This topic is locked from further discussion.
Ignorance is bliss. Ethically, I'm not sure if there is a way to continue supporting commercially raised/slaughtered animals. If you're going to eat meat, the least you can do is be aware of where it's coming from. chrisrooR
Ethically we should all die to avoid procuring suffering to anything else.
[QUOTE="SolidSnake35"][QUOTE="N30F3N1X"]Why would you support the mistreatment of animals? Are you a psychopath per chance? Because we eat them. If i couldn't go to the supermarket, and buy a few LB's of meat. I'd go hunt Bambi's mother, leaving Bambi to suffer. How's that for mistreatment of animals? We should still treat them humanely... which does not happen.So, where's the part where the rest of us should start feeling concerned?
Nibroc420
No mistakes. You don't care about the mistreatment of animals. If you're shitting your pants about my saying that you therefore support the mistreatment of animals then... carry on?[QUOTE="SolidSnake35"][QUOTE="N30F3N1X"]
Yes, you are definitely missing something, as in some cogs in your brain. You managed to put together a non sequitur and a false dichotomy in a single post, pleb. Now read again and feel ashamed of your stupidity.
Communist_Soul
Really, it's not like they remember it.
They suffer. And if you're saying they don't remember it when they're dead, neither would you...[QUOTE="chrisrooR"]Ignorance is bliss. Ethically, I'm not sure if there is a way to continue supporting commercially raised/slaughtered animals. If you're going to eat meat, the least you can do is be aware of where it's coming from. N30F3N1X
Ethically we should all die to avoid procuring suffering to anything else.
Oh, c'mon. I'm talking about managing the levels of known suffering amongst the animals that can experience it. I'm not advocating everyone be a vegan, or even a vegetarian. What I am saying is that we should all strive to be more mindful consumers. It's definitely in our power to treat the animals we eat humanely before they reach our plate. It just takes education and action. Don't be a dick and take my quote to an extreme I never even hinted at.Oh, c'mon. I'm talking about managing the levels of known suffering amongst the animals that can experience it. I'm not advocating everyone be a vegan, or even a vegetarian. What I am saying is that we should all strive to be more mindful consumers. It's definitely in our power to treat the animals we eat humanely before they reach our plate. It just takes education and action. Don't be a dick and take my quote to an extreme I never even hinted at. chrisrooR
I'm thinking of more practical concerns. How do you suggest we do something like that? And what has the fact that they are raised for commercial purpose to do with what you're saying?
Feel free to not support the food industry. Buy free-roaming, grass-fed meat. You'll have to pay a lot more, but you're saving the poor animals!Guppy507Yeah, they'll be safe. Safely entering my belly.
[QUOTE="Nibroc420"][QUOTE="SolidSnake35"] We should still treat them humanely... which does not happen.chrisrooROur current method of killing animals for meat, is quicker, and less painful than the ways of the past. Plus, as our understanding of medicine and nutrition improves, so do the animals lives. Killing them is faster, that's true. But the commercialized process of keeping them in small enclosures and force feeding them corn byproducts remains the industrial standard.
is that what makes them taste so good?
[QUOTE="chrisrooR"]Oh, c'mon. I'm talking about managing the levels of known suffering amongst the animals that can experience it. I'm not advocating everyone be a vegan, or even a vegetarian. What I am saying is that we should all strive to be more mindful consumers. It's definitely in our power to treat the animals we eat humanely before they reach our plate. It just takes education and action. Don't be a dick and take my quote to an extreme I never even hinted at. N30F3N1X
I'm thinking of more practical concerns. How do you suggest we do something like that? And what has the fact that they are raised for commercial purpose to do with what you're saying?
Commercialized farming usually revolves around high productivity, high yield while keeping the costs associated as low as possible. For the food industry in particular, I think it's important we become increasingly more invested in free roaming farming, allowing the animals more space and grass. Cows have historically never dined solely on corn, yet it's all they're fed. It affects the animals, as well as those who eat the animals meat. I don't think allowing animals a bit more room to move around in is unreasonable.[QUOTE="N30F3N1X"][QUOTE="chrisrooR"]Oh, c'mon. I'm talking about managing the levels of known suffering amongst the animals that can experience it. I'm not advocating everyone be a vegan, or even a vegetarian. What I am saying is that we should all strive to be more mindful consumers. It's definitely in our power to treat the animals we eat humanely before they reach our plate. It just takes education and action. Don't be a dick and take my quote to an extreme I never even hinted at. chrisrooR
I'm thinking of more practical concerns. How do you suggest we do something like that? And what has the fact that they are raised for commercial purpose to do with what you're saying?
