Because of the video, pretty much. It's a fittingly thoroughly depressing video that fits the song perfectly. Also, I think people just liked it better by default for a while because it was newer. Then of course Cash died and we all know that also causes a temporary surge in popularity of the works of most entertainers. For a week or two afterward everyone was suddenly a Johnny Cash fan, am I right? :P Incidentally, Reznor himself said something to the effect of him liking Cash's version better (also after seeing the video if I recall correctly).
Nope. As much as I like Trent Reznors version, Johnny Cash gave that song an intangible wisdom and powerful meaning that Trent could never bring. You can feel the pain and remorse when Johnny Cash sings that song.
Nope. As much as I like Trent Reznors version, Johnny Cash gave that song an intangible wisdom and powerful meaning that Trent could never bring. You can feel the pain and remorse when Johnny Cash sings that song.
warbmxjohn
Agreed. There is an ancient, somber "earthen" tone to Cash when he sings it. I even like his decision to change the onecurse word to "Thorns". It fit Cash's style better.
I prefer NIN's version from a relative standpoint, that is, I identify more with it. However, considering the poignancy of Cash's version so close to his death, it's an equally powerful way of depressing the hell outta yourself.
While i have since moved on at the time hurt was released NIN was my favorite band,so believe me i love the song by trent. But I love Johnnys version also. Other than doing it in his musical style,cash did not change anything,all he did was add a couple more decades of pain and experience tio an already great song.
Same. I don't think Cash's version would've had as much impact had he done it when he was younger. But because he was in the twilight of his career, and because of the type of history he had, it made his version very deep and haunting. The words felt like they we're his. ( well except the crown of thorns part...boo:P) That said, the original is still solid, and a great song to play when feeling down.
Log in to comment