Tobey VS Andrew VS Tom, who is better spidey?

Tobey>Tom>Andrew.

Well?

Funnily enough, my ranking is the exact opposite of yours. Even though I thought Spider-Man 2 was the best Spider-Man movie ever, I thought it was in spite of Tobey Maguire rather than because of him. I thought he was short on Spidey's trademark humour and overplayed the emotional-wreck kid angle a bit.

In contrast, the Amazing Spider-Man movies sucked, but Andrew Garfield was consistently the sole highlight of that mess. I haven't seen Homecoming yet, so I could only judge Tom Holland on Civil War. I thought he was pretty good.

That said, one thing Holland's Spidey has in clear crushing advantage is his Aunt May. Marisa Tomei is freaking hot.

Holland > Toby >>>>>>>> Garfield

Holland > Tobey > Garfield

Holland>Tobey>Garfield...I haven't seen Homecoming yet..but do own Civil War...Spidey was pretty good in that movie..hehehe..I will be buying Homecoming once its release on BD. :P I own the 3 Tobey Spidey movies on DVDs..& only 1 Garfield Spidey movie on Bluray..didn't get his second one movie. :P

I can't stand Tobey with his mouth slightly agape, doe eyed stare at MJ. I swear, all I wanted to do through his Spider-Man movies was smack that look off his face.

I didn't mind Holland.....liked Garfield.....Maguire just wasn't spidey.

Holland was in the best movie and that goes a long way

Garfield>Maguire

I haven't seen Homecoming yet.

Haven't seen Homecoming yet, but out of the other two, Garfield was a better Spidey than Maguire.

But at the same time, Maguire was in the best Spidey movie, Spider-Man 2. And that movie worked so well because of Maguire.

I'd really like to see a woman play the role. Maybe a transwoman. Black. Bisexual.

@indzman: Toby by a landslide.

2nd spiderman was unbelievable and the new one in homecoming and the Avengers movie is also to unbelievable

Toby was the most accurate Peter Parker

Indeed :)

I don't know whether I should laugh or take you seriously. So Spidergirl or Spiderwoman?

But the least accurate Spider-Man.

It can be either...on Monday she's spiderwoman...on tuesday he's spiderman..cause you know gender is fluid. :P

Exactly, and she dumps Mary Jane for Harry because she's Bi.

Tom Holland for me. Mostly because I prefer teenage spider-man than college-age spider-man stories. I don't think anybody could do better at being teenage-y spider-man as Tom Holland. That dude has awkwardness distilled to an essence. It is almost cringey.

It does makes me wonder how he would do an adult spider-man down the line. I just can't see him pull it off though. Grown-up spider-man has a different nuisance to his character than teenage spider-man.