Commercialized farming usually revolves around high productivity, high yield while keeping the costs associated as low as possible. For the food industry in particular, I think it's important we become increasingly more invested in free roaming farming, allowing the animals more space and grass. Cows have historically never dined solely on corn, yet it's all they're fed. It affects the animals, as well as those who eat the animals meat. I don't think allowing animals a bit more room to move around in is unreasonable. And now you've made it clear you've never researched this topic.Killing them is faster, that's true. But the commercialized process of keeping them in small enclosures and force feeding them corn byproducts remains the industrial standard.[QUOTE="chrisrooR"][QUOTE="Nibroc420"] Our current method of killing animals for meat, is quicker, and less painful than the ways of the past. Plus, as our understanding of medicine and nutrition improves, so do the animals lives.lostrib
is that what makes them taste so good?
Free range chicken and beef tastes far, far better. Having them in an enclosed area wallowing in their own filth affects them hormonally and developmentally.[QUOTE="chrisrooR"][QUOTE="N30F3N1X"]Commercialized farming usually revolves around high productivity, high yield while keeping the costs associated as low as possible. For the food industry in particular, I think it's important we become increasingly more invested in free roaming farming, allowing the animals more space and grass. Cows have historically never dined solely on corn, yet it's all they're fed. It affects the animals, as well as those who eat the animals meat. I don't think allowing animals a bit more room to move around in is unreasonable. And now you've made it clear you've never researched this topic. You've made nothing clear, considering you've contributed nothing to the discussion.I'm thinking of more practical concerns. How do you suggest we do something like that? And what has the fact that they are raised for commercial purpose to do with what you're saying?
Nibroc420
Commercialized farming usually revolves around high productivity, high yield while keeping the costs associated as low as possible. For the food industry in particular, I think it's important we become increasingly more invested in free roaming farming, allowing the animals more space and grass. Cows have historically never dined solely on corn, yet it's all they're fed. It affects the animals, as well as those who eat the animals meat. I don't think allowing animals a bit more room to move around in is unreasonable.chrisrooR
Have you actually ever been in a farm? Animals don't stay in the stables 24/7 y'know.
So you'll continue to argue that we should spend more money to increase the quality of life of these animals, while children live in even worse conditions than the animals do now. Sure, while we're at it, lets stop medicare, and start feeding animals only the best feed.Nibroc420
Hush, don't give those vegan ****heads more ideas.
[QUOTE="lostrib"][QUOTE="chrisrooR"] Killing them is faster, that's true. But the commercialized process of keeping them in small enclosures and force feeding them corn byproducts remains the industrial standard.chrisrooR
is that what makes them taste so good?
Free range chicken and beef tastes far, far better. Having them in an enclosed area wallowing in their own filth affects them hormonally and developmentally. You clearly haven't been on a farm :| You're watching those documentaries made by vegetarians aren't you? You do realize they put the MOST SHOCKING things in there, not the average farm... It's like watching COPS, they're not going to put standard traffic violations like speeding on TV, they have better footage that will get more viewers. Cows are not fed nothing but corn... and there is no standard for what a farmer can call "free range chickens", just like organic. Unless you live in one of those few states that have created laws, stating that Organic requires the produce has X,Y,Z things, and that you can only call your chickens "free range" if you follow certain standards when raising them, you're simply paying more for the same meat/produce.[QUOTE="chrisrooR"] Commercialized farming usually revolves around high productivity, high yield while keeping the costs associated as low as possible. For the food industry in particular, I think it's important we become increasingly more invested in free roaming farming, allowing the animals more space and grass. Cows have historically never dined solely on corn, yet it's all they're fed. It affects the animals, as well as those who eat the animals meat. I don't think allowing animals a bit more room to move around in is unreasonable.N30F3N1X
Have you actually ever been in a farm? Animals don't stay in the stables 24/7 y'know.
