[QUOTE="TheTrueMagusX1"]
[QUOTE="Nagru"]
I bought the first book, A Game of Thrones, and read the first few chapters. I found it to be a poorly written novel, and moved on to other books.
Theokhoth re-recommended the book to me however, so I'll have to go back to it at some point and give it another chance. I'm in no rush however, I somehow still doubt the novel's anywhere near as impressive as people have been making it out to be.
Nagru
I completely disagree that the novel is poorly written. Martin imo is a master of word play, and his prose reads smoothly. I find that he is very good with dialogue and wit. It does start slow, yes but it does get better..in the end it is a matter of tastes.
I'm more of a Science-Fiction reader, so Fantasy novels already have a harder time appealing to me. Then again I love all of Tolkein's works (Esp. The Silmarillion), Salvatore's Dark Elf trilogy, and Stover's Caine series. As I said I'll give Martin's book another shot, but that's far in the future.
Anyways, If I remember correctly, Martin just threw the reader into the world he created without explaining much and expected the reader to 'get it' and care about what was happening. Does he ever get around to explaining things or is the reader supposed to patch things together along the way? Or am I just remembering another book entirely? (that happens sometimes:P) Also, I remember a section where the Kings children find some 'direwolf' pups, and the whole scene felt so cliche and forced I almost stopped right there.
Thats cool, and yea I love some Sci Fi as well, and between you and I, I am a fan of Harlan Ellison!
But yes Martin does get around to explaining things, and things come together quite well through out the book. Now I do understand your concerns about the Direwolf scene. Yeah it does seem cliche, it really does seem cliche at that moment, with the whole talk about how the children are destined to find them, but trust me, he breaks those cliches quickly...and by the end of the first book, you will quickly forget about that destiny part. It may not seem so at first but the book breaks alot of those cliche and even the ones it seems to establish for it self. I say give the book a chance and atleast read the first book to its entirety.
As for Salvatore Dark Elf books, I will agree that trilogy is awesome. Those books seem like a great action adventure series, like the equivalent of Die Hard in fantasy I suppose.
Log in to comment