Super mario galaxy vs. Zelda TP

Both are fun titles, but I find Twilight Princess has more better story telling & addictive.

While I enjoyed both, I would have to say Mario Galaxy has an edge over Twilight Princess.

Twilight Princess. First Zelda game, overall it engrossed me in the story. Better gameplay, better game, epic boss battles, amazing. Mario games are either terrible or overrated by critics.

I love the Mario series, but i love the Zelda series more. So I'd say Twilight Princess.

Twilight Princess was simply a remake from the GC games (ie. Wind Waker) so it is not really anything new besides improved graphics and those wanting a feel of nostalgia.

Super Mario Galaxy was revolutionary in the fact that is practically re-invented what a platformer should be and set new, ultra-high standards for others wishing to enter the genre. It also pushed the Wii further than predicted possible and proved that great graphics were possible on what was seen a mediocre in terms of presentation quality.

Therefore, I believe SMG is the better of the two. That is not to say TP was a poor game; it was great as well, however not up to the notch made by SMG.

While I enjoyed both, I would have to say Mario Galaxy has an edge over Twilight Princess.

-Russ93

both games are great, but I liked most zelda

Both were a little disappointing and felt like dubbed-down versions of their predecessors, but i'd have to go with SMG.

I think Zelda TP is the best one of these two. Sure SMG is a good game, but nothing beats a great adventure game with a good story line.

I enjoyed TP a little bit more, but I consider Galaxy to be the better game of the two.alphamale1989