If you think Lady Gaga has no talent look here.

[QUOTE="svenus97"][QUOTE="DmadFearmonger"]

She's a crappy Piano player...

I know of Pianists, vocalists and songwriters who put that crap to absolute shame

DmadFearmonger

Keyboard, same instrument but superior. I don't see your pointDmadFearmonger

There's this oneDmadFearmonger

[QUOTE="DmadFearmonger"]Keyboard, same instrument but superior. I don't see your pointBrutal_Elitegs

There's this oneDmadFearmonger

Just gonna point ot that the Piece has a really, really dull name

thoroughly enjoyed that song, favourited it, so thanks for linking. (:

[QUOTE="Brutal_Elitegs"]

[QUOTE="DmadFearmonger"] [QUOTE="DmadFearmonger"]There's this oneDmadFearmonger

Just gonna point ot that the Piece has a really, really dull name

I find it hilarious how everyone, at least before this thread devolved into piano vs. keyboard, was talking about how if all of Gaga's songs were like this they would listen, without realizing that this is currently the top single from her new album. And then it became "well, that one is just pop garbage, this one is deeper" without realizing that the only difference between this version and the album one is that this one used only a piano. Funny how kids who complain about others having crap musical taste will eat up anything as artsy as long as it uses cIassical instruments.gameguy6700

Haha, no. It's not.

How does she play the piano with finger nails like that :|

Haha, no. It's not.

DmadFearmonger

I really think you should listen to a wider range of music, your limiting yourself greatly.

[QUOTE="DmadFearmonger"]

Haha, no. It's not.

tenaka2

I really think you should listen to a wider range of music, your limiting yourself greatly.

Edge of Glory was a boring song.

Although she looks hot in it.

[QUOTE="tenaka2"]

[QUOTE="DmadFearmonger"]

Haha, no. It's not.

DmadFearmonger

I really think you should listen to a wider range of music, your limiting yourself greatly.

If your into unusual vocals try Dead Can Dance, or just Lisa Gerrards solo stuff.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wessHCA12gM&feature=list_related&playnext=1&list=PL01ADFB2349C302B2

or this one

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QJhVM930YXY&feature=related

He's brilliant no doubt. But he's not the worlds greatest DmadFearmonger

You could reproduce that on just about any good Keyboard.DmadFearmonger

[QUOTE="DmadFearmonger"]He's brilliant no doubt. But he's not the worlds greatest Lonelynight

[QUOTE="DmadFearmonger"]You could reproduce that on just about any good Keyboard.Lonelynight

[QUOTE="DmadFearmonger"][QUOTE="tenaka2"]

I really think you should listen to a wider range of music, your limiting yourself greatly.

tenaka2

If your into unusual vocals try Dead Can Dance, or just Lisa Gerrards solo stuff.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wessHCA12gM&feature=list_related&playnext=1&list=PL01ADFB2349C302B2

or this one

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QJhVM930YXY&feature=related

[QUOTE="tenaka2"]

[QUOTE="DmadFearmonger"]I listen to plenty of different forms of music. What do you suggest I listen to?DmadFearmonger

If your into unusual vocals try Dead Can Dance, or just Lisa Gerrards solo stuff.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wessHCA12gM&feature=list_related&playnext=1&list=PL01ADFB2349C302B2

or this one

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QJhVM930YXY&feature=related

At least you tried, its a start.

[QUOTE="Lonelynight"][QUOTE="DmadFearmonger"]You could reproduce that on just about any good Keyboard.DmadFearmonger

[QUOTE="Lonelynight"][QUOTE="DmadFearmonger"]You could reproduce that on just about any good Keyboard.DmadFearmonger

there really is a world of difference, not being elitist here, but there is

not sure of why you cannot hear it

[QUOTE="Lonelynight"][QUOTE="DmadFearmonger"]You could reproduce that on just about any good Keyboard.DmadFearmonger

there really is a world of difference, not being elitist here, but there is

not sure of why you cannot hear it

BiancaDK

It is called dysmusia.

[QUOTE="Lonelynight"][QUOTE="DmadFearmonger"]What do you mean? Just put it on the Piano setting. Is there really that much of a difference?DmadFearmonger

A Piano is a Piano.

A Keyboard is just a thing that shouldn't exist.

But I'm pretty sure there are Keyboards that have Piano settings that sound identical to a good ol' Grand PianoDmadFearmonger

She's a fantastic singer, but she also knows her GaGa persona will sell albums. Like people have said, a nice voice isn't good enough these days.

[QUOTE="DmadFearmonger"]But I'm pretty sure there are Keyboards that have Piano settings that sound identical to a good ol' Grand PianoLonelynight

A lot better than what I can do..

She's so awesome.

brb, listening to Born this Way.

[QUOTE="Lonelynight"][QUOTE="DmadFearmonger"]What do you mean? Just put it on the Piano setting. Is there really that much of a difference?DmadFearmonger

Lady gaga lol... You can know how to sing amazing like the noobs at American Idol, you can know how to play an instrument really well, and you can still be a talentless muscisian with no soul. Anyone that sings cliché MTV bubblegum mainstream trash gets no credit from me. Lady Gaga is the definition of that.

Lady gaga lol... You can know how to sing amazing like the noobs at American Idol, you can know how to play an instrument really well, and you can still be a talentless muscisian with no soul. Anyone that sings cliché MTV bubblegum mainstream trash gets no credit from me. Lady Gaga is the definition of that.

DrWin

[QUOTE="DrWin"]

Lady gaga lol... You can know how to sing amazing like the noobs at American Idol, you can know how to play an instrument really well, and you can still be a talentless muscisian with no soul. Anyone that sings cliché MTV bubblegum mainstream trash gets no credit from me. Lady Gaga is the definition of that.

mrmusicman247

[QUOTE="Apocalypse33"][QUOTE="Mega-Mustaine"]

What? This specific version? Or that autotune-ridden version that all the kiddies eat up?

Mega-Mustaine

I hope you're kidding... Lady Gaga most definitely uses autotune. The fact that she's a very prominent figure for using it doesn't help your arguement.

In fact, I haven't heard all of born this way yet, but I think most songs don't use it for the for any main vocals.

[QUOTE="DmadFearmonger"][QUOTE="Lonelynight"] yes... if they were, why would people still make acoustic pianos?megagene

There's a difference between recreating the pitch and the note, which a keyboard can do, and recreating the overall sound of the insrument

I thought it would be ke$ha...

It is anyways :x

I think lady gaga has a great voice but need to stop acting so gay :x

How can a woman be a gay man? I don't know, she just is...

[QUOTE="UCF_Knight"]Surprised she hasn't quit her job at the post office yet, since you know.. she's still a male lady. JustPlainLucas

shes a women... 100%.. I know..

[QUOTE="Apocalypse33"][QUOTE="Mega-Mustaine"]

Sadly, this is true. However, if Gaga made more music like this, I would might actually start listening to her stuff. I mean, the only thing bad about this song is the lyrics, really.

Of course, like you said, this kind of music does not sell. Anyone who's been alive for 10+ years should realize this.

Bloodseeker23

lol no it's not, it's baracka flocka flame

Edge of Glory was a boring song.

Although she looks hot in it.

Lto_thaG

Disagree and then agree :P.

She's a fantastic singer, but she also knows her GaGa persona will sell albums. Like people have said, a nice voice isn't good enough these days.

yokofox33

Which is kinda unfortunate.