Do you think the college system is seriously flawed??

  • 68 results
  • 1
  • 2

This topic is locked from further discussion.

Avatar image for Paladin_King
Paladin_King

11832

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 13

User Lists: 0

#51 Paladin_King
Member since 2008 • 11832 Posts
Well, I've gone through or at least had some acquaintance with the university systems in Canada, the United States, and the UK. Basically, the UK system, at least comparatively, is more or less fine. The American system is completely bloated and troubled. The Canadian system is basically in between the UK and the Americans. That said, I don't think that TC's concerns are where the difficulties lie. Don't like pre-requisites? Well too bad. If pre-reqs are SO bad that you feel restricted, perhaps that just isn't the right major for you. In my experience, pre-requisites made a lot of sense. Going into any field, in academia or in life, will always require you to pay your dues at the beginning by sitting through some horrendous required courses. On the plus side,, you can usually get through most of them so that by your last year, if not earlier, you have a lot more freedom to do exactly what you want. The idea of pre-reqs is to make you aware of the basics, while also experiencing the entire spectrum of what your chosen field has to offer. It ensures that there are less areas that you'll be in the dark about as well. That said....*Sigh* As far as American schools go..... 1. The tuition is outrageous. Absolutely, unforgivably outrageous. Did you guys know that going to Oxford for a year costs around the equivalent of 10-12 thousand dollars a year for a British kid and about 30,000 a year for an overseas student? Yeah. Now how much does Yale and Harvard (Comparative schools) cost again? Ridiculous. 2. The admissions process is bloated and unforgivable. It's just too much at this points. There are standardized tests all over the place, and standardized tests on top of standardized tests (SATs were weak enough....but now we need SAT subject tests and ACTs as well? seriously?). Students are padding their resumes with extracurricular crap and for many, Advanced Placement college courses are a requirement to get where they want to go. If you're doing an entire year's worth of a college courses in a high school...to get into a university.....something has gone, horribly, terribly wrong. 3. Class sizes are growing increasingly depressing. The amount of engagement, interest, and learning is SO much greater the smaller the classes are. I did my best work and felt most motivated in my senior year's seminars (30 people), while i did my most horrendous and unmotivated crap in my big lectures (200 people). Class sizes are just a total disaster. I'm really not sure how, or if, any of this can be fixed. The problem is that university, or a bachelor's degree, is these days considered to be a requirement to get anywhere in life. As a result, you get a lot of kids in university who really don't deserve to be there: they are uninterested, they don't work, and they have absolutely no area of interest. These wastes of space are what lead to higher overheads (higher tuitions), bloated classes, and ridiculous admissions processes. oh, I'd also like to add that i find American marking to be a bit....easy.
Avatar image for deactivated-5e376fa88bd45
deactivated-5e376fa88bd45

4403

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 3

User Lists: 0

#52 deactivated-5e376fa88bd45
Member since 2004 • 4403 Posts

In other words, college offers you the opportunity to get a higher-paying job so that may spend more money and put more money back into the pockets of the wealthy upper-class.That's really all it boils down to. I fail to see the logic in spending a total of $60,000 dollars to get that "special-dream job" that I've wanted all my life, only to make $30,000 a year. Even if I make $200,000 a year, what does that matter? Money, money, money, that's not where happiness comes from, and I don't need a good degree and a high-paying job to bring me happiness. All I need is a decent paying job, which you can get even without a degree, and good people to spend my time with.

VoodooGamer

If you are in the right place then that 30,000 dollars is only a temporary first year thing. Persistence will get you better positions and higher paychecks as the years pass by. And 30,000 dollars in a first year for people in general is certainly not set in stone. As soon as my brother in law got out of University his first job is paying him $50,000 in the IT industry. Which just so happens to be my degree so yay me(I think). Also on another note, while there is the case of people who don`t need money to derive happiness from, the general case is that people will actually be more happy the more money they have since they can afford more things. While I can`t cite the study on the top of my head, i`ll just tell you that i learned it in one my university classes and that there was actually a study that actually mentioned that.

Also on the note of money going into the pockets of the wealthy upper class. Sure they may get more money, but that money will also likely end up either in the hands of other classes or the government. Money flows and circulates from class to class in general(mind you, not so much in this depression).

Avatar image for Tiefster
Tiefster

14639

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 37

User Lists: 0

#53 Tiefster
Member since 2005 • 14639 Posts

Yes, its flawed. Almost everything about it is in error. It bothers me that the people who graduated high school with me and cheated their way through and are now in some of the best schools taking some of the easiest majors. Tuition is impossible and the loan process is horrible. There are serious quality issues as well, I've had too many terrible professors and my friends have too.