Black Eagle Farm in Virginia. I'm not saying I'm some sort of saint who's above this. I buy and eat meat too. I also am not completely aware of where all of my meat comes from. But I am currently trying to change my eating habits in accordance with what's really going on. With establishments selling low-cost animal products, the poor conditions above are an example of what McDonalds relies on to continue to exist. I honestly don't know if there's a way to change the system, but I've personally become uncomfortable with passively accepting it as it currently is.[QUOTE="chrisrooR"][QUOTE="lostrib"]Free range chicken and beef tastes far, far better. Having them in an enclosed area wallowing in their own filth affects them hormonally and developmentally. You clearly haven't been on a farm :| You're watching those documentaries made by vegetarians aren't you? You do realize they put the MOST SHOCKING things in there, not the average farm... It's like watching COPS, they're not going to put standard traffic violations like speeding on TV, they have better footage that will get more viewers. Cows are not fed nothing but corn... and there is no standard for what a farmer can call "free range chickens", just like organic. Unless you live in one of those few states that have created laws, stating that Organic requires the produce has X,Y,Z things, and that you can only call your chickens "free range" if you follow certain standards when raising them, you're simply paying more for the same meat/produce. Nah, I know those documentaries are full of shit. But I have been in commercial facilities here in Canada, and it's better...but not by a huge margin. I also realize the futility of trying to find actual free-range stuff, considering the standards associated with labeling it as such are really loose. To me, that's not an excuse to continue perpetuating the unnecessary suffering of animals, because it really comes down to "it's tasty". And to respond to the medicare/children post above - Of course I'm not going to put animal lives or suffering above human beings. But I think it's fallacious to think we can only change and focus on one thing at a time. There are many important issues out there, but this thread was specifically engaging the issue of the treatment of animals as a food source.is that what makes them taste so good?
Nibroc420
There are many important issues out there, but this thread was specifically engaging the issue of the treatment of animals as a food source. chrisrooR
And I'm simply pointing out that most of the documentaries way over-exaggerate the issue into something it's not; Often causing people to come out with the same arguements you're making.
"Organic" doesn't mean it's been grown any differently, as there is no standards as to what is "organic" in Canada and most of the USA (not sure about Europe)
The same goes for "free-range", no standards mean anything could be free range. Just write "Organic", or "Free Range" on the packaging, increase price by 50%, and profits soar.
[QUOTE="N30F3N1X"]
[QUOTE="chrisrooR"] Commercialized farming usually revolves around high productivity, high yield while keeping the costs associated as low as possible. For the food industry in particular, I think it's important we become increasingly more invested in free roaming farming, allowing the animals more space and grass. Cows have historically never dined solely on corn, yet it's all they're fed. It affects the animals, as well as those who eat the animals meat. I don't think allowing animals a bit more room to move around in is unreasonable.chrisrooR
Have you actually ever been in a farm? Animals don't stay in the stables 24/7 y'know.
Black Eagle Farm in Virginia. I'm not saying I'm some sort of saint who's above this. I buy and eat meat too. I also am not completely aware of where all of my meat comes from. But I am currently trying to change my eating habits in accordance with what's really going on. With establishments selling low-cost animal products, the poor conditions above are an example of what McDonalds relies on to continue to exist. I honestly don't know if there's a way to change the system, but I've personally become uncomfortable with passively accepting it as it currently is. Agree with you 100%. I eat meat myself, but advocating the ethical treatment of the animals we eat is noble IMO.[QUOTE="chrisrooR"]Black Eagle Farm in Virginia. I'm not saying I'm some sort of saint who's above this. I buy and eat meat too. I also am not completely aware of where all of my meat comes from. But I am currently trying to change my eating habits in accordance with what's really going on. With establishments selling low-cost animal products, the poor conditions above are an example of what McDonalds relies on to continue to exist. I honestly don't know if there's a way to change the system, but I've personally become uncomfortable with passively accepting it as it currently is. Agree with you 100%. I eat meat myself, but advocating the ethical treatment of the animals we eat is noble IMO. Now if only "ethical treatment of animals" was something set in stone, rather than opinions.[QUOTE="N30F3N1X"]
Have you actually ever been in a farm? Animals don't stay in the stables 24/7 y'know.
Renevent42
Black Eagle Farm in Virginia. I'm not saying I'm some sort of saint who's above this. I buy and eat meat too. I also am not completely aware of where all of my meat comes from. But I am currently trying to change my eating habits in accordance with what's really going on. With establishments selling low-cost animal products, the poor conditions above are an example of what McDonalds relies on to continue to exist. I honestly don't know if there's a way to change the system, but I've personally become uncomfortable with passively accepting it as it currently is.chrisrooR
Of course you're not some saint who's above that, otherwise I wouldn't even bother replying.
How do you tell "what's really going on" is in fact what's really going on and not just the occasional rotten apple?
[QUOTE="Renevent42"][QUOTE="chrisrooR"] Black Eagle Farm in Virginia. I'm not saying I'm some sort of saint who's above this. I buy and eat meat too. I also am not completely aware of where all of my meat comes from. But I am currently trying to change my eating habits in accordance with what's really going on. With establishments selling low-cost animal products, the poor conditions above are an example of what McDonalds relies on to continue to exist. I honestly don't know if there's a way to change the system, but I've personally become uncomfortable with passively accepting it as it currently is.Nibroc420Agree with you 100%. I eat meat myself, but advocating the ethical treatment of the animals we eat is noble IMO. Now if only "ethical treatment of animals" was something set in stone, rather than opinions. Well we used to just chop off animal parts as we needed...that wasn't deemed ethical and at some point we (humanity) stopped doing it. It's just an opinion, of course, but I doubt most people would consider that old practice ethical today. So yeah, ethics are "opinions"...but they are based on thoughtful debate and consideration.
