This topic is locked from further discussion.
1. It's something to do after highschool/before college that's different from most work
2. It helps serve the country
3. It helps pay for college
I certainly don't see anything wrong with it... :?
I see this time and time again. Kids that graduated the previous year come in, and visit the school and they are in marine uniforms. They have joined the marines. What are the advantages of this? How does a drill sargent yelling at you 24/7 better than a normal 40 hour work week or college:?Raged_Soulja
Are you thinking about joining?
[QUOTE="Raged_Soulja"]I see this time and time again. Kids that graduated the previous year come in, and visit the school and they are in marine uniforms. They have joined the marines. What are the advantages of this? How does a drill sargent yelling at you 24/7 better than a normal 40 hour work week or college:?jfcundiff
Are you thinking about joining?
Collge for me.
[QUOTE="jfcundiff"][QUOTE="Raged_Soulja"]I see this time and time again. Kids that graduated the previous year come in, and visit the school and they are in marine uniforms. They have joined the marines. What are the advantages of this? How does a drill sargent yelling at you 24/7 better than a normal 40 hour work week or college:?Raged_Soulja
Are you thinking about joining?
Collge for me.
Well that is good.
i think it would be stupid to join now with this particluar warfreshgman
Just because you join now does not mean you will get shipped over to Iraq. Even the people who sign up know that they could go to Iraq. They know what they are getting into when they sign up. Wherever the country needs you to go, you go and serve.
[QUOTE="freshgman"]i think it would be stupid to join now with this particluar warjfcundiff
Just because you join now does not mean you will get shipped over to Iraq. Even the people who sign up know that they could go to Iraq. They know what they are getting into when they sign up. Wherever the country needs you to go, you go and serve.
Then I guess there is no point in joining now is there? You are serving all these people who don't give a crap about you and you get nothing out of it. If that is really why you would want to join. I don't want to serve my country if it lets people like Paris Hilton get more spotlight than the actual war.
[QUOTE="jfcundiff"][QUOTE="freshgman"]i think it would be stupid to join now with this particluar warIlived
Just because you join now does not mean you will get shipped over to Iraq. Even the people who sign up know that they could go to Iraq. They know what they are getting into when they sign up. Wherever the country needs you to go, you go and serve.
Then I guess there is no point in joining now is there? You are serving all these people who don't give a crap about you and you get nothing out of it. If that is really why you would want to join. I don't want to serve my country if it lets people like Paris Hilton get more spotlight than the actual war.
"Today, four soldiers were killed in an RPG ambush outside Baghdad. And in more important news, the Beckems are moving to America and another celeb breakup."
Celebrity culture sucks. And its even more depressing when a report like that actualy happens on the news... People have just stopped caring.
But a career in the armed forces isn't that bad. My dad was a Royal Marine, and he said it was the best years of his life.
Whatever reasons kids go off to join the military, you can bet your ass that most of them aren't going for noble reasons.IlivedI'm glad you pointed this out. Most people willingly swallow the "noble" and illusory images of the regular soldier. Sure there are some good men in the military, especially the officers, but if you look at the privates you will have a MUCH harder time finding that supposed nobility.
First of all look at where the recruitment centers are located- mostly inner cities where the poorest live. Notice how enlistment rates increase as the salary and bonuses increase. I normally don't like Michael Moore, but the images of the soldiers they show in Fahrenheit 9/11 is closer to reality than the myth that most politicians spread- blasting heavy metal music in a tank as they mow down buildings. Then they smile at the camera and pose among the ruins.
I'm glad you pointed this out. Most people willingly swallow the "noble" and illusory images of the regular soldier. Sure there are some good men in the military, especially the officers, but if you look at the privates you will have a MUCH harder time finding that supposed nobility.[QUOTE="Ilived"]Whatever reasons kids go off to join the military, you can bet your ass that most of them aren't going for noble reasons.Jocubus
First of all look at where the recruitment centers are located- mostly inner cities where the poorest live. Notice how enlistment rates increase as the salary and bonuses increase. I normally don't like Michael Moore, but the images of the soldiers they show in Fahrenheit 9/11 is closer to reality than the myth that most politicians spread- blasting heavy metal music in a tank as they mow down buildings. Then they smile at the camera and pose among the ruins.
Yeah, I agree. I knew who it was wanted to be in the army when I went to school, and every one of them was an idiotic bully.
Some kids cannot afford college. Joining the military gives you benefits and will help with college. Plus you travel the world if lucky. And the drill instructors only yell at you during camp. Once your done with camp they will not be screaming at you 24/7. Plus you are serving and defending your country which is an honorable thing to do.jfcundiffHuman beings are defending each other from each other. Two rocks will only chip away from each other when hit. Water is what causes erosion. Think about it.
Plus you are serving and defending your country which is an honorable thing to do.jfcundiff
Ugh... I hate nationalism so much...
The people I knew who went on to join the army... very very odd candidates. Not what you would expect.Yeah, I agree. I knew who it was wanted to be in the army when I went to school, and every one of them was an idiotic bully.
Funky_Llama
I was 18 living in Japan for two years and when I was 22 I got to visit two places in australia, two places in thailand, do charity work in east timor, help the special olympics in guam, visit the UAE and Bahrain (during a time of war unfortunately), go to Singapore.
Then I got out and had a good portion of college paid for me and it looks good on your resume having a degree in CIS and working in the field with 8 years experience.
I don't know of many college students that can claim the same thing.
[QUOTE="Funky_Llama"]The people I knew who went on to join the army... very very odd candidates. Not what you would expect.Yeah, I agree. I knew who it was wanted to be in the army when I went to school, and every one of them was an idiotic bully.
Jandurin
My long time friend became an alcoholic, but ever since he joined the army 2 years ago he has been doing great. Hasn't had a drink at least a year.
Some people might be thinking about being Firemen or Police Officers. There are two ways to do that, one of them is join the military.nickyb628
That's why I'm joining, I also can't afford the college I want to go to atm.
[QUOTE="Funky_Llama"][QUOTE="jfcundiff"]Plus you are serving and defending your country which is an honorable thing to do.Dasacant
Ugh... I hate nationalism so much...
and what exactly isn't honorable about defending your country?It can be honourable, but certainly is not per se. Was it honourable of German soldiers in WW2 to defend their country? Besides which, the burden of proof is on you to demonstrate that it is honourable.
The same reason some one would want to go to college. I know a lot of people who have joined the army and come out with loads of qualifications.Big_Bad_Sad
Yes military service is a very good thing to have on your resume if its combined with some college schooling on the side.
[QUOTE="Dasacant"][QUOTE="Funky_Llama"][QUOTE="jfcundiff"]Plus you are serving and defending your country which is an honorable thing to do.Funky_Llama
Ugh... I hate nationalism so much...
and what exactly isn't honorable about defending your country?It can be honourable, but certainly is not per se. Was it honourable of German soldiers in WW2 to defend their country? Besides which, the burden of proof is on you to demonstrate that it is honourable.
Defending the ones they loved? Staring death in the face and being able to hold their ground, having to leave their family to go defend people that hate them, all the while receiving very little pay and constantly being under stress. and especially today doing all of that stuff willingly and with enthusiasm.It can be honourable, but certainly is not per se. Was it honourable of German soldiers in WW2 to defend their country?Funky_Llama
The majority of German soldiers weren't Nazi's and didn't know about the atrocities that were being carried out on the Jews. Most only knew that they were being deported. I wouldn't say they're cause was honorable, but to die for your country is honorable.
Besides which, the burden of proof is on you to demonstrate that it is honourable.
Funky
Two things;
1.) The Burden of Proof is on YOU to prove him wrong, not the other way around. ;)
2.) Trying to demonstrate something like this on the internet is like trying to have an orgasm with your browser; it just doesn't work.
I'm doing ROTC in college because:
1. They pay for all of my education
2. I get a monthly stipend, which is the same I'd get if I had a college job
3. I want to become a better, more driven individual, and the Army can help you achieve this
4. It will help me become a leader in society (I actually want to do something with my life)
5. When I graduate from ROTC, I will join the Army Reserves, and will be a 2nd Lieutenant, meaning I will be leading a platoon.
6. It will give you a huge advantage over others for leadership and other job positions.
7. It's something in which I've always wanted to do
[QUOTE="Funky_Llama"][QUOTE="Dasacant"][QUOTE="Funky_Llama"][QUOTE="jfcundiff"]Plus you are serving and defending your country which is an honorable thing to do.Dasacant
Ugh... I hate nationalism so much...
and what exactly isn't honorable about defending your country?It can be honourable, but certainly is not per se. Was it honourable of German soldiers in WW2 to defend their country? Besides which, the burden of proof is on you to demonstrate that it is honourable.
Defending the ones they loved? Staring death in the face and being able to hold their ground, having to leave their family to go defend people that hate them, all the while receiving very little pay and constantly being under stress. and especially today doing all of that stuff willingly and with enthusiasm.It wasn't even their choice; they were conscripted in their millions to fight for one of the most evil men in history. They had to fight; nothing honourable there.
It wasn't even their choice; they were conscripted in their millions to fight for one of the most evil men in history. They had to fight; nothing honourable there.
Funky_Llama
You know, this is irrelavant, you're making a strawman out of his argument. The entire premises of his argument was that it was honourable to fight for your country, I think it's plain obvious that he meant that if it was of your own free-will. :roll:
Conscripted or not they still did most of those thing and when I talked about willingness I was talking about most modern armies. The fact of the matter is most people cannot do it and those that can and do deserve your and my respect.It wasn't even their choice; they were conscripted in their millions to fight for one of the most evil men in history. They had to fight; nothing honourable there.
Funky_Llama
[QUOTE="Funky_Llama"]It can be honourable, but certainly is not per se. Was it honourable of German soldiers in WW2 to defend their country?VoodooGamer
The majority of German soldiers weren't Nazi's and didn't know about the atrocities that were being carried out on the Jews. Most only knew that they were being deported. I wouldn't say they're cause was honorable, but to die for your country is honorable.
Besides which, the burden of proof is on you to demonstrate that it is honourable.
Funky
Two things;
1.) The Burden of Proof is on YOU to prove him wrong, not the other way around. ;)
2.) Trying to demonstrate something like this on the internet is like trying to have an orgasm with your browser; it just doesn't work.
In the words of Patton.. No poor bastard won a war by dying for his country, he won it by making the other poor dumb bastard die for his country :P
[QUOTE="VoodooGamer"][QUOTE="Funky_Llama"]It can be honourable, but certainly is not per se. Was it honourable of German soldiers in WW2 to defend their country?sSubZerOo
The majority of German soldiers weren't Nazi's and didn't know about the atrocities that were being carried out on the Jews. Most only knew that they were being deported. I wouldn't say they're cause was honorable, but to die for your country is honorable.
Besides which, the burden of proof is on you to demonstrate that it is honourable.
Funky
Two things;
1.) The Burden of Proof is on YOU to prove him wrong, not the other way around. ;)
2.) Trying to demonstrate something like this on the internet is like trying to have an orgasm with your browser; it just doesn't work.
In the words of Patton.. No poor bastard won a war by dying for his country, he won it by making the other poor dumb bastard die for his country :P
Or in other words, live long enough to die another day. :lol:
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment