Star Wars vs LOTR

IMO LOTR

I picked Star Wars because it has V.

I picked Lord of the Rings since I find them to be over all better than the original trilogy, and better than the prequel trilogy by a mile. Though if this was including the EU of Starwars, I'd pick that without hesitation.

Star Wars, by far, and anyone saying otherwise are just wrong.

LOTRs are better movies but I'm still going with Star Wars.

It seems wrong to compare two series that are completely different. I love them both.

LotR is vastly superior as far as movies go, plus I like the fantasy sci-fi genre better than future sci-fi. But Star Wars is a classic that will be remembered for ages. I like both almost equally.

If I must choose, I would pick LOTR, just because overall as a movie its better, and my bias toward the fantasy theme :P

I love them both.

I refuse to choose.

I love them both.

I refuse to choose.

Netherscourge

It's silly to compare the two.

i dont like sci fi so the answer is kinda obvious

I even didnt watched Star wars so I will pick LOTR which is one of my best movies.GIMLI ftw

LOTR trilogy is far better in all mediums- much richer lore, better written characters and just more awesome.

Both are great, but if I had to pick which one I'd rather watch right now it'd be a LOTR film.

LOTR trilogy is far better in all mediums- much richer lore, better written characters and just more awesome.

iloverikku11

I don't quite understand what the voting is for. But I vote Star Wars.

In terms of writing, comparing Tolkien to Lucas is like comparing a tank to a toothpick. No contest.Allicrombie

[QUOTE="iloverikku11"]

LOTR trilogy is far better in all mediums- much richer lore, better written characters and just more awesome.

Deihjan

Lord of the Rings novel. The movies are way better than Star Wars; though it is fairly close.

Star Wars. The Force is more attractive than hobbits.."|

lord of the rings, and frankly, it's not even close for me.

Star Wars trilogy: 8/10
lotr: 10/10 (they are my favrouite movies of all time)

[QUOTE="Deihjan"][QUOTE="iloverikku11"]

LOTR trilogy is far better in all mediums- much richer lore, better written characters and just more awesome.

Allicrombie

[QUOTE="Allicrombie"][QUOTE="Deihjan"] Plus George Lucas has a problem with fleshing out his characters and worlds, instead he fills his universe with aliens we can't remember the names of.mitu123

Probably?

LotR is vastly superior as far as movies go, plus I like the fantasy sci-fi genre better than future sci-fi. But Star Wars is a classic that will be remembered for ages. I like both almost equally.

If I must choose, I would pick LOTR, just because overall as a movie its better, and my bias toward the fantasy theme :P

KamuiFei

Hard to compare the 2, but Star Wars seems to have deeper content in it, through comic books, games, etc.

The Lord of the Rings by a country mile.

[QUOTE="mitu123"][QUOTE="Allicrombie"] mee'sa Jar Jar Binks! =PBlackDevil99

Probably?

[QUOTE="KamuiFei"]

LotR is vastly superior as far as movies go, plus I like the fantasy sci-fi genre better than future sci-fi. But Star Wars is a classic that will be remembered for ages. I like both almost equally.

If I must choose, I would pick LOTR, just because overall as a movie its better, and my bias toward the fantasy theme :P

hydralisk86

Hard to compare the 2, but Star Wars seems to have deeper content in it, through comic books, games, etc.

[QUOTE="mitu123"][QUOTE="Allicrombie"] mee'sa Jar Jar Binks! =PBlackDevil99

Probably?

[QUOTE="hydralisk86"]

[QUOTE="KamuiFei"]

LotR is vastly superior as far as movies go, plus I like the fantasy sci-fi genre better than future sci-fi. But Star Wars is a classic that will be remembered for ages. I like both almost equally.

If I must choose, I would pick LOTR, just because overall as a movie its better, and my bias toward the fantasy theme :P

Allicrombie

Hard to compare the 2, but Star Wars seems to have deeper content in it, through comic books, games, etc.

Example, different aspects of the force, weapons, ships and fighters, alien races, planets, etc.

[QUOTE="hydralisk86"]

[QUOTE="KamuiFei"]

LotR is vastly superior as far as movies go, plus I like the fantasy sci-fi genre better than future sci-fi. But Star Wars is a classic that will be remembered for ages. I like both almost equally.

If I must choose, I would pick LOTR, just because overall as a movie its better, and my bias toward the fantasy theme :P

Allicrombie

Hard to compare the 2, but Star Wars seems to have deeper content in it, through comic books, games, etc.

agree

Star Wars... Although Return of The King was much better than Return of The Jedi imo.

i like both but star wars is much much better in every aspect!

Lord of the Rings. The Star Wars prequels are freaking terrible.

[QUOTE="BlackDevil99"]

[QUOTE="mitu123"] Probably the worst character in the series.hydralisk86

Probably?

[QUOTE="Allicrombie"][QUOTE="hydralisk86"] It's not future Sci-fi, it's in the past because in the beginning of every Star Wars movie, it says, "A long, long ago, in a galaxy far, far away..."

Hard to compare the 2, but Star Wars seems to have deeper content in it, through comic books, games, etc.

hydralisk86

Example, different aspects of the force, weapons, ships and fighters, alien races, planets, etc.

LOTR has pretty much the same amount content aside from the books and movies than Start Wars (minus crappy cartoon and otherstaight to DVD movies).