What disorders would be ok? Which ones would not? I know a family that willingly had a child that had Down's Syndrome. Could you do that? What about Angelman Syndrome or Lesch-Nyan or even Dwarfism?
This topic is locked from further discussion.
What disorders would be ok? Which ones would not? I know a family that willingly had a child that had Down's Syndrome. Could you do that? What about Angelman Syndrome or Lesch-Nyan or even Dwarfism?
I would get an abortion.LonelynightFor any disorder? Would you be willing to live with slight MR or Fragile X Syndrome?
[QUOTE="Lonelynight"]I would get an abortion.GatlingHammerFor any disorder? Would you be willing to live with slight MR or Fragile X Syndrome?Depends on the seriousness.
[QUOTE="GatlingHammer"][QUOTE="Lonelynight"]I would get an abortion.LonelynightFor any disorder? Would you be willing to live with slight MR or Fragile X Syndrome?Depends on the seriousness. Well, what would be too serious? What wouldn't be serious enough? I've mentioned several disorders already which ones could you live with your child having?
Well the screening tests aren't 100% accurate. Not even close, but the further evaluations and studies are as close to 100% as medical science can get. Or do you mean that you wouldn't be willing to take even the miniscule chance that the child would be healthy?The tests to see if there are going to be disorders aren't 100% accurate. I would hate the thought that I might have destroyed a perfectly healthy life because a test was wrong. I'd still continue with the pregnancy.
Atmanix
[QUOTE="Atmanix"]Well the screening tests aren't 100% accurate. Not even close, but the further evaluations and studies are as close to 100% as medical science can get. Or do you mean that you wouldn't be willing to take even the miniscule chance that the child would be healthy?The tests to see if there are going to be disorders aren't 100% accurate. I would hate the thought that I might have destroyed a perfectly healthy life because a test was wrong. I'd still continue with the pregnancy.
GatlingHammer
I was referring to the screening tests mostly. Honestly though I'd still have an issue with it even if they were 99.8% correct. Abortion just doesn't sit well with me.
Great topic, TC. (:
Unfortunately I'd have no idea unless I, God forbid, end up in said situation. My immediate reaction was ,,do not want'', but that impulse could easily stem from the fact I don't want a pregnancy, period.
hah. I went through that same thought process and came to the conclusion that small children, disabled or not, are damn scary :S[QUOTE="Jandurin"]hah. I went through that same thought process and came to the conclusion that small children, disabled or not, are damn scary :SBiancaDKLoud noises wrapped in self-regenerating filth.
HEY! My son is ... well no, that's a lie. He's extremely loud and annoying when he wants to be.
It's a tough question because even within a family trying to do the right thing the issue is ambiguous. I usually state what I would do in the OP but I couldn't in this situation. Even something like dwarfism where they could live a perfectly normal and productive life I wonder if I could continue that pregnancy.
It's a tough question because even within a family trying to do the right thing the issue is ambiguous. I usually state what I would do in the OP but I couldn't in this situation. Even something like dwarfism where they could live a perfectly normal and productive life I wonder if I could continue that pregnancy.
GatlingHammer
Dwarfism isn't something to abort over in my opinion.
[QUOTE="GatlingHammer"]
It's a tough question because even within a family trying to do the right thing the issue is ambiguous. I usually state what I would do in the OP but I couldn't in this situation. Even something like dwarfism where they could live a perfectly normal and productive life I wonder if I could continue that pregnancy.
Atmanix
Dwarfism isn't something to abort over in my opinion.
I'm not saying that placed in that situation I would, I'm just saying that even something as non-life threatening as dwarfism would give me pause.[QUOTE="Atmanix"][QUOTE="GatlingHammer"]
It's a tough question because even within a family trying to do the right thing the issue is ambiguous. I usually state what I would do in the OP but I couldn't in this situation. Even something like dwarfism where they could live a perfectly normal and productive life I wonder if I could continue that pregnancy.
GatlingHammer
Dwarfism isn't something to abort over in my opinion.
I'm not saying that placed in that situation I would, I'm just saying that even something as non-life threatening as dwarfism would give me pause.I know, I wasn't saying you did, sorry if it came off that way. I was just throwing out my opinion on it.
Continue with the pregnancy. For the months to come before the baby's birth, I'd be preparing myself on how to better rear a child with predicted disorder.
Ceraby
I would do this aswell.
I would if it was some minor physical issue. For mental or extreme handicaps? Absolutely not, in fact I think forcing someone to live through that is torture in itself and killing the fetus could be considered an act of mercy. Not a chick though so thankfully I never have to worry about that.
It depends on the disorder. I also know people who have a child with Down's Syndrome. It is really not that bad compared to some. I would probably want to get an abortion if it was something really serious, but that's also up to the mother.
I'd have an abortion if I knew my child would be born with serious, incurable disorders.
If you're talking stuff like Autism, then no. I would just deal with it.
If you're talking deformity, severe mental retardation or something that would give them and myself a hard life of alienation where they would be completely dependent on other people or even mahcines to live, then I would just have an abortion.
I think it's torture on both the child and yourself to have to endure something like that for the rest of your and their lives.
I'd have an abortion and most likely wouldn't even try to have another child after that.
Sounds harsh, but it's nobody's choice but mine.
Very tough question.. I am a guy and gay so having children will probably be something I plan for not something that happens out of the blue, but I have no idea what I would do in that situation. Perhaps if I were a woman and I knew my child would go through a horrible life because of said disorder then I would abort. If it is something that because of new technology and acceptance among society then I would probably keep the child. That is a tough choice though.
For this question, are the males supposed to pretend they own a functioning uterus? If so, then I'd abort for most serious disorders. I could handle smaller learning disorders or slight MR.
If not, then I dunno, the woman carrying the child can make the decision and I'll support regardless.
Of course I wouldn't abort the child. I would want the child to live so he can have a choice.Genetic_Codeso he can have a choice of what? Whether or not he enjoys the way his brain works? Whether or not he should off himself? Do you condone suicide? 'cause your post would make more sense if you did
[QUOTE="Genetic_Code"]Of course I wouldn't abort the child. I would want the child to live so he can have a choice.Jandurinso he can have a choice of what? Whether or not he enjoys the way his brain works? Whether or not he should off himself? Do you condone suicide? 'cause your post would make more sense if you did Yeah, I though the same thing. But chose to do a mental shrug rather than reply. :P
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment