Star Wars vs. Lord of the Rings

FOTR: 4, TTT: 2, ROTK: 11/11. 11 wins out of 11 nominations is pretty amazing in my book.

blackngold29

And again, (how to phrase this)Return of the King is the only film that got a lot of nominations and won all of them...ok, Titanic got 15 nominations, but only won 11 of them, Ben Hur got 17 nominations but only won 11 of them...those three are the top three movies for Oscar wins. Not that that matters I guess...

I hated the acting and dialogue use in the newer SW. They tried to make funny remarks at times when it shouldn't be funny. Peter Jackson, I think, did a great job making the viewer feel the tone of the movie.

I hated the acting and dialogue use in the newer SW. They tried to make funny remarks at times when it shouldn't be funny. Peter Jackson, I think, did a great job making the viewer feel the tone of the movie.

Witchking111111

especiallly the special extended editions.

tolkien's world is deeper and full of better stories. then again, i do like fantasy more than sci-fi anyway.

Well I wouldn't say the Star Wars universe is deeper than LOTR's..I mean Tolkien created an entire history and world that is alluded to within his books, and there are other books in the LOTR universe, while Star Wars is just Star Wars with stuff added on by other people (like the other universe books /comics / games...)

Anyhow Star Wars IV was awesome, the rest were 'meh' and LOTOR 1 was AMAZING and the rest pretty much sucked.... LOTR I > SW IV...

Well I wouldn't say the Star Wars universe is deeper than LOTR's..I mean Tolkien created an entire history and world that is alluded to within his books, and there are other books in the LOTR universe, while Star Wars is just Star Wars with stuff added on by other people (like the other universe books /comics / games...)

Anyhow Star Wars IV was awesome, the rest were 'meh' and LOTOR 1 was AMAZING and the rest pretty much sucked.... LOTR I > SW IV...

TallicaFan2005

watch the special extended editions... that should change your mind. each adds between 30-45 minuted to the movie. adds like an hour to the rotk.

Star Wars, the acting in LOTR felt really weak at timesmaccer101

how?...

Star Wars, the acting in LOTR felt really weak at timesmaccer101

You know Hayden Christensen (Or however you spell his second name) who played Anakin , was an awful actor.The acting in LOTR is far superior to that of Star Wars (at least the new ones)

I prefer LOTR by the way.