Avatar image for deactivated-5e376fa88bd45
deactivated-5e376fa88bd45

4403

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 3

User Lists: 0

#54 deactivated-5e376fa88bd45
Member since 2004 • 4403 Posts

1. The tuition is outrageous. Absolutely, unforgivably outrageous. Did you guys know that going to Oxford for a year costs around the equivalent of 10-12 thousand dollars a year for a British kid and about 30,000 a year for an overseas student? Yeah. Now how much does Yale and Harvard (Comparative schools) cost again? Ridiculous.Paladin_King

Here in Canada, I believe the norm to be some where around 5-7k a year Canadian. Ridiculously generous in comparision to you guys for sure considering that i can make a good chunk of that money solely through summer work. People here however will still whine about how the price tag is way too high. To add something else thats interesting: In Germany, I think they used to pay only 500 euro(is that the currency in Germany) per semester. Now its $1000 per semester.

Avatar image for thepwninator
thepwninator

8134

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 4

User Lists: 0

#55 thepwninator
Member since 2006 • 8134 Posts

[QUOTE="VoodooGamer"]

In other words, college offers you the opportunity to get a higher-paying job so that may spend more money and put more money back into the pockets of the wealthy upper-class.That's really all it boils down to. I fail to see the logic in spending a total of $60,000 dollars to get that "special-dream job" that I've wanted all my life, only to make $30,000 a year. Even if I make $200,000 a year, what does that matter? Money, money, money, that's not where happiness comes from, and I don't need a good degree and a high-paying job to bring me happiness. All I need is a decent paying job, which you can get even without a degree, and good people to spend my time with.

doanm

If you are in the right place then that 30,000 dollars is only a temporary first year thing. Persistence will get you better positions and higher paychecks as the years pass by. And 30,000 dollars in a first year for people in general is certainly not set in stone. As soon as my brother in law got out of University his first job is paying him $50,000 in the IT industry. Which just so happens to be my degree so yay me(I think). Also on another note, while there is the case of people who don`t need money to derive happiness from, the general case is that people will actually be more happy the more money they have since they can afford more things. While I can`t cite the study on the top of my head, i`ll just tell you that i learned it in one my university classes and that there was actually a study that actually mentioned that.

Also on the note of money going into the pockets of the wealthy upper class. Sure they may get more money, but that money will also likely end up either in the hands of other classes or the government. Money flows and circulates from class to class in general(mind you, not so much in this depression).

My brother got out of college with a degree in geology and was making 60K per year starting. He's been out for a year now, and he's now making it money at a rate equivalent to 100K per year. College = money if you go into the right field.
Avatar image for Paladin_King
Paladin_King

11832

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 13

User Lists: 0

#56 Paladin_King
Member since 2008 • 11832 Posts

[QUOTE="Paladin_King"]1. The tuition is outrageous. Absolutely, unforgivably outrageous. Did you guys know that going to Oxford for a year costs around the equivalent of 10-12 thousand dollars a year for a British kid and about 30,000 a year for an overseas student? Yeah. Now how much does Yale and Harvard (Comparative schools) cost again? Ridiculous.doanm

Here in Canada, I believe the norm to be some where around 5-7k a year Canadian. Ridiculously generous in comparision to you guys for sure considering that i can make a good chunk of that money solely through summer work. People here however will still whine about how the price tag is way too high. To add something else thats interesting: In Germany, I think they used to pay only 500 euro(is that the currency in Germany) per semester. Now its $1000 per semester.

5-7K is actually on the higher side. Perhaps science degrees are most expensive? I know arts/humanities degrees only run between 4-5 thousand a year, and foreign kids pay triple, around 12-15 which is still cheaper than the US The British tuition price is pretty similar. I agree though, I always scoff a bit at the amount of protest Canadian schools get hit with for even attempting a small, 50-100 dollar tuition hike. We have it so freaking good, and it's not as though our universities are any worse than the average American school in quality of education...in fact many are better. Hell, McGill university was just ranked in the top twenty in the world, well above every non-Ivy school.
Avatar image for lilasianwonder
lilasianwonder

5982

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

#57 lilasianwonder
Member since 2007 • 5982 Posts

I hate buying books cause they cost soooo much, you don't get much for selling them back, and if you wait like a year there will be a new edition out so you can't even sell it.

Avatar image for soulless4now
soulless4now

41388

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 5

User Lists: 0

#58 soulless4now
Member since 2003 • 41388 Posts

I think the whole educational system is flawed. >_>

Avatar image for Dark__Link
Dark__Link

32653

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

#59 Dark__Link
Member since 2003 • 32653 Posts

[QUOTE="Dark__Link"][QUOTE="thepwninator"] Where're you at?thepwninator

The big orange "S" doesn't give it away? :( Oh, and I checked, it's $50,700. :(

Didn't even look at your avatar :P

Stanford was my second choice after Caltech. I'm of the opinion that, overall, it's the best university in the US (I think the Ivies are overrated, myself).

Stanford?! It's orange, not red! And I don't see a tree!
Avatar image for thepwninator
thepwninator

8134

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 4

User Lists: 0

#60 thepwninator
Member since 2006 • 8134 Posts
[QUOTE="thepwninator"]

[QUOTE="Dark__Link"] The big orange "S" doesn't give it away? :( Oh, and I checked, it's $50,700. :(Dark__Link

Didn't even look at your avatar :P

Stanford was my second choice after Caltech. I'm of the opinion that, overall, it's the best university in the US (I think the Ivies are overrated, myself).

Stanford?! It's orange, not red! And I don't see a tree!

What is it then? And I'm colorblind, so I wouldn't be able to tell whether it's red or orange anyway :P
Avatar image for Dark__Link
Dark__Link

32653

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

#61 Dark__Link
Member since 2003 • 32653 Posts

[QUOTE="Dark__Link"][QUOTE="thepwninator"] Didn't even look at your avatar :P

Stanford was my second choice after Caltech. I'm of the opinion that, overall, it's the best university in the US (I think the Ivies are overrated, myself).

thepwninator

Stanford?! It's orange, not red! And I don't see a tree!

What is it then? And I'm colorblind, so I wouldn't be able to tell whether it's red or orange anyway :P

Syracuse!!

Avatar image for Mr_Oblivio
Mr_Oblivio

898

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 3

User Lists: 0

#62 Mr_Oblivio
Member since 2007 • 898 Posts

Yeah. flawed or fraud? There's absolutely no reason for a textbook tha is 150 pages long, a paperback, and on a subject nobody cares about to be over $100. Can you say rip off? Also, why the extra charges for people that are out of state? What does it matter where they live, so long as they want to better educate themselves just as much as the person paying less money for living in state.

Avatar image for deactivated-5e376fa88bd45
deactivated-5e376fa88bd45

4403

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 3

User Lists: 0

#63 deactivated-5e376fa88bd45
Member since 2004 • 4403 Posts

Yeah. flawed or fraud? There's absolutely no reason for a textbook tha is 150 pages long, a paperback, and on a subject nobody cares about to be over $100. Can you say rip off?

Mr_Oblivio

To be fair though, its also the quality of the information that matters to which is factored into the cost of the book. It does cost money to have a guy compile a bunch of complex knowledge into something coherent for the layperson to understand after all.(Not always the case with science books though) .

Avatar image for thepwninator
thepwninator

8134

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 4

User Lists: 0

#64 thepwninator
Member since 2006 • 8134 Posts

[QUOTE="thepwninator"][QUOTE="Dark__Link"] Stanford?! It's orange, not red! And I don't see a tree!Dark__Link

What is it then? And I'm colorblind, so I wouldn't be able to tell whether it's red or orange anyway :P

Syracuse!!

Ah. I'm at Rice University, myself.
Avatar image for thepwninator
thepwninator

8134

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 4

User Lists: 0

#65 thepwninator
Member since 2006 • 8134 Posts

[QUOTE="Mr_Oblivio"]

Yeah. flawed or fraud? There's absolutely no reason for a textbook tha is 150 pages long, a paperback, and on a subject nobody cares about to be over $100. Can you say rip off?

doanm

To be fair though, its also the quality of the information that matters to which is factored into the cost of the book. It does cost money to have a guy compile a bunch of complex knowledge into something coherent for the layperson to understand after all.(Not always the case with science books though) .

College textbook authors could very well have fewer than 5000 customers, and considering the amount of research and writing necessary, especially for science books, they need to be expensive just to turn a profit, as publisher take a significant chunk of the income as well.
Avatar image for AnObscureName
AnObscureName

2069

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 1

User Lists: 0

#66 AnObscureName
Member since 2008 • 2069 Posts
Aren't I glad I live in Scotland. Free tuition paid by the English tuition fee payers ftw. Bit unfair but I'm not one not to take full advantage of it (unless I manage to get into Cambridge, which I doubt will happen unless over the next couple of years, I become more involved in extra-curricural activities.)
Avatar image for Mr_Oblivio
Mr_Oblivio

898

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 3

User Lists: 0

#67 Mr_Oblivio
Member since 2007 • 898 Posts

Still, it doesn't help us to have to pay $300-$??? for books per semester when we're alreadyin debt thousands.

Avatar image for Mr_Oblivio
Mr_Oblivio

898

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 3

User Lists: 0

#68 Mr_Oblivio
Member since 2007 • 898 Posts

Aren't I glad I live in Scotland. Free tuition paid by the English tuition fee payers ftw. Bit unfair but I'm not one not to take full advantage of it (unless I manage to get into Cambridge, which I doubt will happen unless over the next couple of years, I become more involved in extra-curricural activities.)AnObscureName

I know a student at my college from scotland, under the circumstances you just state though, why the hell did he come to the U.S. for higher education?