So to the people who didn't like the Watchmen film and read the graphic novel...

...do you think you would have liked it more if you didn't read the graphic novel and just viewed it as a film not film adaption?

I prefer the ending in the book, but I still love the film

I still have yet to read the graphic novel.

I wouldn't have been as disappointed as I was but I don't think I would have thought it was a better film. Infact, if I hadn't read the graphic novel prior to watching the movie I reckon I would have been totally lost :P The film is kind of a structural mess.

I wouldn't have been as disappointed as I was but I don't think I would have thought it was a better film. Infact, if I hadn't read the graphic novel prior to watching the movie I reckon I would have been totally lost :P The film is kind of a structural mess.

Forever_Changes

I never read the graphic novel but i watched the movie. I was alittle lost but it was good.

I prefer the ending in the book, but I still love the film

kate_jones

while not as great as the book (ofcourse)

I still love the movie. infact...i liked the ending of the movie more then the book.

there were some problems in the movie, but all the good things just out weighted it for me, so i loved it. there are afew things i think the movie even did better then the book

The graphic novel is better, but I still liked the movie enough even though it had its faults.

I didn't really like the graphic novel much either, so no.

Loved the graphic novel

Hated the movie