'Under God' should be in the pledge twice.

  • 62 results
  • 1
  • 2

This topic is locked from further discussion.

Avatar image for Anamosa41
Anamosa41

3594

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 7

User Lists: 0

#51 Anamosa41
Member since 2006 • 3594 Posts
[QUOTE="LS07"]

[QUOTE="Anamosa41"][QUOTE="CptJSparrow"][QUOTE="Anamosa41"][QUOTE="CptJSparrow"]One is already unconstitutional.CptJSparrow

Can you explain how it is unconstitutional? The constitution itself mentions God many times.

You obviously have never read the Constitution of the United States of America or the Bill of Rights, as they nowhere mention the word 'God' and the Establishment Clause of First Amendment to the Constitution of the United States of America expressly states that Congress is not permitted to make any law respecting an establishment of religion, creating an excessive entanglement of government and religion, and every law must have a legitimate secular purpose. Congress added the words "under God" to the Pledge of Allegiance in 1954 during the Red Scare to set America apart from the secular Soviet government.

Apologies. I meant the Declaration of Independence. The nation was meant to be a nation that serves God.

I have to disagree with both of you anamosa this was not meant to be a nation that serves God we have a speration of church and state and CptJSparrow it is not unconstitutional because it is not required, I believe they made those 2 words optional and you can just pause there if you want, correct me if I'm wrong here

No law says that you are required to say the pledge, but that has no bearing on its Constitutionality or lack thereof. Anamosa, the Declaration of Independence is not the supreme law of the land, and the man who wrote it was a deist who believed that a deity did nothing but create the universe and instill inherent rights for man--this is NOT the Christian God, nor does it represent Constitutional philosophy.

The writer obviously was meaning the Christian God when he said the word "God". I think everyone knows this.
Avatar image for muthsera666
muthsera666

13271

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 9

User Lists: 0

#52 muthsera666
Member since 2005 • 13271 Posts

To muthsera666, Of course were entitled to our opinions but I dont think we should abandon the very principles that helped found this nation. And if One nation under Allah orany other godwas used in the pledge, I would not say it. We live in a free nation and you dont have to say god.Besides, 80 percent of Americans believe in god.GamingBoy2009

What the majority believe is irrelevant to the governing of a nation. Times change and Christianity is not as pervasive as it used to be, thankfully. It should not be used to indoctrinate children. They get enough of that from their parents forcing them to church, that they should be able to go to a secular school and learn the scientific theories, while recognizing them as theoriesinstead of being taught to except the religious theories as factual events.

And why wouldn't you use Allah or another term for God (god is so generic...)?

Avatar image for Nickman71
Nickman71

1002

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

#53 Nickman71
Member since 2003 • 1002 Posts
Why is it there in the first place? The original pledge never mentioned God. It was only added after the Knights of Columbus, a Roman Catholic orgainization pushed for it in the 1950's.
Avatar image for muthsera666
muthsera666

13271

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 9

User Lists: 0

#54 muthsera666
Member since 2005 • 13271 Posts
[QUOTE="muthsera666"]

1) I don't now, but all through elementary, middle, and high school, we didn't have a choice. We had to say the pledge in its entirety.

LS07

well I'm not sure when the ruling was, but if they try to make you now, sue there asses off and split the cash with me I'm broke

That doesn't really help me in college though... :)

Avatar image for Ezgam3r
Ezgam3r

2308

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

#55 Ezgam3r
Member since 2006 • 2308 Posts

1) In my high school, we had to say the pledge. So yes, I was forced.

2) I know tht God, Allah, and Yaweh are the same God, but they have different connotations and are therefore nto accepted by all of the members of the different faiths. I know some people who get angry when they hear the name Allah instead of God...

muthsera666

1) Were you in a privite school? Because in a public one I think its illigal to force you to say it.

2) Allah and Yahweh are just the Arabic and Hebrew names for God respectively. If a Christian was speaking Arabic, they'll say "Allah" and a Muslim speaking Hebrew would say "Yahweh". No one should get pissed off by this.

Avatar image for muthsera666
muthsera666

13271

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 9

User Lists: 0

#56 muthsera666
Member since 2005 • 13271 Posts
[QUOTE="muthsera666"]

1) In my high school, we had to say the pledge. So yes, I was forced.

2) I know tht God, Allah, and Yaweh are the same God, but they have different connotations and are therefore nto accepted by all of the members of the different faiths. I know some people who get angry when they hear the name Allah instead of God...

Ezgam3r

1) Were you in a privite school? Because in a public one I think its illigal to force you to say it.

2) Allah and Yahweh are just the Arabic and Hebrew names for God respectively. If a Christian was speaking Arabic, they'll say "Allah" and a Muslim speaking Hebrew would say "Yahweh". No one should get pissed off by this.

1) Public.

2) I know this. You know this. Many people know this. It doesn't change the fact that some people still do not like to hear their god called by a different name, especially by the name that the "other" uses.

Avatar image for GamingBoy2009
GamingBoy2009

1651

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 54

User Lists: 0

#57 GamingBoy2009
Member since 2005 • 1651 Posts
To mutersa666 again: What!! Since when did we live in a nation that was not for the people and by the people? Are you saying that the government should have their way and not the people? SHAME ON YOU!!!! Also I dont believe that children should be indoctrinated. I believe we should introduce them to both sides and let them choose what they want, not just throw it away like your saying.
Avatar image for Ezgam3r
Ezgam3r

2308

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

#58 Ezgam3r
Member since 2006 • 2308 Posts
[QUOTE="Ezgam3r"][QUOTE="muthsera666"]

1) In my high school, we had to say the pledge. So yes, I was forced.

2) I know tht God, Allah, and Yaweh are the same God, but they have different connotations and are therefore nto accepted by all of the members of the different faiths. I know some people who get angry when they hear the name Allah instead of God...

muthsera666

1) Were you in a privite school? Because in a public one I think its illigal to force you to say it.

2) Allah and Yahweh are just the Arabic and Hebrew names for God respectively. If a Christian was speaking Arabic, they'll say "Allah" and a Muslim speaking Hebrew would say "Yahweh". No one should get pissed off by this.

1) Public.

2) I know this. You know this. Many people know this. It doesn't change the fact that some people still do not like to hear their god called by a different name, especially by the name that the "other" uses.

1) Yea..... Lawsuit.

2)Well, feel sorry for those people.

Avatar image for muthsera666
muthsera666

13271

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 9

User Lists: 0

#59 muthsera666
Member since 2005 • 13271 Posts

To mutersa666 again: What!! Since when did we live in a nation that was not for the people and by the people? Are you saying that the government should have their way and not the people? SHAME ON YOU!!!! Also I dont believe that children should be indoctrinated. I believe we should introduce them to both sides and let them choose what they want, not just throw it away like your saying. GamingBoy2009

1) When did I say throw it away?

2) What are both sides? Religious and secular? Which religion do you expose them to? Only Christian? Only Western religions? What about ancient religions now referred to as mythologies?

3) For the best of the people doesnot necessarily mean giving them what they want. If a parent gave his or her children everything they wanted, wouldn't we say that makes him or her a bad parent? That he or she should keep in mind the welfare of the chilren, even if means they don't always get what they think they should, even if it's a majority vote?

3) This nation has never really been by the people. This is not a democratic country. True democracy is an inapplicable ideal, similar to true communism. The United States is primarily a republic. With the popular vote in an election, such as the presidental election, if every person in the state voted republican, the representatives could still approportion the botes to, say, the Green Party, as part of the representational governmental rule.

Avatar image for muthsera666
muthsera666

13271

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 9

User Lists: 0

#60 muthsera666
Member since 2005 • 13271 Posts
[QUOTE="muthsera666"][QUOTE="Ezgam3r"][QUOTE="muthsera666"]

1) In my high school, we had to say the pledge. So yes, I was forced.

2) I know tht God, Allah, and Yaweh are the same God, but they have different connotations and are therefore nto accepted by all of the members of the different faiths. I know some people who get angry when they hear the name Allah instead of God...

Ezgam3r

1) Were you in a privite school? Because in a public one I think its illigal to force you to say it.

2) Allah and Yahweh are just the Arabic and Hebrew names for God respectively. If a Christian was speaking Arabic, they'll say "Allah" and a Muslim speaking Hebrew would say "Yahweh". No one should get pissed off by this.

1) Public.

2) I know this. You know this. Many people know this. It doesn't change the fact that some people still do not like to hear their god called by a different name, especially by the name that the "other" uses.

1) Yea..... Lawsuit.

2)Well, feel sorry for those people.

1) Well, it was a rural Pennsylvania town, so it was fairly saturated with people who thought themselves Christian, so it's not really a surprise.

2) Me too.

Avatar image for LS07
LS07

945

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

#61 LS07
Member since 2007 • 945 Posts

[QUOTE="GamingBoy2009"]To mutersa666 again: What!! Since when did we live in a nation that was not for the people and by the people? Are you saying that the government should have their way and not the people? SHAME ON YOU!!!! Also I dont believe that children should be indoctrinated. I believe we should introduce them to both sides and let them choose what they want, not just throw it away like your saying. muthsera666

1) When did I say throw it away?

2) What are both sides? Religious and secular? Which religion do you expose them to? Only Christian? Only Western religions? What about ancient religions now referred to as mythologies?

3) For the best of the people doesnot necessarily mean giving them what they want. If a parent gave his or her children everything they wanted, wouldn't we say that makes him or her a bad parent? That he or she should keep in mind the welfare of the chilren, even if means they don't always get what they think they should, even if it's a majority vote?

3) This nation has never really been by the people. This is not a democratic country. True democracy is an inapplicable ideal, similar to true communism. The United States is primarily a republic. With the popular vote in an election, such as the presidental election, if every person in the state voted republican, the representatives could still approportion the botes to, say, the Green Party, as part of the representational governmental rule.

I'm to tired to argue with anything you said and I'm going to bed, but before I do I have to point out you have 2 number 3s

Avatar image for GamingBoy2009
GamingBoy2009

1651

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 54

User Lists: 0

#62 GamingBoy2009
Member since 2005 • 1651 Posts
To muthersa666: Ok I see that this arguement is getting us nowhere. Im through with posting for the night but I will leave with this: Were all entitled to our beliefs and I just want to say, dont take away my beliefs, as well as the 80% of people who believe. Respect my beliefs and I will respect yours. I will definatly be praying for you. God Bless America and Good night
Avatar image for Why_Me-
Why_Me-

131

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

#63 Why_Me-
Member since 2007 • 131 Posts

we put it in there to make a point because the soviets outlawed religion. the cold wars over, time to take it out.mugge5002
Yeah, we should replace it with "under Marx." Then we'll be heading in the right direction. (sarcasm)