Girls strip 11 y/o boy naked and upload video to youtube; no charges pressed

Nvm. I honestly don't know what to say. I think the boy's mother didn't want to make this bigger than it already was. Very odd though.

Personal opinion aside, for those calling to send/punish the girls severly for their crimes is hypocritical because that too can scar them for life. I know what they did was wrong and they should be punished in a matter most fitting but by the looks of it, it was bad judgement from the girl's side. Also, as for double standards, yes there will always be double standards but here you go: LINK

The girl is being charged as a sex offender. How's that for scarred for life, and how's that for double standards. :? The law goes after everyone.

This whole thing is perplexing though. I don't think there's enough information to establish a well-informed opinion but from what I've seen, those girls should be punished by their parents. Maybe the boy's mother doesn't want this to go too far? This whole thing is messed up.

leviathan91

[QUOTE="WhiteKnight77"]

[QUOTE="Nibroc420"]They recorded a naked 11 year old, and then posted it on the internet. That is production and distribution of child porn. The girls should be charged.Nibroc420

The police didn't see it that way.

After finding out further information about said case (remember that I stated that there are 2 sides to the story), the boy brought it on himself. He was the instigator and suffered the consequences of his actions. Should the girls have posted the video on YouTube? No and I have stated that they didn't use good judgment, but as such, the boy caused his own embarrassment and the police saw it that way.

Normally I would agree that the girls should have been punished, if they were the true perpetrators of a crime, but as they didn't initiate the incident in question, the boy got his just dues.

[QUOTE="leviathan91"]

Personal opinion aside, for those calling to send/punish the girls severly for their crimes is hypocritical because that too can scar them for life. I know what they did was wrong and they should be punished in a matter most fitting but by the looks of it, it was bad judgement from the girl's side. Also, as for double standards, yes there will always be double standards but here you go: LINK

The girl is being charged as a sex offender. How's that for scarred for life, and how's that for double standards. :? The law goes after everyone.

This whole thing is perplexing though. I don't think there's enough information to establish a well-informed opinion but from what I've seen, those girls should be punished by their parents. Maybe the boy's mother doesn't want this to go too far? This whole thing is messed up.

Nibroc420

They're not immune. They did a crime that they could be charged with if the boy's mother wasn't so forgiving. The girls aren't victims but I don't think this has to be bigger than it already is. That's probably the boy's mother's reasoning.

[QUOTE="Nibroc420"][QUOTE="WhiteKnight77"]

The police didn't see it that way.

WhiteKnight77

After finding out further information about said case (remember that I stated that there are 2 sides to the story), the boy brought it on himself. He was the instigator and suffered the consequences of his actions. Should the girls have posted the video on YouTube? No and I have stated that they didn't use good judgment, but as such, the boy caused his own embarrassment and the police saw it that way.

Normally I would agree that the girls should have been punished, if they were the true perpetrators of a crime, but as they didn't initiate the incident in question, the boy got his just dues.

unwanted?

lolz kid wasnt even putting up a fight (;

BiancaDK

[QUOTE="Nibroc420"][QUOTE="WhiteKnight77"]

The police didn't see it that way.

WhiteKnight77

After finding out further information about said case (remember that I stated that there are 2 sides to the story), the boy brought it on himself. He was the instigator and suffered the consequences of his actions. Should the girls have posted the video on YouTube? No and I have stated that they didn't use good judgment, but as such, the boy caused his own embarrassment and the police saw it that way.

Normally I would agree that the girls should have been punished, if they were the true perpetrators of a crime, but as they didn't initiate the incident in question, the boy got his just dues.

[QUOTE="WhiteKnight77"]

[QUOTE="Nibroc420"]And you dont see anything wrong with that? It's pretty obvious what they did was a felony, and if anyone else were to do the same they'd be charged to the full extent of the law, and labeled as sex offenders. No-one is above the law, children or not.gameguy6700

After finding out further information about said case (remember that I stated that there are 2 sides to the story), the boy brought it on himself. He was the instigator and suffered the consequences of his actions. Should the girls have posted the video on YouTube? No and I have stated that they didn't use good judgment, but as such, the boy caused his own embarrassment and the police saw it that way.

Normally I would agree that the girls should have been punished, if they were the true perpetrators of a crime, but as they didn't initiate the incident in question, the boy got his just dues.

I don't know what he did to instigate the incident and I didn't ask (this is a clue as to how I got my information) about what he did. The fact remains, is that he started it and got his just dues. Maybe the kid was being pervy and was trying to pull the girls shorts down, maybe he tried to grab some breasts, I don't know, but he found out the hard way that he should be more careful about his actions when it comes to young teenage girls.

@ Nibroc, maybe they made child porn, but the police didn't see it that way.

@ Nibroc, maybe they made child porn, but the police didn't see it that way.

WhiteKnight77

Maybe? There's no question, they DID and it was on Youtube.
I dont see how the police "Can't see it that way", when it was pretty obviously the case.

Creation of Child porn = Illegal.
Distribution of Child Porn = Illegal.

Yet these girls do both, and nothing happens. A clear example of a corrupt justice system.

[QUOTE="WhiteKnight77"]

@ Nibroc, maybe they made child porn, but the police didn't see it that way.

Nibroc420

Maybe? There's no question, they DID and it was on Youtube.
I dont see how the police "Can't see it that way", when it was pretty obviously the case.

Creation of Child porn = Illegal.
Distribution of Child Porn = Illegal.

Yet these girls do both, and nothing happens. A clear example of a corrupt justice system.

I am just going on what I have been told. They didn't make child porn.

[QUOTE="Nibroc420"]

[QUOTE="WhiteKnight77"]

@ Nibroc, maybe they made child porn, but the police didn't see it that way.

WhiteKnight77

Maybe? There's no question, they DID and it was on Youtube.
I dont see how the police "Can't see it that way", when it was pretty obviously the case.

Creation of Child porn = Illegal.
Distribution of Child Porn = Illegal.

Yet these girls do both, and nothing happens. A clear example of a corrupt justice system.

I am just going on what I have been told. They didn't make child porn.

This type of thing needs to happen in my life.bobcheeseball

agreed.

[QUOTE="Nibroc420"]

[QUOTE="WhiteKnight77"]

@ Nibroc, maybe they made child porn, but the police didn't see it that way.

WhiteKnight77

Maybe? There's no question, they DID and it was on Youtube.
I dont see how the police "Can't see it that way", when it was pretty obviously the case.

Creation of Child porn = Illegal.
Distribution of Child Porn = Illegal.

Yet these girls do both, and nothing happens. A clear example of a corrupt justice system.

I am just going on what I have been told. They didn't make child porn.

2. I'm assuming you're asking other kids about the incident. I wouldn't go off what children say, ESPECIALLY if they're friends of the girls. Hell, even if it's an adult, if they're friends with the families of the girls they're also liable to go with whatever the girls say.

[QUOTE="WhiteKnight77"]

[QUOTE="Nibroc420"]

Maybe? There's no question, they DID and it was on Youtube.

I dont see how the police "Can't see it that way", when it was pretty obviously the case.

Creation of Child porn = Illegal.
Distribution of Child Porn = Illegal.

Yet these girls do both, and nothing happens. A clear example of a corrupt justice system.

gameguy6700

I am just going on what I have been told. They didn't make child porn.

2. I'm assuming you're asking other kids about the incident. I wouldn't go off what children say, ESPECIALLY if they're friends of the girls. Hell, even if it's an adult, if they're friends with the families of the girls they're also liable to go with whatever the girls say.

If you think the police did wrong, call them and make a complaint.

I didn't ask other kids. I live no where near Ft. Myers and I don't know anyone involved. I wanted to make a complaint and found out otherwise (I dropped a big hint in an earlier post about getting information).

Yes, I am aware of teens getting busted for sexting (and have brought such stuff up in the past myself), but as I said, the police saw something different and I didn't ask why. Maybe you could.

Aren't double standards wonderful? :roll:DavidianMH

Were the girls hot...? If so - I'd be ok with this happening to myself.

Were the girls hot...? If so - I'd be ok with this happening to myself.

Buttons1990

Probably not if the most action they get is stripping 11 year olds. Still... I wish this had happened to me.

That's not good. Sounds like nothing else will be done about it though.

ths kid is honeslty a sissy. Number one how do you not fight them off. In my days when girls want to take your clpthes of fyou let them. his mom did the right thing and told hoim to grow some balls.

good lord, you don't file charges for this kind of ****. You don't really file charges for anything kids do, unless it resulted in some sort of physical harm that requires a trip to the emergency room (and, no...a bloody nose is not an emergency).

Just call the parents of the kids that stripped the boy, and they will get so much crap from their parents for what they did, they will never do it again.

Has the world lost all sense of reason? Are we pressing charges for every little offense now?

My god, my parents would have been millionaires 15 years ago had they known you can sue for such bullcrap.

That mother is an idiot. Does she really think parents of kids who do such a thing are going to dish out a proportional punishment???markop2003

they problably will. or not. if the media didnt blow this out of proportion, everything would have worked out fine, but now "principle" and "example" have infected the situation, resulting in a ticking time bomb of drama. The parents of the girls might not punish them simply out of spite, for more publicity, or something else.

just...move along folks.

What is happening to the world? We are acting like a bunch of weak sissies when it comes to our kids, resulting in weak kids, i.e. the kind of kid that can get beat up by a bunch of girls and stripped by them, an not like it. Sounds like heaven to me :P

good lord, you don't file charges for this kind of ****. You don't really file charges for anything kids do, unless it resulted in some sort of physical harm that requires a trip to the emergency room (and, no...a bloody nose is not an emergency).

Just call the parents of the kids that stripped the boy, and they will get so much crap from their parents for what they did, they will never do it again.

Has the world lost all sense of reason? Are we pressing charges for every little offense now?

My god, my parents would have been millionaires 15 years ago had they known you can sue for such bullcrap.

mrbojangles25

[QUOTE="mrbojangles25"]

good lord, you don't file charges for this kind of ****. You don't really file charges for anything kids do, unless it resulted in some sort of physical harm that requires a trip to the emergency room (and, no...a bloody nose is not an emergency).

Just call the parents of the kids that stripped the boy, and they will get so much crap from their parents for what they did, they will never do it again.

Has the world lost all sense of reason? Are we pressing charges for every little offense now?

My god, my parents would have been millionaires 15 years ago had they known you can sue for such bullcrap.

mrmusicman247

oh I dont know...how old were the girls/would the boys be in the hypothetical?

They might just get a harsh lecture and have to explain themselves. I don't think they'd be charged with sexual assault or anything.

[QUOTE="mrbojangles25"]

good lord, you don't file charges for this kind of ****. You don't really file charges for anything kids do, unless it resulted in some sort of physical harm that requires a trip to the emergency room (and, no...a bloody nose is not an emergency).

Just call the parents of the kids that stripped the boy, and they will get so much crap from their parents for what they did, they will never do it again.

Has the world lost all sense of reason? Are we pressing charges for every little offense now?

My god, my parents would have been millionaires 15 years ago had they known you can sue for such bullcrap.

mrmusicman247

did you ever think about the situation. There should never be a situation where little girls can do this to a guy. The double standard exists because guys can easily take advantage of a woman not the other wa aorund.

[QUOTE="mrmusicman247"]

[QUOTE="mrbojangles25"]

good lord, you don't file charges for this kind of ****. You don't really file charges for anything kids do, unless it resulted in some sort of physical harm that requires a trip to the emergency room (and, no...a bloody nose is not an emergency).

Just call the parents of the kids that stripped the boy, and they will get so much crap from their parents for what they did, they will never do it again.

Has the world lost all sense of reason? Are we pressing charges for every little offense now?

My god, my parents would have been millionaires 15 years ago had they known you can sue for such bullcrap.

MoetWitMedusa

did you ever think about the situation. There should never be a situation where little girls can do this to a guy. The double standard exists because guys can easily take advantage of a woman not the other wa aorund.

An online video shows a prank some would say went too far.

Three young girls from Dunbar Middle school videotaped themselves tackling an 11 year old boy and taking off his clothes. The group can be heard laughing at times and mocking the boy as he struggled to break free.

"He stopped to chat with his friend and they thought it would be funny," said the boy's mother.

The child who we are not identifying is a 5Th grader at Ray Pottorf Elementary. His mom says she only found out about the video when her older son, who goes to school with the girls, said his friends had seen the video online.

"You take his clothes off in broad daylight, in the middle of a busy neighborhood and then you post it on YouTube to tell all your friends look at what I did. Crime or not, it shouldn't happen," she added.

Fort Myers Police says the girl would have faced misdemeanor battery charges, but that the boy's mother has refused to press charges. She wants the girls' parents to hand out a punishment instead.

The video has since been removed by YouTube.

Link

This really makes me angry. Had this been a group of boys stripping an 11 year old girl naked they would have all been charged with a felony sex offense and hit with the full fury of the law. The police wouldn't have let the parent decide whether or not to press charges, they would have just filed them anyway. But because it's a group of girls victimizing a boy it's just an innocent prank "gone too far".

gameguy6700

These girls get no punishment, yet when a girl sends herself naked on a picture phone to some boy (not the internet where EVERYONE sees) he gets child pornography charges. That's fair. Makes sense. Hope for American Society - 1Brozekial

"you damn well know that this is child prongoray"

Did anyone read the comments on the article? Some of them are pretty funny.

[QUOTE="mrmusicman247"]

[QUOTE="mrbojangles25"]

good lord, you don't file charges for this kind of ****. You don't really file charges for anything kids do, unless it resulted in some sort of physical harm that requires a trip to the emergency room (and, no...a bloody nose is not an emergency).

Just call the parents of the kids that stripped the boy, and they will get so much crap from their parents for what they did, they will never do it again.

Has the world lost all sense of reason? Are we pressing charges for every little offense now?

My god, my parents would have been millionaires 15 years ago had they known you can sue for such bullcrap.

MoetWitMedusa

did you ever think about the situation. There should never be a situation where little girls can do this to a guy. The double standard exists because guys can easily take advantage of a woman not the other wa aorund.

[QUOTE="Brozekial"]These girls get no punishment, yet when a girl sends herself naked on a picture phone to some boy (not the internet where EVERYONE sees) he gets child pornography charges. That's fair. Makes sense. Hope for American Society - 1whipassmt

[QUOTE="bobaban"]

[QUOTE="DavidianMH"] You can't be turned gay you are born gayDroidPhysX

What's hilarious is that you are trying to refute that what he says is true. I know it's only anecdotal evidence so it's shaky at best as I can offer no proof, and you can choose not to believe me if you'd like, but as a restaurant manager who's cook staff is primarily former prisoners/felons I can tell you that the majority of them have admitted to either being involved in homosexual activity or witnessing it while incarcerated.

[QUOTE="EasyStreet"][QUOTE="Omni-Slash"] oh no..this is when the state should step in..I'm as anti govt as they come....but .the child's best interest is not being represented...this boy will have to go through the rest of his life dealing with this the girls committed a crime....the crime is outside the realm of the mother's control.....where is the line drawn?...do we get to pass on rape and murder charges?...lasseeb

+1 on that

[QUOTE="whipassmt"]

[QUOTE="Brozekial"]These girls get no punishment, yet when a girl sends herself naked on a picture phone to some boy (not the internet where EVERYONE sees) he gets child pornography charges. That's fair. Makes sense. Hope for American Society - 1Brozekial

Nvm. I honestly don't know what to say. I think the boy's mother didn't want to make this bigger than it already was. Very odd though.

leviathan91

well it got posted on youtube how much bigger can it get??

That mother is an idiot. Does she really think parents of kids who do such a thing are going to dish out a proportional punishment???markop2003

good lord, you don't file charges for this kind of ****. You don't really file charges for anything kids do, unless it resulted in some sort of physical harm that requires a trip to the emergency room (and, no...a bloody nose is not an emergency).

Just call the parents of the kids that stripped the boy, and they will get so much crap from their parents for what they did, they will never do it again.

Has the world lost all sense of reason? Are we pressing charges for every little offense now?

My god, my parents would have been millionaires 15 years ago had they known you can sue for such bullcrap.

mrbojangles25

Its not about pressing charges for every offense, the thing is if the roles where reversed and boys stripped a girl naked and posted it on youtube then things wouldnt be okay, they would have a ball and chain the second this would have gotten out.

this may turn him gaybobaban

or worse.

[QUOTE="mrmusicman247"]

[QUOTE="mrbojangles25"]

good lord, you don't file charges for this kind of ****. You don't really file charges for anything kids do, unless it resulted in some sort of physical harm that requires a trip to the emergency room (and, no...a bloody nose is not an emergency).

Just call the parents of the kids that stripped the boy, and they will get so much crap from their parents for what they did, they will never do it again.

Has the world lost all sense of reason? Are we pressing charges for every little offense now?

My god, my parents would have been millionaires 15 years ago had they known you can sue for such bullcrap.

MoetWitMedusa

did you ever think about the situation. There should never be a situation where little girls can do this to a guy. The double standard exists because guys can easily take advantage of a woman not the other wa aorund.

double standards ftw

How on earth did a guy let 3 girls about the same age as him strip him of his clothes. Man up. If that was me I would have either kicked and punched them, or let them strip me then rub up against them in ironic revenge. Come dude, MAN UP!

Plus he had his friends with him. His friends suck ***. Time to get new friends.

How on earth did a guy let 3 girls about the same age as him strip him of his clothes. Man up. If that was me I would have either kicked and punched them, or let them strip me then rub up against them in ironic revenge. Come dude, MAN UP!Diablo-B

[QUOTE="Diablo-B"]How on earth did a guy let 3 girls about the same age as him strip him of his clothes. Man up. If that was me I would have either kicked and punched them, or let them strip me then rub up against them in ironic revenge. Come dude, MAN UP!whipassmt

How on earth did a guy let 3 girls about the same age as him strip him of his clothes. Man up. If that was me I would have either kicked and punched them, or let them strip me then rub up against them in ironic revenge. Come dude, MAN UP!

Plus he had his friends with him. His friends suck ***. Time to get new friends.

Diablo-B

At 11 is there really much difference in strength and with 3 on 1?

[QUOTE="Diablo-B"]

How on earth did a guy let 3 girls about the same age as him strip him of his clothes. Man up. If that was me I would have either kicked and punched them, or let them strip me then rub up against them in ironic revenge. Come dude, MAN UP!

Plus he had his friends with him. His friends suck ***. Time to get new friends.

AutoPilotOn

At 11 is there really much difference in strength and with 3 on 1?