This topic is locked from further discussion.
So, the medic should get paid the most?wado-karateIf he needs to go to school longer, sure. Many jobs are dangerous, like fishing, mining, etc. However, safer jobs that require more school, such as lawyers, doctors, architects, etc. pay better to balance all of the schooling required.
So, the medic should get paid the most?wado-karate
No. The Spy should get paid the most.
Either him or the Heavy.
[QUOTE="wado-karate"]So, the medic should get paid the most?MetroidPrimePwn
No. The Spy should get paid the most.
Either him or the Heavy.
Engineer does do a lot of work though, so can't forget him.
[QUOTE="wado-karate"]So, the medic should get paid the most?Engrish_MajorIf he needs to go to school longer, sure. Many jobs are dangerous, like fishing, mining, etc. However, safer jobs that require more school, such as lawyers, doctors, architects, etc. pay better to balance all of the schooling required. So, do you think that once student loans have been paid off, the pay should be reduced? Surely a dangerous job should be paid more than a safe one?
Doctors already make quite a bit of money...the amount of money we pay low ranked enlisted soldiers is terrible compared to what companies like Blackwater are willing to pay. Pretty bad when Blackwater employees get more time off,less restrictions,better food,and can quit whenever they want. Soldiers essentially have to sign their lifes away for 4 years (beyond that now, thanks to stop-loss)
They both deserve more, overall though.
[QUOTE="MetroidPrimePwn"][QUOTE="wado-karate"]So, the medic should get paid the most?Legendaryscmt
No. The Spy should get paid the most.
Either him or the Heavy.
Engineer does do a lot of work though, so can't forget him.
I think the scout should be paid the most, to compensate for his comparative weakness.[QUOTE="Engrish_Major"][QUOTE="wado-karate"]So, the medic should get paid the most?karristonIf he needs to go to school longer, sure. Many jobs are dangerous, like fishing, mining, etc. However, safer jobs that require more school, such as lawyers, doctors, architects, etc. pay better to balance all of the schooling required. So, do you think that once student loans have been paid off, the pay should be reduced? Surely a dangerous job should be paid more than a safe one? It all has to do with supply and availability. Not everybody off the street can be a doctor. They have to go through several years of school and training. It's also a valued commodity -> people need and want doctors. It's not saying that what soldiers do is unimportant, just that it's harder to come by doctors.
[QUOTE="Engrish_Major"][QUOTE="wado-karate"]So, the medic should get paid the most?karristonIf he needs to go to school longer, sure. Many jobs are dangerous, like fishing, mining, etc. However, safer jobs that require more school, such as lawyers, doctors, architects, etc. pay better to balance all of the schooling required. So, do you think that once student loans have been paid off, the pay should be reduced? Surely a dangerous job should be paid more than a safe one? It's supply and demand. There are not as many people that can successfully obtain a MD degree. Almost anyone that is physically able can be a soldier.
[QUOTE="karriston"][QUOTE="Engrish_Major"] If he needs to go to school longer, sure. Many jobs are dangerous, like fishing, mining, etc. However, safer jobs that require more school, such as lawyers, doctors, architects, etc. pay better to balance all of the schooling required.sonicareSo, do you think that once student loans have been paid off, the pay should be reduced? Surely a dangerous job should be paid more than a safe one? It all has to do with supply and availability. Not everybody off the street can be a doctor. They have to go through several years of school and training. It's also a valued commodity -> people need and want doctors. It's not saying that what soldiers do is unimportant, just that it's harder to come by doctors. True, but not everyone off the street can be an effective soldier too, especially with the mental and physical strain it takes to be in a war-zone. And with wars in Iraq and other places in the world, are soldiers not becoming a valued commodity too? (By the way, I'm playing Devil's Advocate here).
[QUOTE="Legendaryscmt"][QUOTE="MetroidPrimePwn"]No. The Spy should get paid the most.
Either him or the Heavy.
Funky_Llama
Engineer does do a lot of work though, so can't forget him.
I think the scout should be paid the most, to compensate for his comparative weakness.Pyro's can get heat exhaustion or accidently burn themselves maybe they should get a raise too for those nasty medical bills
[QUOTE="Funky_Llama"][QUOTE="Legendaryscmt"]I think the scout should be paid the most, to compensate for his comparative weakness.Engineer does do a lot of work though, so can't forget him.
Lief_Ericson
Pyro's can get heat exhaustion or accidently burn themselves maybe they should get a raise too for those nasty medical bills
Now that's true. Also the soldier should get a cut in pay because bloody anyone can be a good soldier.[QUOTE="markop2003"]Doctor, though a high ranking soldier should make the samelucky326Anyone above Officer ranking has a nice pay deal Also Senior Doctors make a nice bit of pay as well, especially those in Private Practise. A standard GP makes about 100K, you don't need to be a high ranking doctor to get high wages
Here's another question to add to it: Who deserves a higher salary: A fireman, or a politician?karristonNow that's a better question. I do believe that politicians, while their base pay might be fair, get an undue amount of money from outside sources that can influence their work.
[QUOTE="markop2003"]Doctor, though a high ranking soldier should make the samelucky326Anyone above Officer ranking has a nice pay deal Also Senior Doctors make a nice bit of pay as well, especially those in Private Practise. Private practise is a tricky one in the context of this question though, don't you think? Would you say someone who forces people to pay extortionate prices for things they may need to improve or maintain their quality of life just so that they can live an excessively comfortable life deserves more than a doctor who works for much less in a hospital?
True, but not everyone off the street can be an effective soldier too, especially with the mental and physical strain it takes to be in a war-zone.karristonPfft, like hell, all he needs to do is fire the rocket launcher, and chances are it'll be a crit rocket, which have blast radii of several miles. >_>
[QUOTE="karriston"] True, but not everyone off the street can be an effective soldier too, especially with the mental and physical strain it takes to be in a war-zone.Funky_LlamaPfft, like hell, all he needs to do is fire the rocket launcher, and chances are it'll be a crit rocket, which have blast radii of several miles. >_> But what about shell shock? What about the suicide rates of Vietnam vets? Surely this shows that not everyone has what it takes to be a soldier in a war?
[QUOTE="Funky_Llama"][QUOTE="karriston"] True, but not everyone off the street can be an effective soldier too, especially with the mental and physical strain it takes to be in a war-zone.karristonPfft, like hell, all he needs to do is fire the rocket launcher, and chances are it'll be a crit rocket, which have blast radii of several miles. >_> But what about shell shock? What about the suicide rates of Vietnam vets? Surely this shows that not everyone has what it takes to be a soldier in a war? They knew what they were in for when they picked soldier. Maybe they should have been something less stressful like engineer.
Doctors actually save lives and soliders risk their life to kill other lives to safe lives.
I would say doctors because they protect more lives.
[QUOTE="karriston"][QUOTE="Funky_Llama"]Pfft, like hell, all he needs to do is fire the rocket launcher, and chances are it'll be a crit rocket, which have blast radii of several miles. >_>II-FBIsniper-IIBut what about shell shock? What about the suicide rates of Vietnam vets? Surely this shows that not everyone has what it takes to be a soldier in a war? They knew what they were in for when they picked soldier. Maybe they should have been something less stressful like engineer. That's my point though. Surely the amount of conscripts that broke down in the first and second world wars, the Vietnam war and countless others, shows that not everyone is up to the task? Damn you if you're making yet another Team Fortress reference though.
[QUOTE="karriston"]But what about shell shock? What about the suicide rates of Vietnam vets? Surely this shows that not everyone has what it takes to be a soldier in a war?II-FBIsniper-IIThey knew what they were in for when they picked soldier. Maybe they should have been something less stressful like engineer. All this shows is, while I would agree there are exceptional soldiers, given the wrong situation anyone will break.
[QUOTE="Funky_Llama"][QUOTE="karriston"] True, but not everyone off the street can be an effective soldier too, especially with the mental and physical strain it takes to be in a war-zone.karristonPfft, like hell, all he needs to do is fire the rocket launcher, and chances are it'll be a crit rocket, which have blast radii of several miles. >_> But what about shell shock? What about the suicide rates of Vietnam vets? Surely this shows that not everyone has what it takes to be a soldier in a war?Damn, I knew people wouldn't get that. U_U
You can't say that about every soldier though. What about those that are just defending their countries, or themselves? Would someone who fought to defend Britain during WW II deserve equal or more pay than a doctor during the same period?Doctors actually save lives and soliders risk their life to kill other lives to safe lives.
I would say doctors because they protect more lives.
Gaming-Planet
[QUOTE="karriston"][QUOTE="Funky_Llama"]Pfft, like hell, all he needs to do is fire the rocket launcher, and chances are it'll be a crit rocket, which have blast radii of several miles. >_>Funky_LlamaBut what about shell shock? What about the suicide rates of Vietnam vets? Surely this shows that not everyone has what it takes to be a soldier in a war?Damn, I knew people wouldn't get that. U_U Goddamit, not another one :p You guys are ruining my one and only serious topic on Gamespot :(
Being a Doctor myself Ive got to say that salaries for most doctors are well deserved and alot of us are actualy underpaid while a few way way overpaid for what they actualy do. Ive got to tell you that the training you undrego to become a Doc, Medschool, internship, residence etc is very demanding competitive and not to forgiving. It requires sacrifice and commitment.to get through but it doesnt end their, Although it seems to be diminishing now days, our social responsablity is also quite huge as well. You spend long hours training, working in a high stress environment where although you might not be aware of it You (the Doctor) are exposed to life threatning factors on a daily basis these usualy come in the form of viruses, bacterias, fungi, contaminated Sharps, Stress, lawyers, and nurses lol.
The responsability we contract with patients is inmense and any mistake on our part is deemed instantly unforgivable, and immideately sueable. A large part of Medical Lawsuits are brough about not because of actual fault on the Dr's behalf but by money hungry lawyers and disgruntled misguided patients.
If you factor in the time spent away from family, being on call on holydays and weekends. Long work hours high stress among other things, not to mention the costs of running your own practice and hiring staff. then the potential benefits sometimes just dont seem like its enough. and might barely compensate.
A soldier, especialy one in combat is at risk on a more acute basis and I cant describe what the cost to them represents but yeah some of them should be compensated a little more, But then again so should teachers.
Hope this helps bring some perspective on your question
[QUOTE="Gaming-Planet"]You can't say that about every soldier though. What about those that are just defending their countries, or themselves? Would someone who fought to defend Britain during WW II deserve equal or more pay than a doctor during the same period?Doctors actually save lives and soliders risk their life to kill other lives to safe lives.
I would say doctors because they protect more lives.
karriston
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment