[QUOTE="gameguy6700"]
[QUOTE="StripTheSoul"]
Clannad/AfterStory (****is sad)
Velocitas8
I have to disagree with this.
!!!WARNING: MASSIVE SPOILERS BELOW! DO NOT READ IF YOU HAVEN'T FINISHED AFTER STORY!!!
Would have put this in spoiler quotes except GS gives me an "HTML not well-formed" error if I do. So this will have to suffice. Again, massive spoilers lie ahead for anyone who hasn't finished Clannad: After Story so quit reading now or forever have the entire series ruined.
Clannad: After Story had the most disasterous ending I've ever seen. I was stunned at how just how damaging one episode could be to a series. If you only watch up to episode 21 then yeah, the "ending" is superb. But episode 22 just **** all over everything the series had been building up to at that point. All of the hardship since episode 17? Gone. All of immense leaps in character development Okazaki had made since Nagisa died? Gone. The bittersweet reunion of father and daughter? Gone. The beautifully tragic ending of episode 21? Never happened. Pretty much that entire last arc was rendered pointless by the last episode which is a shame seeing as it was by and far the best arc the series had.
Now yes, I'm aware of Clannad's timeline and how that arc really did happen and how Okazaki died, went to the other world as the robot, then got sent back, collected the orbs this time around, and made a wish. While that does mitigate a lot of the damage the ending did (at least it wasn't the inexplicable deus ex machina it seems like the first time you watch it), it doesn't change the fact that we get hit with a reset ending. Basically the writers went too far, chickened out, and made up a Disney ending (although granted that is Key's typical way of ending their visual novels).
This is to say nothing of the fact that the last third of the episode is pure filler, and annoying filler at that. It was bad enough that we had to listen to Fuko for seven minutes, but for half of that time to be spent with her forcing her sister to say the same damn line over and over again was too much. I found myself screaming at the show to just move the hell on and show us whatever it was that it was building up to.
!!! END SPOILERS !!!
Going to have to agree.
The ending doesn't work for the anime because, as I said above: it doesn't make sense outside the context of the visual novel.
It's still a great series, but they should've altered the storyline somehow for the anime adaptation just so it didn't have to end as it did. Now I played the visual novel before I saw the anime (so I knew what was going to happen), but people were saying that the ending in the anime felt really cheap which, stepping back, I can completely understand.
How different is the VN from the show? I have it installed on my PC but I haven't gotten through too much of it since it's pretty much like reading the show right now. I know there's multiiple paths and multiple endings, but I'm also aware that in order to unlock after story you have to play through it enough times to unlock all the paths which I seriously can't see myself doing if the VN doesn't have some very worthwhile differences from the anime.
Log in to comment