RE4 (GC) or RE4 : Wii? Which d'you prefer?

Read title. Answer poll!

The Wii version has extra content

The controls are worse in the Wii version but the aiming is better. It's the exact opposite way in the Gamecube version

Considering that it's only 20 bucks it's worth it to have both so you have the extra content and see the difference in control schemes

I think controls are great on Wii too.

Aiming is a bit too easy but that doesn't bother me, you simply save bullets. :)

I had the GCN version, amazing game. Wii version, equally great!

The Wii version has extra content

The controls are worse in the Wii version but the aiming is better. It's the exact opposite way in the Gamecube version

Considering that it's only 20 bucks it's worth it to have both so you have the extra content and see the difference in control schemes

Wii edition, not even a contest. I hate using analog sticks to aim.

the wii version is the definitive version. who would choose any of the other versions unless you dont own a wii?

The controls for RE4 Wii Edition are far superior to the GC version(I own both). Add in additional content, Widescreen, and 30 dollar price tag and the winner is very obvious.

Graphics of the Gamecube Version

Content of the PS2 Version

Greatly improved controls, but old conrol scheme still intact

480p, Widescreen

All at a budget price

It's the best version of one of the best games ever made, and thats that.

The wii version since it has more and you can play it with the gamecube controller.

wii edition

The Wii version, obviously for the content and lower price and beefed up controls.

However, I played the game so much on the gamecube, sometimes I miss that version.

Wii version for the superior aiming ..which tho made the game easier :)

I guess I prefer the Wii version, beacuse of new content and controls, but I had way more fun with the GC version. I played it through about 6 times, completed mercenaries mode with 5 stars with all characters on all maps and unlocked everything. I got the Wii version to see what the fuzz was about, and I haven't even finished it.

Just saying that by the time the Wii version came, I felt I was pretty much done with the game. The controls didn't make me want to finish the game and unlock stuff again.

Must say that I agree with Jayson, that the aiming for the Wii is obviously better, but the controls overall was better in the GC version. I thought going through the menus and some other stuff was pretty annoying in the Wii version.

It has more modes so the Wii version also I liked the controls too.

The Wii version has extra content

The controls are worse in the Wii version but the aiming is better. It's the exact opposite way in the Gamecube version

Jaysonguy

Your statement makes no sence.

Controls are bad but they are good? What is that suppost to mean?

[QUOTE="Jaysonguy"]

The Wii version has extra content

The controls are worse in the Wii version but the aiming is better. It's the exact opposite way in the Gamecube version

snover2009

Your statement makes no sence.

Controls are bad but they are good? What is that suppost to mean?

You're aware you do more then aim in the game right?

[QUOTE="snover2009"]

[QUOTE="Jaysonguy"]

The Wii version has extra content

The controls are worse in the Wii version but the aiming is better. It's the exact opposite way in the Gamecube version

Jaysonguy

Your statement makes no sence.

Controls are bad but they are good? What is that suppost to mean?

You're aware you do more then aim in the game right?

I played the GC version more. The only reason I got the Wii version was because it came with my Wii when I first got it. Only new thing was the controls since I had already played the exztra content on the PS2.

The motion controls were nice but I would not have bought the Wii version for them having already played it before.

I prefered the GC version.

[QUOTE="Jaysonguy"]

[QUOTE="snover2009"]

Your statement makes no sence.

Controls are bad but they are good? What is that suppost to mean?

garrett_duffman

You're aware you do more then aim in the game right?

How is movement the same?

ONe side of it is the same and that's it

[QUOTE="garrett_duffman"][QUOTE="Jaysonguy"]

You're aware you do more then aim in the game right?

Jaysonguy

How is movement the same?

ONe side of it is the same and that's it

maybe because movement is handled with just the analog stick

[QUOTE="garrett_duffman"][QUOTE="Jaysonguy"]

You're aware you do more then aim in the game right?

Jaysonguy

How is movement the same?

ONe side of it is the same and that's it

[QUOTE="Jaysonguy"]

[QUOTE="garrett_duffman"] thats got to be the most asinine thing ive seen today. the controls are mapped virtually the same as the GC version, only the aiming is different. well, instead of hitting B you hit either Z or C, but its still easy as cerealgarrett_duffman

How is movement the same?

ONe side of it is the same and that's it

I don't understand

If you're playing the game on the Wii then you're not using two thumbsticks

[QUOTE="garrett_duffman"][QUOTE="Jaysonguy"]

How is movement the same?

ONe side of it is the same and that's it

Jaysonguy

I don't understand

If you're playing the game on the Wii then you're not using two thumbsticks

Lets just conclude that the Wii version is superior to all in every aspect and move on.

Lets just conclude that the Wii version is superior to all in every aspect and move on.

snover2009

[QUOTE="Jaysonguy"]

[QUOTE="garrett_duffman"] i just dont agree with that.garrett_duffman

I don't understand

If you're playing the game on the Wii then you're not using two thumbsticks

You move with the thumbstick lol
That's much

The thumbstick gives you better control of the movement of the character

[QUOTE="garrett_duffman"][QUOTE="Jaysonguy"]

I don't understand

If you're playing the game on the Wii then you're not using two thumbsticks

Jaysonguy

You move with the thumbstick lol
That's much

The thumbstick gives you better control of the movement of the character

In case you didn't notice, the Wii also has a thumbstick, so how does this argument work?

[QUOTE="Jaysonguy"]

[QUOTE="garrett_duffman"] ooooh dear... you dont use the C-stick in RE4 much anyways. the C-stick control has been replaced by the D-pad control, which isnt a problem at all, i find it more comfortable. (the C-stick is just used for tilting the camera just a little bit while walking, which proves to be useless throughout about 90% of the game)snover2009

You move with the thumbstick lol
That's much

The thumbstick gives you better control of the movement of the character

In case you didn't notice, the Wii also has a thumbstick, so how does this argument work?

Yes, one of them

The one that now determines your direction isn't there anymore.

You're stuck using the Wiimote to steer your character which isn't as precise as the thumbstick.

The Wiimote is great for the aiming because all you're doing is pointing at something on the screen, but for character navigation it's a second place finish.

[QUOTE="garrett_duffman"][QUOTE="Jaysonguy"]

I don't understand

If you're playing the game on the Wii then you're not using two thumbsticks

Jaysonguy

You move with the thumbstick lol
That's much

The thumbstick gives you better control of the movement of the character

[QUOTE="snover2009"]

[QUOTE="Jaysonguy"]

You move with the thumbstick lol
That's much

The thumbstick gives you better control of the movement of the character

Jaysonguy

In case you didn't notice, the Wii also has a thumbstick, so how does this argument work?

Yes, one of them

The one that now determines your direction isn't there anymore.

You're stuck using the Wiimote to steer your character which isn't as precise as the thumbstick.

The Wiimote is great for the aiming because all you're doing is pointing at something on the screen, but for character navigation it's a second place finish.

RE4 doesn't use that little C stick on the GameCube controller, you stear and move with just the one stick.

The Wii Remote is more accurate than a thumb stick.

In Scarface the camera is controled with the pinter and worked better than using the D-pad to move the camera in the Godfather

I've only played the gc version, but I've heard that the wii version is the best.

The Wii version has extra content

The controls are worse in the Wii version but the aiming is better. It's the exact opposite way in the Gamecube version

Considering that it's only 20 bucks it's worth it to have both so you have the extra content and see the difference in control schemes

Jaysonguy

I've only played it on Wii.