[QUOTE="black_cat19"][QUOTE="nimatoad2000"] read the list of what they did right now. itll not take more than 3 minutes. just go down to what experiments they did. i have not heard anything even close to this magnitude. goth_bacon
Hmm, you're right, that didn't take long.
Somehow I still feel killing and torturing people because of ideology is less justifiable than doing so for experimentation. Don't get me wrong, both are horrible and disgusting, but it's just the sheer stupidity of the Inquisition's motives that make their actions worse than the Unit's in my eyes.
I see what you mean. But personally, I think Unit 731 was worse. Because Unit 731's experiments were just so inhumane and systematic. It had absolutely no regard for the subjects and had only the goal in mind. It was pragmatic and machine-like. Meanwhile, the Inquisition tortured and killed in the name of God. Sure, that's unacceptable today, but in their eyes, God is the ultimate power and anything done in his name is justified. And they believed the people being persecuted were devil worshippers, witches, etc: in their view, the greatest evils. They didn't know better. On the other hand, Unit 731 has no justification. I think it does. Unit 731 was simply the triumph of cold science over ethics, and their experiments were that way because that's how science operates. It's just like experimentation on animals, cold science only cares about gathering data and then decoding that data to get results, until ethics come into the picture and remind us that as human beings we can't forsake the well-being of the subjects just for the sake of results.
It's the same with the inquisition, the triumph of dogma over freedom. They are equally inhumane and pragmatic, it's just that pure science has that quality of cold detatchment that seems so unnatural to us as human beings, and I bet if the inquisition had had the kind of resources the Unit was granted, the ensuing brutality would have been just as appaling.
I just think the Inquisition is less justifiable because they just killed people over lack of tolerance, while the unit, even if arguably more inhumane, killed people to gather data and achieve scientific results, so in the end, it is the Inquisition that comes off as killing people for no justifiable reason. At least that's what I think.
Log in to comment