[QUOTE="Colt45fool"]You're not getting it though. What if EVERY independent artist had backing like Vampire Wekeend.What if these independent musicians were backed by major labels. Look at Modest Mouse--Modest Mouse has such a cult following as an independent artist that when they go to a major their album goes platnium. Now apply that to Vampire Weekend, and Odawas...Fruit Bats, and Fleet Foxes...Black Milk and The Jacka. You think these dudes wouldn't sell? Fruit Bats, and Odawas probably not but the other musicians probably would. Way more than you're giving them credit for.ICP isn't good, I was just bringing them up as a musician who has sold. Independent music sells. Good music sells. Independent =/= good, though it can be.
Good music sells because they grow established fanbases who expect a certain level of quality. If good musicians went major, they'd sell way better or just as well as the current crop of major label musicians. The ear of the listener isn't dead, the record execs are just morons.
Orlando_Magic
Vampire Weekend is super catchy, makes funny videos, gets airplay on MTV, and is basically a pop act on an indie label. Sure, I think other bands like them would sell on a major label. Who wouldn't? They are everything a major label looks for in a new act, yet are on an indie. Not every indie band is like that.
Fleet Foxes would sell well but not on the level of Vampire Weekend.
The Jacka and Black Milk definitely would not sell on a major label. They would sell worse than Little Brother did when LB was on Atlantic.
Fruit Bats and Odawas would not sell.
I am not disagreeing with you that artists with established fanbases will sell. That's pretty obvious lol. You said earlier that good music sells no matter what, even if its on an indie. So I gave you some examples of "good" music (aka music I know you like) and showed you that they weren't selling. There's really not much more to it than that.
What's stopping someone like Freddie Gibbs from having a fanbase as large as Wiz Khalifa? Both of them are good, maybe even great artists, yet if both of them put out albums today Wiz would be the only one to put up decent numbers. Just because you are a good artist does not mean you will ever develop that core fanbase that will translate into album sales.
The fact that you already admitted earlier that "bad" music sells shows you that quality of music isn't the sole determinant of album sales. So when a good album happens to sell, you can't just sit back and say "oh it was because the music was good." Marketing and getting the right people to listen to the music is just as, if not more important.
The original argument was that an artist with an established fanbase will sell. But how do you create an established fanbase? By putting out good music. You put out a dud (Wale, Murs, etc.) and your fan base goes with it. Sure there are outliers to this rule, but lets disregard musicians that get ****loads of promotion like Soulja Boy, or Nickelback or live off gimmicks like ICP....because neither of those were in the original conversation. Obviously the only determinant in selling isn't making good music; that's obvious. Accessibility is expected, but bands like Radiohead don't make pop music and they still go Gold on indie labels...TV On The Radio sells without pop music, and so do the Fleet Foxes. These bands may be the exception, but it's telling of how much the industry has changed....because 30 years ago these bands would never sell. Ever. The industry is changing and so are its fans. Piracy isn't the only thing killing record sells these days, it's people going out and searching for dope music....once record execs realize this, maybe we'll see the multi platnium record sales we saw earlier this decade.
I don't listen to Freddie Gibbs so I can't comment on it. The Jacka and Black Milk would absolutely sell on a major with the right promotion. Dudes have single worthy songs for days. "Get It In"/'Summer'/Glamorous Lifestyle wouldn't get radio play? You think? Without U/RePPin For U/Overdose/Long Story Short wouldn't get play? I could see either guy put up Kweli type numbers, especially Black Milk.
Log in to comment