Which of these phones would you pick?

I'm stuck between the Samsung Impression and the Sony Ericsson C905a. On one hand, the Samsung has a large OLED screen, a touch screen, and a full qwerty keyboard. On the other the Sony has a 8.1 MP camera with xenon flash, Wi-Fi, and conversation mode for texting. I'm stuck :(

What do you guys suggest?

Here's the Samsung:

http://reviews.cnet.com/cell-phones/samsung-impression-sgh-a877/4505-6454_7-33573210.html

Here's the Sony:

http://reviews.cnet.com/cell-phones/sony-ericsson-cyber-shot/4505-6454_7-33421771.html

Any reason as to why I should go with the Samsung?dk00111

My sis has gotten 2 sony ericsons and both have broke on her.

My sis has gotten 2 sony ericsons and both have broke on her.

SnowJackal

One of my friends has the Impression, and she apparently likes it. I haven't seen the Sony myself, but I suppose I would recommend the Impression.

The Samsung for sure.

sony ericsson!!!auron_16

blackberry bold! if not then the sony ericssonUnknownmuncher

My Sony still works great and I have had it for years.

The Sony one there also seems to have a better camera too (it is a Cyber Shot). The user reviews currently give it an edge on the cnet to.

Neither, get a Blackberry instead.

These are the only 2 phones you like or could afford?n00bkid

Neither, get a Blackberry instead.

elblanquito_81

Whatever one I can phone people with. harashawn

dont complicate things

I'd say the Samsung just from the things you listed that were better about the Sony didn't seem as helpful/nescessary for a phone. I'm no phone expert though; I've never owned one, but I'm looking.

If anyone wants to give me their opinion without hijacking the thread, has anyone heard anything good about the LG Secret? It's pretty and doesn't have a full touch screen, which is what I'd prefer.

I'd say the Samsung just from the things you listed that were better about the Sony didn't seem as helpful/nescessary for a phone. I'm no phone expert though; I've never owned one, but I'm looking.

If anyone wants to give me their opinion without hijacking the thread, has anyone heard anything good about the LG Secret? It's pretty and doesn't have a full touch screen, which is what I'd prefer.

IcyToasters

I just got the Samsung Solstice yesterday, I think its the one right before this. I like it, its perdy cool. Sony Ericsson is hit or miss with me.Squidney

[QUOTE="Squidney"]I just got the Samsung Solstice yesterday, I think its the one right before this. I like it, its perdy cool. Sony Ericsson is hit or miss with me.dk00111