Damn right it is wish you were here was boring IMO...I usually get flamed everytime I post that opinion lol. Wish You Were Here is epic and emotional. Dark Side of the Moon drags on... and on... and on
careful with that axe eugene, set the controls for the heart of the sun, dogs, echoes, shine on you crazy diamond. all tied for their best song.
it saddens me that most people are soo into PF's mainstream non prog songs, PF's best work is their early work and Animals + shine on you crazy diamond.
[QUOTE="cousin_eddy"][QUOTE="DivergeUnify"] Damn right it isDivergeUnify
wish you were here was boring IMO...I usually get flamed everytime I post that opinion lol. Wish You Were Here is epic and emotional. Dark Side of the Moon drags on... and on... and on IMO the three albums in that era starting with wish you were here and ending with the wall are complete rubbish..never could get into any of them. I personally love dark side of the moon but that is just me...i guess you could say I dont like wish you were here especially as much because I cant stand syd barrett.
[QUOTE="DivergeUnify"][QUOTE="cousin_eddy"] wish you were here was boring IMO...I usually get flamed everytime I post that opinion lol.cousin_eddy
Wish You Were Here is epic and emotional. Dark Side of the Moon drags on... and on... and on IMO the three albums in that era starting with wish you were here and ending with the wall are complete rubbish..never could get into any of them. I personally love dark side of the moon but that is just me...i guess you could say I dont like wish you were here especially as much because I cant stand syd barrett.
That means you don't like Dark Side of The Moon and The Wall then. :?:P
careful with that axe eugene, set the controls for the heart of the sun, dogs, echoes, shine on you crazy diamond. all tied for their best song.
it saddens me that most people are soo into PF's mainstream non prog songs, PF's best work is their early work and Animals + shine on you crazy diamond.
nimatoad2000
Animals is really good as well. However, their albums before Dark Side of the Moon were mostly psychedelic, not prog
[QUOTE="cousin_eddy"][QUOTE="DivergeUnify"] Wish You Were Here is epic and emotional. Dark Side of the Moon drags on... and on... and onghoklebutter
IMO the three albums in that era starting with wish you were here and ending with the wall are complete rubbish..never could get into any of them. I personally love dark side of the moon but that is just me...i guess you could say I dont like wish you were here especially as much because I cant stand syd barrett.
That means you don't like Dark Side of The Moon and The Wall then. :?:P
I love dark side of the moon, the only albums I cant stand are WWYH animals and the wall. I can not have any tolerance for syd barrett but still love the albums he wasn't even on. Syd barrett is one of the most overrated talents..ever IMO but not as bad as roger waters..who is complete rubbish.
careful with that axe eugene, set the controls for the heart of the sun, dogs, echoes, shine on you crazy diamond. all tied for their best song.
it saddens me that most people are soo into PF's mainstream non prog songs, PF's best work is their early work and Animals + shine on you crazy diamond.
Animals is really good as well. However, their albums before Dark Side of the Moon were mostly psychedelic, not prog its classified as psycodelic / prog rock.
[QUOTE="cousin_eddy"] IMO the three albums in that era starting with wish you were here and ending with the wall are complete rubbish..never could get into any of them. I personally love dark side of the moon but that is just me...i guess you could say I dont like wish you were here especially as much because I cant stand syd barrett.cousin_eddy
That means you don't like Dark Side of The Moon and The Wall then. :?:P
I love dark side of the moon, the only albums I cant stand are WWYH animals and the wall. I can not have any tolerance for syd barrett but still love the albums he wasn't even on. Syd barrett is one of the most overrated talents..ever IMO but not as bad as roger waters..who is complete rubbish. Frank Zappa is overrated.
[QUOTE="cousin_eddy"][QUOTE="DivergeUnify"] Wish You Were Here is epic and emotional. Dark Side of the Moon drags on... and on... and onghoklebutter
IMO the three albums in that era starting with wish you were here and ending with the wall are complete rubbish..never could get into any of them. I personally love dark side of the moon but that is just me...i guess you could say I dont like wish you were here especially as much because I cant stand syd barrett.
That means you don't like Dark Side of The Moon and The Wall then. :?:P
darkside of the moon and the wall of their weakest albums, the least experimental, the least progressive, only the final cut is worse.. but .. that album really is just roget waters solo. better to be forgotten.
That means you don't like Dark Side of The Moon and The Wall then. :?:P
Rikardur
I love dark side of the moon, the only albums I cant stand are WWYH animals and the wall. I can not have any tolerance for syd barrett but still love the albums he wasn't even on. Syd barrett is one of the most overrated talents..ever IMO but not as bad as roger waters..who is complete rubbish. Frank Zappa is overrated.
to each their own, unlike most I dont get offended by opinions :lol: Zappa is a musical genius and I never listen to any naysayers.
[QUOTE="Rikardur"][QUOTE="cousin_eddy"] I love dark side of the moon, the only albums I cant stand are WWYH animals and the wall. I can not have any tolerance for syd barrett but still love the albums he wasn't even on. Syd barrett is one of the most overrated talents..ever IMO but not as bad as roger waters..who is complete rubbish.cousin_eddy
Frank Zappa is overrated.
to each their own, unlike most I dont get offended by opinions :lol: Zappa is a musical genius and I never listen to any naysayers.
Neither do I. I just felt I had to throw out the overrated card like you did.
[QUOTE="nimatoad2000"] Probably because the band later became a prog band. Their earlier stuff is undeniably more psychedelic than progressive DivergeUnify
umm.. the only prog album of their later stuff is animals, the only other prog song is shine on you crazy diamond out of post darkside. darkside and the wall arnt prog at all. songs that are undoubledly prog pre darkside - astronomie dominie, interstellar overdrive, pretty much all of saucerful minus corporal cleg and maybee another, ummaguma, atom heart mother the song, and the rest of the album is pretty experimental and good, more, obscured by clouds, one of these days. a band / album / song can be prog and psychodelic at once, their are different catagories of prog rock / metal.
Log in to comment