trugs26

[QUOTE="trugs26"]

Well I haven't heard this argument much, but in my opinion Melee is better. I've played both of them to death, and I like them both a lot, it's just that Roy was my character! Now I've gotta settle for Marth.

wooooode

They're both very fun games

Happy now?

:lol:

I never played Melee but I loved Brawl.

[QUOTE="sman3579"]

people dont argue about the game anymore........... do they?

blazingneo32089

People just miss wave dashing and L canceling, they don't really hate brawl.Pyro767

[spoiler]

I don't see anybody arguing, though Brawl is superior in every shape and form. Okay, so the characters move .0000001% slower, what a huge, massive factor that breaks the game. :roll: It's the same exact thing, only with ten times more content and better graphics and sound. Melee is an excellent game, but Brawl is everything Melee was but way more. The one thing Melee is more superior in is menus. The main menu music and look for Brawl is nowhere near as epic as it was for Melee.enterawesome

...I assume you didn't read my criticisms just a few posts above?

Most people who hate brawl are the tourney nerds who played on final destination with no items. Fox vs. Fox vs. Fox vs. Fox. They'd speed around all game and do their little movement exploits. They hate smash balls, they think that Brawl's slower speed makes it easier. They're idiots who don't know how t have fun. In Melee I used Sheik and Roy. Though I miss Roy I have plenty of fun with Ike. I seem to have a lot of trouble with Sheik in Brawl so I stick with Zelda as my main.

My biggest beef with Brawl:

Bowser's character redesign - scaly raptor (not elephant) legs, gradient hair, and more pronounced spikes from melee was far more badass IMO

Lucario but no Mewtwo - bullcrap IMO

I really wanted more villains (K. ROOL) Wolf was a great addition though

There's some more issues. Overall Brawl is basically the same expierence to me with a few differences and a lot more content.

The only reason I'd play Melee is for nosalgia, my old favorite characters and some of the character designs I simply like better.

[QUOTE="Pyro767"]People just miss wave dashing and L canceling, they don't really hate brawl.VGobbsesser

*long ass list of complaints and nitpicks*

[QUOTE="VGobbsesser"]

[QUOTE="Pyro767"]People just miss wave dashing and L canceling, they don't really hate brawl.Shinobishyguy

*long ass list of complaints and nitpicks*

Better to give a list of what I disliked about the game than to just go around around saying "I hate it" without backing up why I dislike it,no?

[QUOTE="Shinobishyguy"]

[QUOTE="VGobbsesser"]Generalizations and assumptions are fun. Oh,and here's everything I disliked about Brawl.Note how I don't even mention wave dashing and L-canceling.

*long ass list of complaints and nitpicks*VGobbsesser

Better to give a list of what I disliked about the game than to just go around around saying "I hate it" without backing up why I dislike it,no?

Yeah until this post I didn't even know there was a debate. I guess there is now though. Brawl is slightly better than Melee in every way, so logically Brawl is the better game (although not much). Of course I only play with Kirby and he is exactly the same in both games (I've at least never noticed any difference). So for me its just a difference in graphics and content and Brawl wins that easily. Also the online works pretty well for me, it could have been better but I'm happy with it. Of course I have heard people say the N64 version was the best, those people are the craziest of all.

lol You know all you're doin' is sparking another Brawl vs. Melee argument?:P

I don't see anybody arguing, though Brawl is superior in every shape and form. Okay, so the characters move .0000001% slower, what a huge, massive factor that breaks the game. :roll: It's the same exact thing, only with ten times more content and better graphics and sound. Melee is an excellent game, but Brawl is everything Melee was but way more. The one thing Melee is more superior in is menus. The main menu music and look for Brawl is nowhere near as epic as it was for Melee.enterawesome

Your right theres more content in Brawl Excpet its the new content that I didn't like Boss Battle mode was horrible along with everything else

Melee is faster paced and has more glitches.OreoMilkshake

Glitches make a game good? I thought glitches were the very thing that The Conduit was criticized for.:?

[QUOTE="OreoMilkshake"]Melee is faster paced and has more glitches.HipYoungster42

Glitches make a game good? I thought glitches were the very thing that The Conduit was criticized for.:?

This was even an argument? I thought Brawl was better hands down. It certainly was more polished nobody can deny that.

brawl takes less skill to master while melee took more skill and timing to master

wavedashing

L- Cancelling

kinda like when mario kart wii took away snakingand made mario kart less skillful