Gandalf v Obi-Wan

Who would you rather have as your mentor? Personally, gandalf killed a balrog, so him. What did Obi-Wan do? die?

Well to be fair they both died...sort of.Sajo7

Neither, it would be Ernest, he went to all kinds of cool places

Who would you rather have as your mentor? Personally, gandalf killed a balrog, so him. What did Obi-Wan do? die?

BossPerson

He came back more powerful than you could possibly imagine. :P

I'm gonna go with Obi-wan. (as much as I love Gandalf... :c )

Qui Gon JinnSandulf29

Neither, it would be Ernest, he went to all kinds of cool places

solidruss

[QUOTE="solidruss"]

Neither, it would be Ernest, he went to all kinds of cool places

xaos

Do I get a few "do-overs"?

Is this even a question? Gandalf

I fear that Gandalf would try to put date rape drugs in my drink, so I'm going to go with Obi-Wan.

I fear that Gandalf would try to put date rape drugs in my drink, so I'm going to go with Obi-Wan.

Diophage

Ya know Obi rolled that way too, just sayin. I heard it from a guy that knows a guy

[QUOTE="xaos"][QUOTE="solidruss"]

Neither, it would be Ernest, he went to all kinds of cool places

solidruss

Do I get a few "do-overs"?

I fear that Gandalf would try to put date rape drugs in my drink, so I'm going to go with Obi-Wan.

Diophage

[QUOTE="Diophage"]

I fear that Gandalf would try to put date rape drugs in my drink, so I'm going to go with Obi-Wan.

solidruss

Ya know Obi rolled that way too, just sayin. I heard it from a guy that knows a guy

Who would I have teach me: Obi-wan.

He's got great track record in terms of powerful students

Who would I rather fight along side with: Gandalf

Good sword fighter, powerful wizard, and can summon giant eagles to his aid

And when he dies, he actually comes back more powerful than you could possibly imagine

[QUOTE="solidruss"]

[QUOTE="xaos"] And to think that I said I liked you better post-TOU revision :(xaos

Do I get a few "do-overs"?

Awesome! *fist pump*

[QUOTE="Diophage"]

I fear that Gandalf would try to put date rape drugs in my drink, so I'm going to go with Obi-Wan.

BossPerson

as a mentor, easily obi-wan.

as a comrade, easily gandalf.

[QUOTE="Sandulf29"]Qui Gon JinnBossPerson

Obi Wan beat Anakin when he was arguably at his peak. BranKetra

in words of wisdom, gandalf easily trumps obi-wan. All those speeches to frodo and pippin? c'mon, gandalf is the ultimate mentor. He also summons dragon killing eagles at command

[QUOTE="BranKetra"]Obi Wan beat Anakin when he was arguably at his peak. Sandulf29

Gandalf, because he's killed a Balrog, came back from the dead, and knows lots of badass spells.

Yoda, the mentor I want is :P

I think Yoda vs Gandalf would be a better comparison.Allicrombie

[QUOTE="Sandulf29"][QUOTE="BranKetra"]Obi Wan beat Anakin when he was arguably at his peak. BranKetra

Yoda is creepySandulf29

alright, how about who would you rather fight? Sidious or the witch king of agmar? (the guy with the spiky mask)

BossPerson

alright, how about who would you rather fight? Sidious or the witch king of agmar? (the guy with the spiky mask)

BossPerson

[QUOTE="BossPerson"]

alright, how about who would you rather fight? Sidious or the witch king of agmar? (the guy with the spiky mask)

Sandulf29