If all games in the series had the same graphics, but original story & gamep

Assuming all these games in the series have the latest graphics and soundability, but kept the story, level design andgameplay rules of the title the year it was released,what would you rather play?

Half-Life 1 or Half-Life 2?

Morrowind or Oblivion?

Deus Ex 1 or Deus Ex 2?

The Longest Journey 1 or The Longest Journey 2?

Black & White 1 or Black & White 2?

Shogun Total War or Medeival II Total War?

Longest journey 2

dunno about the rest.

Half-Life 1 or Half-Life 2?

Morrowind or Oblivion?

Deus Ex 1 or Deus Ex 2?

The Longest Journey 1 or The Longest Journey 2?

Black & White 1 or Black & White 2?

Shogun Total War or Medeival II Total War?

The__MCP

Half-Life

Morrowind

Deus Ex

Haven't played either

Black & White 2

Haven't played either

Either of the Half-Life games. 1 or 2, it wouldn't really matter to me since they both rock!

Assuming all these games in the series have the latest graphics and soundability, but kept the story, level design andgameplay rules of the title the year it was released,what would you rather play?

Half-Life 1 or Half-Life 2?

Morrowind or Oblivion?

Deus Ex 1 or Deus Ex 2?

The Longest Journey 1 or The Longest Journey 2?

Black & White 1 or Black & White 2?

Shogun Total War or Medeival II Total War?

The__MCP

Halflife 2
Morrowind (never played it but everyone who has says its better)
Deus Ex 1 (its better than DX2, even with the outdated visuals)
Black and White 1
Shogun: Total War

morrowind

Half-Life 1 (The only thing that HL 2 really does better is graphics in my opinion)
Morrowind (brilliant game, much better than Oblivion)
Deus Ex (Haven't played through all of either game, but have played enough of both to know that 1 is better)
Haven't played any of the rest.

Half Life 2
Morrowind
Deus Ex
The Longest Journey 2
Black and White 2
Medeival II

HL2

Morrowind (a must play for an RPG fan, Ob not so much...)

DE1

TLJ2

Don't care about the rest.

Assuming all these games in the series have the latest graphics and soundability, but kept the story, level design andgameplay rules of the title the year it was released,what would you rather play?

Half-Life 1 or Half-Life 2?

Morrowind or Oblivion?

Deus Ex 1 or Deus Ex 2?

The Longest Journey 1 or The Longest Journey 2?

Black & White 1 or Black & White 2?

Shogun Total War or Medeival II Total War?

The__MCP

Half-Life

Morrowind

Deus Ex

haven't played both

haven't played either

Half-Life 1 or Half-Life 2?

Don't know.

Morrowind or Oblivion?

Not sure. Probably Oblivion.

Deus Ex 1 or Deus Ex 2?

Definitely the 1st one.

The Longest Journey 1 or The Longest Journey 2?

Don't know. Never played the first one and only played the 2nd one for a little while.

Black & White 1 or Black & White 2?

Don't know. Haven't played either game enough to tell which would be better.

Shogun Total War or Medeival II Total War?

Herrick hasn't played either game.

This is a nice thread. Anyone else have any other games to add?

Half-Life 1 or Half-Life 2?

Don't know.

Morrowind or Oblivion?

Not sure. Probably Oblivion.

Deus Ex 1 or Deus Ex 2?

Definitely the 1st one.

The Longest Journey 1 or The Longest Journey 2?

Don't know. Never played the first one and only played the 2nd one for a little while.

Black & White 1 or Black & White 2?

Don't know. Haven't played either game enough to tell which would be better.

Shogun Total War or Medeival II Total War?

Herrick hasn't played either game.

This is a nice thread. Anyone else have any other games to add?

Herrick

I tried to think of other games that were different from sequel to sequel but looking at the reviews in Gamespot's archives, there were a lot of games that were almost mirror images of their predecessor. Yes, if anyone else can brainstorm some games, I'd like to see more opinions.

Assuming all these games in the series have the latest graphics and soundability, but kept the story, level design andgameplay rules of the title the year it was released,what would you rather play?

Half-Life 1 or Half-Life 2?

Morrowind or Oblivion?

Deus Ex 1 or Deus Ex 2?

The Longest Journey 1 or The Longest Journey 2?

Black & White 1 or Black & White 2?

Shogun Total War or Medeival II Total War?

The__MCP