Well we used to just chop off animal parts as we needed...that wasn't deemed ethical and at some point we (humanity) stopped doing it. It's just an opinion, of course, but I doubt most people would consider that old practice ethical today. So yeah, ethics are "opinions"...but they are based on thoughtful debate and consideration. Renevent42
So where do we draw the line?
[QUOTE="Renevent42"]Well we used to just chop off animal parts as we needed...that wasn't deemed ethical and at some point we (humanity) stopped doing it. It's just an opinion, of course, but I doubt most people would consider that old practice ethical today. So yeah, ethics are "opinions"...but they are based on thoughtful debate and consideration. N30F3N1X
So where do we draw the line?
There's tons of issues that could be resolved...the issue right now is we caught between profits and ethics. There's room for both, IMO.[QUOTE="N30F3N1X"][QUOTE="Renevent42"]Well we used to just chop off animal parts as we needed...that wasn't deemed ethical and at some point we (humanity) stopped doing it. It's just an opinion, of course, but I doubt most people would consider that old practice ethical today. So yeah, ethics are "opinions"...but they are based on thoughtful debate and consideration. Renevent42
So where do we draw the line?
There's tons of issues that could be resolved...the issue right now is we caught between profits and ethics. There's room for both, IMO. That's not answering the question.There's tons of issues that could be resolved...the issue right now is we caught between profits and ethics. There's room for both, IMO. Renevent42
Is mistreatment a standard? Or a minority? How can we even tell who we are giving money to? And why does the desire to "stop the mistreatment" stop at animals that are raised for food?
[QUOTE="Renevent42"][QUOTE="N30F3N1X"]There's tons of issues that could be resolved...the issue right now is we caught between profits and ethics. There's room for both, IMO. That's not answering the question.So where do we draw the line?
Nibroc420
Your question is irrelevant...the "line" is something that has shifted many times throughout human history based on evolving ethics and beliefs. These beliefs are based in large on how a society views animals and/or reactions to certain actions and activities.
So for you maybe animals living miserable lives in tiny boxes or filthy windowless warehouses is acceptable for the sake of maximum production, profits, and $1 hamburgers is ethical. I don't think it is, and I think we can raise animals for food without having to resort to this type of abuse.
So that's what the ethical debate is today...that's what the folks advocating the ethical treatment of farm animals are mostly trying to get accross.
So for you maybe animals living miserable lives in tiny boxes or filthy windowless warehouses is acceptable for the sake of maximum production, profits, and $1 hamburgers is ethical. I don't think it is, and I think we can raise animals for food without having to resort to this type of abuse.
Renevent42
Truth is, most farms arent like that, unless we're talking Veal.
The documentaries you watch go to hundreds of different farms for footage, and show the most horrific, because it futhers their agenda by increasing the shock value of the movie.
[QUOTE="Renevent42"]
So for you maybe animals living miserable lives in tiny boxes or filthy windowless warehouses is acceptable for the sake of maximum production, profits, and $1 hamburgers is ethical. I don't think it is, and I think we can raise animals for food without having to resort to this type of abuse.
Nibroc420
Truth is, most farms arent like that, unless we're talking Veal.
The documentaries you watch go to hundreds of different farms for footage, and show the most horrific, because it futhers their agenda by increasing the shock value of the movie.
At this point in time, that is. Those factory farms are growing, though, which is why people are fighting so hard to change things. If you look at the farming industry just 50-75 years ago things have changed drastically and of course they will continue to change over time. I think that's why it's important to have these types of things out front and center so we as a society can decide.
At this point in time, that is. Those factory farms are growing, though, which is why people are fighting so hard to change things. If you look at the farming industry just 50-75 years ago things have changed drastically and of course they will continue to change over time. I think that's why it's important to have these types of things out front and center so we as a society can decide. Renevent42
Those factory farms are growing? Got any numbers to back that up?
I'd say people are "fighting so hard" because we are in the age of everything is entitled to rights and everything's worth bitching about.
[QUOTE="Nibroc420"]
[QUOTE="Renevent42"]
So for you maybe animals living miserable lives in tiny boxes or filthy windowless warehouses is acceptable for the sake of maximum production, profits, and $1 hamburgers is ethical. I don't think it is, and I think we can raise animals for food without having to resort to this type of abuse.
Renevent42
Truth is, most farms arent like that, unless we're talking Veal.
The documentaries you watch go to hundreds of different farms for footage, and show the most horrific, because it futhers their agenda by increasing the shock value of the movie.
At this point in time, that is. Those factory farms are growing, though, which is why people are fighting so hard to change things. If you look at the farming industry just 50-75 years ago things have changed drastically and of course they will continue to change over time. I think that's why it's important to have these types of things out front and center so we as a society can decide.
Either back up your claims with legit sources and numbers, or accept the fact you're wrong. You've watched one too many anti-meat documentaries.[QUOTE="Renevent42"] At this point in time, that is. Those factory farms are growing, though, which is why people are fighting so hard to change things. If you look at the farming industry just 50-75 years ago things have changed drastically and of course they will continue to change over time. I think that's why it's important to have these types of things out front and center so we as a society can decide. N30F3N1X
Those factory farms are growing? Got any numbers to back that up?
I'd say people are "fighting so hard" because we are in the age of everything is entitled to rights and everything's worth bitching about.
:lol: It's not even some well kept secret or anything...the USDA has these statistics. Factory farms are growing, as well is the number of corporate owned/operated farms vs family owned farms. Since the 1950's farming has become increasingly industrialized. I actually work in the ag business, BTW.[QUOTE="Renevent42"][QUOTE="Nibroc420"]
Truth is, most farms arent like that, unless we're talking Veal.
The documentaries you watch go to hundreds of different farms for footage, and show the most horrific, because it futhers their agenda by increasing the shock value of the movie.
Nibroc420
At this point in time, that is. Those factory farms are growing, though, which is why people are fighting so hard to change things. If you look at the farming industry just 50-75 years ago things have changed drastically and of course they will continue to change over time. I think that's why it's important to have these types of things out front and center so we as a society can decide.
Either back up your claims with legit sources and numbers, or accept the fact you're wrong. You've watched one too many anti-meat documentaries.How about you back up your claim that factory farms aren't growing?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Factory_farming
" In 1990 factory farming accounted for 30% of world meat production.[15] By 2005 this had risen to 40%.[16]"
Either back up your claims with legit sources and numbers, or accept the fact you're wrong. You've watched one too many anti-meat documentaries. How about you back up your claim that factory farms represent the minority?[QUOTE="Nibroc420"][QUOTE="Renevent42"]
At this point in time, that is. Those factory farms are growing, though, which is why people are fighting so hard to change things. If you look at the farming industry just 50-75 years ago things have changed drastically and of course they will continue to change over time. I think that's why it's important to have these types of things out front and center so we as a society can decide.
Renevent42
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Factory_farming
:lol: You realize it's possible to view the edits to that page right? Ahh Wikipedia, the source where you edit the page to fit your assumptions.[QUOTE="Renevent42"]How about you back up your claim that factory farms represent the minority?[QUOTE="Nibroc420"] Either back up your claims with legit sources and numbers, or accept the fact you're wrong. You've watched one too many anti-meat documentaries.Nibroc420
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Factory_farming
:lol: You realize it's possible to view the edits to that page right? Ahh Wikipedia, the source where you edit the page to fit your assumptions. I just offered evidence, can you offer any evidence that factory farms are in fact, not growing?[QUOTE="Nibroc420"][QUOTE="Renevent42"] How about you back up your claim that factory farms represent the minority?:lol: You realize it's possible to view the edits to that page right? Ahh Wikipedia, the source where you edit the page to fit your assumptions. I just offered evidence, can you offer any evidence that factory farms are in fact, not growing? I never claimed they were not growing. I'm simply asking for evidence that they're all as bad as you claim. I know the media likes to show the worst of the worst, while generalizing an entire industry, I'm simply curious if you've actually researched this, or if you're blindly believing what the anti-meat documentaries have been feeding you.http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Factory_farming
Renevent42
:lol: It's not even some well kept secret or anything...the USDA has these statistics. Factory farms are growing, as well is the number of corporate owned/operated farms vs family owned farms. Since the 1950's farming has become increasingly industrialized. I actually work in the ag business, BTW.Renevent42
Maybe I should've worded that better. Factory farms may be growing and USDA has numbers about it, where does any of it say animals being mistreated is an increasing trend?
we are fruit eater/plant eaters
nobody eat raw meat just like omnivores,carnivors
the vegan meat is from the same source people create breadyomanjdf
We can eat raw meat, it's just not as healthy nor tasty as cooked meat. And besides how come we can't digest fibers? More bullshit pls
thats the "truth" about animal farming
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PhqP8yOkouUyomanjdf
Fix'd
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment