In your opinion, which band is more "Legendary" Pink Floyd or Led Zepp

Neither. They are both mainstream bands with legions of fans.LJS9502_basic

Pink Floyd isn't mainstream.

[QUOTE="LJS9502_basic"]Neither. They are both mainstream bands with legions of fans.Hopkins_J

Pink Floyd isn't mainstream.

[QUOTE="LJS9502_basic"]Neither. They are both mainstream bands with legions of fans.Hopkins_J

Pink Floyd isn't mainstream.

Um.....that is wrong. Very much so and played on the radio with regularity since inception.

Neither. They are both mainstream bands with legions of fans.LJS9502_basic

Which makes them bad? And did the thread not just ask which one is more legendary?

[QUOTE="LJS9502_basic"]Neither. They are both mainstream bands with legions of fans.Ninja-Vox

Which makes them bad? And did the thread not just ask which one is more legendary?

[QUOTE="Hopkins_J"]

[QUOTE="LJS9502_basic"]Neither. They are both mainstream bands with legions of fans.LJS9502_basic

Pink Floyd isn't mainstream.

Um.....that is wrong. Very much so and played on the radio with regularity since inception.

I bet you didn't know that Stairway to Heaven is the most played song on the radio.

[QUOTE="LJS9502_basic"]Neither. They are both mainstream bands with legions of fans.Hopkins_J

Pink Floyd isn't mainstream.

I bet you didn't know that Stairway to Heaven is the most played song on the radio.

Hopkins_J

[QUOTE="LJS9502_basic"]Neither. They are both mainstream bands with legions of fans.Hopkins_J

Pink Floyd isn't mainstream.

[QUOTE="LJS9502_basic"][QUOTE="Hopkins_J"]

[QUOTE="LJS9502_basic"]Neither. They are both mainstream bands with legions of fans.Hopkins_J

Pink Floyd isn't mainstream.

Um.....that is wrong. Very much so and played on the radio with regularity since inception.

I bet you didn't know that Stairway to Heaven is the most played song on the radio.

:lol: And that means Pink Floyd isn't mainstream.

[QUOTE="Ninja-Vox"]

[QUOTE="LJS9502_basic"]Neither. They are both mainstream bands with legions of fans.LJS9502_basic

Which makes them bad? And did the thread not just ask which one is more legendary?

LJS, do you still deny that The Cure is mainstream? That was always funny.

Your do know that the definition of legendary is well known or famous right?darksword1123

And neither of those bands is more legendary than the other. You do know what that means...right?

LJS, do you still deny that The Cure is mainstream? That was always funny.

MoonSpoon

Wasn't what I actually said however. ;)

[QUOTE="Hopkins_J"][QUOTE="LJS9502_basic"][QUOTE="Hopkins_J"]

[QUOTE="LJS9502_basic"]Neither. They are both mainstream bands with legions of fans.LJS9502_basic

Pink Floyd isn't mainstream.

Um.....that is wrong. Very much so and played on the radio with regularity since inception.

I bet you didn't know that Stairway to Heaven is the most played song on the radio.

:lol: And that means Pink Floyd isn't mainstream.

Your sarcasm enthralled me.

Your sarcasm enthralled me.

Hopkins_J

Not my fault the conclusion lacked logic.

[QUOTE="darksword1123"] Your do know that the definition of legendary is well known or famous right?LJS9502_basic

And neither of those bands is more legendary than the other. You do know what that means...right?

[QUOTE="Ninja-Vox"]

[QUOTE="LJS9502_basic"]Neither. They are both mainstream bands with legions of fans.LJS9502_basic

Which makes them bad? And did the thread not just ask which one is more legendary?

Amma just saying what does them being mainstream and having fans have to do with either being more legendary than the other?

[QUOTE="LJS9502_basic"][QUOTE="darksword1123"] Your do know that the definition of legendary is well known or famous right?darksword1123

And neither of those bands is more legendary than the other. You do know what that means...right?

Not really. Considering the longevity and fans they have both sustained...neither is more legendary than the other.

[QUOTE="LJS9502_basic"][QUOTE="darksword1123"] Your do know that the definition of legendary is well known or famous right?darksword1123

And neither of those bands is more legendary than the other. You do know what that means...right?

[QUOTE="Hopkins_J"]

Your sarcasm enthralled me.

LJS9502_basic

Not my fault the conclusion lacked logic.

You know, your a funny guy.

Amma just saying what does them being mainstream and having fans have to do with either being more legendary than the other?

Ninja-Vox

Because they are both equal in that department...

[QUOTE="Ninja-Vox"]

Amma just saying what does them being mainstream and having fans have to do with either being more legendary than the other?

LJS9502_basic

Because they are both equal in that department...

Then why didn't you say that in the first place?

Then why didn't you say that in the first place?

Hopkins_J

I did.;)

It seemed to me like you were saying:

question: which of these bands is more legendary?

Answer: Neither. They're both just mainstream and not deserving of the title legendary. You know like when someone says "hey i love led zeppelin" and there's always that guy who takes the high-road and says "meh... mainstream..." I thought you were saying that neither band is legendary; as opposed to "neither is more legendary than the other" which would have been a little clearer.

If i misinterpreted i apologise. If you were indeed just saying that they both have equal numbers of hype and fans, that's fine. On this forum however where everyone seems to consider themselves grand overlord of musical taste, it's often natural to interpret things as hostility when it could be a simple comment.

[QUOTE="LJS9502_basic"][QUOTE="Ninja-Vox"]

Amma just saying what does them being mainstream and having fans have to do with either being more legendary than the other?

Hopkins_J

Because they are both equal in that department...

Then why didn't you say that in the first place?

Neither. They are both mainstream bands with legions of fans.LJS9502_basic

[QUOTE="LJS9502_basic"][QUOTE="Ninja-Vox"]

Amma just saying what does them being mainstream and having fans have to do with either being more legendary than the other?

Hopkins_J

Because they are both equal in that department...

Then why didn't you say that in the first place?

I think he did, it was just a little unclear. You could interpret "neither" as "neither are legendary" or "neither is more legendary than the other."

It seemed to me like you were saying:

question: which of these bands is more legendary?

Answer: Neither. They're both just mainstream and not deserving of the title legendary. You know like when someone says "hey i love led zeppelin" and there's always that guy who takes the high-road and says "meh... mainstream..." I thought you were saying that neither band is legendary; as opposed to "neither is more legendary than the other" which would have been a little clearer.

If i misinterpreted i apologise. If you were indeed just saying that they both have equal numbers of hype and fans, that's fine. On this forum however where everyone seems to consider themselves grand overlord of musical taste, it's often natural to interpret things as hostility when it could be a simple comment.

Ninja-Vox

I would have used the word "just" if that were my intent.:|

I would have used the word "just" if that were my intent.:|

LJS9502_basic

Hence why i said i apologised if i had misinterpreted the post.

:|

Well, fine, fine, fine!

Why come into this thread and say "nethier"

I mean what's the point?

Well, fine, fine, fine!

Why come into this thread and say "nethier"

I mean what's the point?

Hopkins_J

Giving an answer to the question? :|

[QUOTE="darksword1123"][QUOTE="LJS9502_basic"][QUOTE="darksword1123"] Your do know that the definition of legendary is well known or famous right?LJS9502_basic

And neither of those bands is more legendary than the other. You do know what that means...right?

Not really. Considering the longevity and fans they have both sustained...neither is more legendary than the other.

Well, fine, fine, fine!

Why come into this thread and say "nethier"

I mean what's the point?

Hopkins_J

You asked....I answered. And totally in an unbiased fanboy way.