Star Wars Vs. Star Trek.

I'd love an explanation of how people think a movie based series and a tv show based series are directly compatible....oh well, off to bed.Memberino

Both.

But if I had to choose, it would be STAR TREK by far. Ignoring the putrid JJ Abrams film, I would say the franchise has been somewhat consistant.

SW Episodes I-II-III killed it for me, in many ways.

[QUOTE="ContraQueen"]

[QUOTE="Iantheone"]Star Trek TNG>Star Wars>Rest of Star TrekMemberino

I completely agree. Star Trek TNG is highly superior.

And I never was into Battlestar Galactica but I just started watching it recently.

Star Trek. I've seen about 90% of the VOY & TNG series. As well as about 50% of DS9 and ENT. All the movies as well. I remember back in HS I read through both editions of the encyclopedia and I frequently visit the Memory Alpha website to look stuff up for kicks.

Nothing agianst Star Wars I rlly like that too. I just never got into it as much as the Trek. I find SW a little too much fantasy with the Force powers and light saber battles. It's a little too much like magic hocus pocus stuff for me. The Trek seems, more realistic? I guess that's why I have always liked it more.

Star Wars, i never got into Star Trek. Just seemed a little naff to me but each to their own =]

Iv'e never seen a single episode of either.

Star Wars for sure!

Star Trek by a mile. Never really got into Star Wars all that much. Sure, I liked it when I was a child, but it doesn't hold up at all when viewed objectively at an older age. That, and the new movies were so bad they kind of tainted the older series for me. Trek, on the other hand, never gets old for me. Even Voyager and Enterprise (to a much lesser degree) had their strong points.

Jean-Luc Picard: Best Captain EVER.

/comic book guy voice

Jean-Luc Picard: Best Captain EVER.

drochnathair

Star wars of course!

Star Trek.

looks like Star Wars is winning big time.jediknight52501

i like science fiction a bit more than fantasy so i have to go with star trek.

tbo ST vs. SW is a terrible comparison.

they are not even remotely in the same category.

looks like Star Wars is winning big time.jediknight52501

I think more ppl in general like SW over ST. Reading through the posts though it seems that there are more dedicated ST fans, here on GS at least.

Star Trek, because of this man right here

I demand for a exterminatus of this thread for not including Warhammer 40k.

That's a tough one. I couldn't decide. I like the Trek series and (some)movies and I like the Star Wars movies and universe.

I demand for a exterminatus of this thread for not including Warhammer 40k.

sSubZerOo

Blood for the blood god! Skulls for the skull throne!!

I like Star Trek better although I prefer the interconnected universe and timeline of ST: TNG-DS9-Voyager. I like consistency such as when Starfleet changed uniform styles in First Contact. DS9 followed and then Voyager once they reestablished contact with the Federation.

Star Trek. Plinkett ruined the entirety of Star Wars for me (except the unadulterated original trilogy, that is still a science-fiction masterpiece; shame it is almost completely unavailable anywhere... and oh my did Han shoot first... hell, Greedo didn't even GET to shoot, lol).

Though, Plinkett did ruin the Generations-on movies for me as well... I can still appreciate TOS, TNG and VOY and I to VI for what they are.

Star Wars is winning the poll but Star Trek is winning the post war.jediknight52501

Star Wars is infantile compared to Star Trek.

I think that, in general, I prefer Star Trek over Star Wars. Star Trek is more sophisticated and seemingly more mature.

*Walks in to topic*

Mass Effect..

*Walks out*

*Walks in to topic*

Mass Effect..

*Walks out*

dreman999

I'd rank Mass Effect at the same level as Star Trek. Mature and sophisticated.