Secret Rings vs Black Knight

Secret Rings vs Black Knight

I like secret rings better, although black knight isn't half as bad as the critics say it is.

I like secret rings better, although black knight isn't half as bad as the critics say it is.

gamer6464

That's about what I was going to say.

I have yet to play Secret Rings, but since Black Knight was pretty damn medeocre I'll vote for Secret Rings on this one.

I'll have to admit, though, Black Knight's story was so hilariously bad that I actually enjoyed it to an extent...

Secret Rings is my favorite 3D Sonic, unfortunately the first three hours are bad, sometimes even horrible. But if you finally unlock more speed and better controls, it's very good.

It was the right concept, but Black Knight seemingly destroyed it with horrible sword controls and too many enemies...

Hopefully the next storybook game will be an improved version of Secret Rings, but without adding a new gimmick...

Secret of the Rings because it has no pointless gimmicks unlike Sonic and the Black Knight which has a sword.

Secret of the Rings because it has no pointless gimmicks unlike Sonic and the Black Knight which has a sword.

chocolate1325

I think every sonic related game that has come out in the next gen systems has been a complete and utter failure. Secret rings is glitchy....invisible walls......and the Wii emotions and such made it irritating to enjoy........

Honestly have not.....honestly WILL not......play black night. because the concept of Sonic wielding a sword to take out an armored foe....is just ridiculous. Sonic is sonic. not some sword wielding hero.

Sonic was on the top of its game with Adventure 2 Battle. Sonic as an RPG like that was pretty cool. There were tons of things to do there. But now there trying to make him finding some ancient sword or something.

Next thing ya know he'll be saving Amy (Who will then be a princess).......and the story will have Amy....Sonic....and Eggman having 3 powers that combined make a Triangle.....and Sonic will be wearing a green hood....and you get where i'm going.

Sonic should just stay simple with his few power-ups here and there. Stop trying to make him something different in each game. (such as swordsman guy.......beastly hedgehog thing...). It's getting a little over the top making him have a sword.

Honestly i think they both suck, but I hate secret rings more.

If this were an actual fight, both games would knock eachother out on the first punch.
Cat poo vs dog poo came to mind when I saw this poll.

There's no contest. Secret Rings is actually a decent game. Black Knight is just terrible.

They should just do a sequel to Secret Rings that plays similar except with remote+nunchuck and Sonic at level 0 should be a little faster and turn a little better. I like how you can customize his speed though, since some people prefer to blaze through but some people find it too fast, but most people can agree that in the beginning levels Sonic is pretty much too slow.

And something really cool that would be a possibility with the remote+nunchuck is, using the remote's IR aimer to lock onto enemies for homing attack! It'd be super awesome cause the game designers could make it so that some enemies can't be homing attacked into or something and then you would have to point at a different enemy and homing attack him instead.