[QUOTE="123625"][QUOTE="sSubZerOo"][QUOTE="123625"][QUOTE="RationalAtheist"][QUOTE="123625"] People who follow the bible don't die for it, they die for God.
sSubZerOo
If the bible didn't exist, your belief in God, as it is, would not exist either.
Your belief stems from adherence to the doctrine.
What if questions are useless. Its like me saying, If charles darwin didn't exist or didn't wirte about his theory of evolution and natural selection, everyone would still be creationist. Which is quite possible.
Thats false, evolution was hypotheisesd by I believe Aximander, before Christ in Ancient greece.. During the time of Socrates.. And I am quite sure some one would come to this conclusion with the evidence we have seen.
Okay what if those people didn't exist or write about evolution?
There would be another person.. You make it sound like these people founded evolution.. When merely they realized through deductive reasoning.. If it didn't happen with Darwin it would have happened with some thing else.. Just because you don't believe it, doesn't mean that the science community doesn't either.
Mere assumptions, are you 100% sure this would happen? How do you know? These could of been the only people to suggest something like this. "What if," questions are useless, cause the results and predictions are beyond our knowledge or comprehending. You cannot say for sure, using a "what if" question.
And beleif in God does not stem from one doctrine.
Many religions/doctrines, god can be seen as completely different.. Hell some forms of Budhism, are closer to athiests then true thiests.
I know this
Actually im sure many of the pagans didn't write down there God's on scripture. They were passed down by oral tradition. If christianity wasn't written down it could of been passed down aurally. Just a though.
Called Greek, and Norse Mythology..
These were the only pagan religions?
Not at all they were considered examples..
I'm not alking about a select group of pagan materials. I'm talking about most Pagan texts, were they all written and passed down, by texts and not speech? I am assuming no.
Actually almost all anceint religions were passed down by speech and preeching, then only to be wirrten down hundreds of years later.
That is false, cultures like Rome and Greece had written language for a very very very long time..
These count as most religions?
Well we could go further.. We know for instance that the culture in India had written language for a very long time.. Same goes for China. Written language is the first step for the advancement of civilization.
For one thing we are not discussing language, we are discussing religion and how it was known. Just because a language existed doesnt mean all had the ability to read and write, actually most of them didn't. Only the higher rank people with education could read and write.
We're talking about religion. Most religions were passed down by the mouth. They weren't just written and distributed, and people beleived in them. They were oral stories which people years later wrote down. Like the Gospels for example, and other religous texts im sure.
So in conclusion i propose "what if" questions useless as they are not valid.
And please excuse my slobberish typing.
Log in to comment