This topic is locked from further discussion.
noones....
GS`s I read it to know about how gameplay is
Player... i ask/read some opinion to see how well teh controller are.
But i tend to get teh game and tested myself. Reason why i have own really bad games.. others that have bad review taht i loved and others that have great review that i sell.. :P I`m even waiting for Bug island to be less $$$ so i can get it :lol: :lol:
me everyone has different oppinion i guess just because theirs alot of them playing itand not just 5 or 10dukenukem2
gamespots even though i disagree w/ them alot but theyre more pro at rating
im not gonna go buy what players say
once i did that and i was so pissed
gs gave this one game a 6.5 and the players gave it a 9.0 so i decided to try it and it sucked...from then on i went by gs ratings and the rest is history
[QUOTE="dukenukem2"]me everyone has different oppinion i guess just because theirs alot of them playing itand not just 5 or 10Raiden_69
gamespots even though i disagree w/ them alot but theyre more pro at rating
im not gonna go buy what players say
once i did that and i was so pissed
gs gave this one game a 6.5 and the players gave it a 9.0 so i decided to try it and it sucked...from then on i went by gs ratings and the rest is history
I know, that happened to me with The Nightmare Before Christmas: Oogie's Revenge for the PS2. Gamespot gave it a 6.something and all the other review gave it 8.5s and 8.0s so I thought "Ah, I like TNBC anyways and if these people like the game so much, I probably will! Boy was I wrong :roll:Even though the Gamespot's scores may be low, they still have some very valuable and true info in the reviews. However, I go to IGN for Video Reviews. I still have a lot of respect for gamespot and their reviews, more so than Player reviews. Many player reviews are trash, while a rare few are really good. I'll only read the ones that are recommened by a lot of people.
I usually read major reviews (Gamespot, IGN, etc). Then I look at a few of the player reviews but specifically the lower end (without being rediculous) then at the higher end. I look at the lower end because it usually contains opinions of people that had their expectations crushed. Thus I get a good feel of what 'people thought the game was, but it was not'. The high end you will find the opposite (and fan boys), but sorting through them gives me a good idea of what the game is fun for. The goal of the high end / low end, is to make sure your expectations are right before you buy (a lot of enjoyment comes from your own expectation of the game / event).
I'll wrap it up by reading reviews in the middle in hopes of finding someone that takes good care of reviewing the games. If they like the same genre or games I'll usually check in on them once in a while to see if they have played anything that might appeal to me that I overlooked.
In short, I spend more time looking at player reviews (because there are more out there). It not only helps set my expectations but gives me a good feel of what the community around me really cares about.
I used to look heavily at player reviews, but what's sad is that they aren't as reliable because of fanboys of rival or competing titles. I've actually seen threads on other message boards where people ask that members go to gamespot or other player review sites and give it horrible ratings even if they've never played it. Pathetic...
So I tend to do a 50/50 now with the pro reviews (usually gamespot and game informer mag) and player reviews. Tends to work pretty well.
Even the recommended ones are sometimes terrible because fanboys recommend whatever review gives their favourite game a high score without even giving any thought as to what the actual content of the review says.Even though the Gamespot's scores may be low, they still have some very valuable and true info in the reviews. However, I go to IGN for Video Reviews. I still have a lot of respect for gamespot and their reviews, more so than Player reviews. Many player reviews are trash, while a rare few are really good. I'll only read the ones that are recommened by a lot of people.
StephenBassford
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment