How do scientists know that it's erupted 3 times over the past 2.1 million years? Anyone able to clarify this for me? I don't doubt that it has, but how exactly do they know this fact?
This topic is locked from further discussion.
Rock type and stratification analysis. When magma cools it forms igneous rock. Rock that is formed through sedimentation is called sedimentary rock.How do scientists know that it's erupted 3 times over the past 2.1 million years? Anyone able to clarify this for me? I don't doubt that it has, but how exactly do they know this fact?
zmbi_gmr
[QUOTE="XileLord"]Why do you think? I know it's because of the 2012 Mayan calender BS, it's just irritating to hear bad things always having to happen then. Wonder what the next date people will say after 2012 goes by.....I'm guessing 2020.Why does everybody always pick 2012 as the date when bad things are supposed to happen?
-Big_Red-
This is the new(?) news: Yellowstone Has Bulged as Magma Pocket Swells
But yea, it could blow anytime...
brandojones
"Scientists think a swelling magma reservoir four to six miles (seven to ten kilometers) below the surface is driving the uplift. Fortunately, the surge doesn't seem to herald an imminent catastrophe, Smith said." (emph. added)
That doesn't exactly sound like "it could blow anytime".
It's a thing that only happens every 600 million years. We're all going to die. Why not die this way.[QUOTE="l4dak47"][QUOTE="Atmanix"]
In what way would it be cool?
spawnassasin
because i wanna live to the rip old age of 100 maybe 90 but burning to death or suffocating due to toxic fumes does not sound like a good way to die
What if the volcano is going to erupt when you are 95?Rock type and stratification analysis. When magma cools it forms igneous rock. Rock that is formed through sedimentation is called sedimentary rock.[QUOTE="zmbi_gmr"]
How do scientists know that it's erupted 3 times over the past 2.1 million years? Anyone able to clarify this for me? I don't doubt that it has, but how exactly do they know this fact?
BumFluff122
Must be a very percise analysis to determine the number of eruptions over such a long period of time. Blows my mind honestly.
Why do you think? I know it's because of the 2012 Mayan calender BS, it's just irritating to hear bad things always having to happen then. Wonder what the next date people will say after 2012 goes by.....I'm guessing 2020. More likely 2015. But well see.[QUOTE="-Big_Red-"][QUOTE="XileLord"]
Why does everybody always pick 2012 as the date when bad things are supposed to happen?
XileLord
If it happens approximately every 600 million years, then it's not really going to happen anytime soon most likely. Even if it was 40 million years behind schedule, that's still be like only 8% behind schedule.
And I guess this pat of the article was completely ignored.
"But once we saw [the magma] was at a depth of ten kilometers, we weren't so concerned. If it had been at depths of two or three kilometers [one or two miles], we'd have been a lot more concerned."
"Fortunately, the surge doesn't seem to herald an imminent catastrophe."
Rock type and stratification analysis. When magma cools it forms igneous rock. Rock that is formed through sedimentation is called sedimentary rock.[QUOTE="BumFluff122"]
[QUOTE="zmbi_gmr"]
How do scientists know that it's erupted 3 times over the past 2.1 million years? Anyone able to clarify this for me? I don't doubt that it has, but how exactly do they know this fact?
zmbi_gmr
Must be a very percise analysis to determine the number of eruptions over such a long period of time. Blows my mind honestly.
I on't think a precise analysis is needed. ll you need to do i take a core of rock and look at the diferences in the lyers.This is an example of rock stratification
If it happens approximately every 600 million years, then it's not really going to happen anytime soon most likely. Even if it was 40 million years behind schedule, that's still be like only 8% behind schedule.
And I guess this pat of the article was completely ignored.
"But once we saw [the magma] was at a depth of ten kilometers, we weren't so concerned. If it had been at depths of two or three kilometers [one or two miles], we'd have been a lot more concerned."
"Fortunately, the surge doesn't seem to herald an imminent catastrophe."
