Pink Floyd or Porcupine Tree?

They're both progressive rock bands, and I do like both, but I like Pink Floyd more. What about you guys?

This can't be a serious question...Floyd.

This can't be a serious question...Floyd.

Pirate700

[QUOTE="Pirate700"]

This can't be a serious question...Floyd.

ArmoredCore55

Floyd, no contest for me.

[QUOTE="ArmoredCore55"][QUOTE="Pirate700"]

This can't be a serious question...Floyd.

Pirate700

Floyd, no contest

You know, I've heard of PT and whatnot but I've never really gotten into their music, anybody mind linking some of their really good songs so I can get a taste? Pink Floyd is marvelous though.Im_single

Stupid Dream

Youtube these:

The Creator Has a Mastertape

Heartattack In A Lay By

Where We Would Be

Arriving Somewhere But Not Here

Way Out Of Here

in that link I gave you go to album selections and put on Voyage 34. It's an experience worth your time to zone out.

[QUOTE="Im_single"]You know, I've heard of PT and whatnot but I've never really gotten into their music, anybody mind linking some of their really good songs so I can get a taste? Pink Floyd is marvelous though.Nifty_Shark

Stupid Dream

Both are pretty terrible.xTheExploited

Porcupine Tree for me, but thats just because I've never really listened to Pink Floyd.

I'll work on that when I get some money.

Both are pretty terrible.xTheExploited

[QUOTE="xTheExploited"]Both are pretty terrible.ArmoredCore55

No no. This isn't the fair approach cause I know the point of this is wait in the bushes eyeing the bands he lists and as soon as you target a nu metal or pop punk band you unleash your attack. Those arguments aren't fair though to me.

[QUOTE="xTheExploited"]Both are pretty terrible.ArmoredCore55

[QUOTE="xTheExploited"]Both are pretty terrible.Guppy507

This can't be a serious question...Floyd.

Pirate700

I've never really got into PF as hard as I've tried it just doens't do it for me. PT is amazing though.

[QUOTE="ArmoredCore55"][QUOTE="xTheExploited"]Both are pretty terrible.Darth-Caedus

[QUOTE="Guppy507"][QUOTE="xTheExploited"]Both are pretty terrible.testfactor888

I'll have to go with Porcupine Tree.

That's not to say Pink Floyd is bad, it's just Porcupine Tree is better. :P

The only Pink Floyd song I like is High Hopes and my god I ****in love that song! I'm guessing I'd feel the same about Porcupine Tree.

I love both, Pink Floyd if I was forced to choose.

Oh but Cynic > both:P.

Oh but Cynic > both:P.St_JimmyX

The only Pink Floyd song I like is High Hopes and my god I ****in love that song! I'm guessing I'd feel the same about Porcupine Tree.

haggard_korn

Considering they're my favorite band, Pink Floyd.

Thankfully Roger Waters is coming around my area like 3 times, gotta hit up atleast one, if the ticket prices aren't outrageous.

[QUOTE="St_JimmyX"]Oh but Cynic > both:P.Darth-Caedus

[QUOTE="Darth-Caedus"][QUOTE="St_JimmyX"]Oh but Cynic > both:P.ArmoredCore55

[QUOTE="haggard_korn"]

The only Pink Floyd song I like is High Hopes and my god I ****in love that song! I'm guessing I'd feel the same about Porcupine Tree.

ArmoredCore55

I'm not sure. My dad is a huge Pink Floyd fan and we used to always listen to them during long car rides. High Hopes is the only song that ever stood out enough for me to ask him the name of it.

I love both, but still....Pink Floyd on top.

Going to have to go with Porcupine Tree. I think they just sound better.aaronmullan

Haven't heard anything by Porcupine Tree, but I do love Pink Floyd...

[QUOTE="aaronmullan"]Going to have to go with Porcupine Tree. I think they just sound better.ArmoredCore55

Haven't herd anything by Porcupine Tree, but I do love Pink Floyd...super_mario_128