StealthMonkey4
Why would someone let facts stand in the way of fear!? :o
arosols usually stay in the atmosphere for 3 or 4 years at most. It would still be enough to cause mass devastation on Earth though.It would be a global disaster since the ashes will block out the sun for a hell of a lot of years
DanteSuikoden
arosols usually stay in the atmosphere for 3 or 4 years at most. It would still be enough to cause mass devastation on Earth though.[QUOTE="DanteSuikoden"]
It would be a global disaster since the ashes will block out the sun for a hell of a lot of years
BumFluff122
BumFluff! \o/
arosols usually stay in the atmosphere for 3 or 4 years at most. It would still be enough to cause mass devastation on Earth though.[QUOTE="BumFluff122"]
[QUOTE="DanteSuikoden"]
It would be a global disaster since the ashes will block out the sun for a hell of a lot of years
Atmanix
BumFluff! \o/
hello :)[QUOTE="brandojones"]
This is the new(?) news: Yellowstone Has Bulged as Magma Pocket Swells
But yea, it could blow anytime...
GabuEx
"Scientists think a swelling magma reservoir four to six miles (seven to ten kilometers) below the surface is driving the uplift. Fortunately, the surge doesn't seem to herald an imminent catastrophe, Smith said." (emph. added)
That doesn't exactly sound like "it could blow anytime".
I mean "anytime" as in a couple of years or a couple of hundred years. Also, just because it doesn't 'seem' like it would happen soon doesn't mean it won't.
[QUOTE="GabuEx"]
[QUOTE="brandojones"]
This is the new(?) news: Yellowstone Has Bulged as Magma Pocket Swells
But yea, it could blow anytime...
brandojones
"Scientists think a swelling magma reservoir four to six miles (seven to ten kilometers) below the surface is driving the uplift. Fortunately, the surge doesn't seem to herald an imminent catastrophe, Smith said." (emph. added)
That doesn't exactly sound like "it could blow anytime".
I mean "anytime" as in a couple of years or a couple of hundred years. Also, just because it doesn't 'seem' like it would happen soon doesn't mean it won't.
This a huge amount of years we're talking about here, 600 million, just because it's 40 million overdue doesn't mean it's likely to erupt anytime soon, it's very unlikely it'll erupt anytime even within the next few million, it doesn't appear close to erupting and it's already 40 million years behind schedule, I doubt another few thousand will change anything. I mean, sure, it could happen, but so could a random asteroid strike us and kill every single person on Earth, or a nuclear holocaust, but both of these events are extremely unlikely, and a super volcano eruption is even less likely.
There was a recent story about a far away star (almost the size of our sun) that is going to implode soon.BrianB0422I hate to nitpick but the star is much much bigger than the sun (if it was in place of ours it would go further than the asteroid belt). on topic: i dont think it would be too fun
[QUOTE="brandojones"]
[QUOTE="GabuEx"]
"Scientists think a swelling magma reservoir four to six miles (seven to ten kilometers) below the surface is driving the uplift. Fortunately, the surge doesn't seem to herald an imminent catastrophe, Smith said." (emph. added)
That doesn't exactly sound like "it could blow anytime".
StealthMonkey4
I mean "anytime" as in a couple of years or a couple of hundred years. Also, just because it doesn't 'seem' like it would happen soon doesn't mean it won't.
This a huge amount of years we're talking about here, 600 million, just because it's 40 million overdue doesn't mean it's likely to erupt anytime soon, it's very unlikely it'll erupt anytime even within the next few million, it doesn't appear close to erupting and it's already 40 million years behind schedule, I doubt another few thousand will change anything. I mean, sure, it could happen, but so could a random asteroid strike us and kill every single person on Earth, or a nuclear holocaust, but both of these events are extremely unlikely, and a super volcano eruption is even less likely.
It last erupted 640,000 years ago. Maybe you misread something...
not million. thouasand. so theres a good chance for it to happen in our life time. and no it will just affect half of america and some parts of canada. mostly due to the toxic air[QUOTE="HaloReachGOTY"]
[QUOTE="cjek"]Yellowstone could erupt tomorrow, or it could erupt in millions of years. Nobody knows, but the danger has always been there and always will be. And besides, it's likely that North America wouldn't be the only place affected; it would be a global disaster.worlock77
No, a volcanic eruption of that size would effect the entire planet.
Correct. I remember from history class, when Krakatoa erupted in the 1800s, the ash blocked out the sun across the whole world and temperatures plummeted. The coldest temperatures ever still come from that era. I am sure that with today's tech, if something like this happened, they would figure some way to disperse the ash, the same way they figured how to fix the oil spill.[QUOTE="StealthMonkey4"]
[QUOTE="brandojones"]
I mean "anytime" as in a couple of years or a couple of hundred years. Also, just because it doesn't 'seem' like it would happen soon doesn't mean it won't.
brandojones
This a huge amount of years we're talking about here, 600 million, just because it's 40 million overdue doesn't mean it's likely to erupt anytime soon, it's very unlikely it'll erupt anytime even within the next few million, it doesn't appear close to erupting and it's already 40 million years behind schedule, I doubt another few thousand will change anything. I mean, sure, it could happen, but so could a random asteroid strike us and kill every single person on Earth, or a nuclear holocaust, but both of these events are extremely unlikely, and a super volcano eruption is even less likely.
It last erupted 640,000 years ago. Maybe you misread something...
I guess I got the article confused with what TC said (he said it erupts every 600 million years), either way, what I said is still true, I really doubt it poses any threat at all, at least during any of our lifetimes.
It wouldn't destroy America lol. Life will get very interesting over here, that's for sure. Global cooling will be in effect and then Al Gore can make a movie about that and make millions.Happens every 600 million years. super volcano
good luck america lol
im going to guess it will happen 2012. thoughts?HaloReachGOTY
[QUOTE="BrianB0422"]There was a recent story about a far away star (almost the size of our sun) that is going to implode soon.xsynthI hate to nitpick but the star is much much bigger than the sun (if it was in place of ours it would go further than the asteroid belt). on topic: i dont think it would be too fun And if it hasn't imploded already then we'll never see it!
i dont know. its the first i ever heard of it. CNN was making a big deal about it and brought in Dr. michio kaku to talk about it.[QUOTE="SeraphimGoddess"]This isn't a breaking development by a long shot. Thoughts: If it blows, bummer. If it doesn't, cool.HaloReachGOTY
The Yellowstone caldera is a very well-known supervolcano. You are correct in saying that it is overdue for a major eruption, based on the geological record. Yes, it would be a major global disaster.
[QUOTE="worlock77"][QUOTE="HaloReachGOTY"]not million. thouasand. so theres a good chance for it to happen in our life time. and no it will just affect half of america and some parts of canada. mostly due to the toxic air
taylor888
No, a volcanic eruption of that size would effect the entire planet.
Correct. I remember from history class, when Krakatoa erupted in the 1800s, the ash blocked out the sun across the whole world and temperatures plummeted. The coldest temperatures ever still come from that era. I am sure that with today's tech, if something like this happened, they would figure some way to disperse the ash, the same way they figured how to fix the oil spill.Yes... Fixed the oil spill...
Correct. I remember from history class, when Krakatoa erupted in the 1800s, the ash blocked out the sun across the whole world and temperatures plummeted. The coldest temperatures ever still come from that era. I am sure that with today's tech, if something like this happened, they would figure some way to disperse the ash, the same way they figured how to fix the oil spill.[QUOTE="taylor888"][QUOTE="worlock77"]
No, a volcanic eruption of that size would effect the entire planet.
mattbbpl
Yes... Fixed the oil spill...
I had the same reaction. The oil spill wasn't fixed. It was hidden beneath the surface.
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment