What is the best game...

That you have ever played (All Time), For PC.

I'm debating between Brothers In Arms Hell's Highway, Gears Of War, or World In Conflict.

f-a-d-3

half life

vice city

deus ex

all old games!

Aside from WoW and other MMO's, the game I probably logged the most time with was the original Starcraft. Played that for ages.

So I'm going to say Starcraft 1

[QUOTE="nevereathim"]

[QUOTE="bedram793"]^^^ Basically what he is saying is he probably hasn't even played Deus Ex. He said best games you have played, not best games of all time that is out there.fatshodan

I have played Deus Ex..why else would I list it? That's what I'm trying to say.

Why has this misunderstanding lasted so long! Let me try and explain:

You tell him that he's wrong to think Gears of War and etc are the best games he's ever played because they aren't the best games ever made.

Note the distinction between best game ever played and best game ever made. There have been better games made than Gears of War and the others he mentioned, but if he hasn't played them, he can't mention them amongst the best games he's ever played, can he?

For example, if I've only played Dark Messiah and Big Rigs - if those are the only games I've ever played, then one of those two games is inherently the best game I've ever played by virtue of them being the only games I've ever played.

The people who replied to you were objecting to the fact that you criticised his choices, but unless you know every game he's ever played, how can you judge? He may have only played five PC games, in which case he may be well within his rights to legitimately state that those three games are the best he's ever played.

Now, if you don't understand the above, you're either a very incompetent troll or you;re just incompetent.

exactly.

Doom, Total Annihilation, Myth: The Fallen Lords, Max Payne, Ultima Online (before it died), Dungeon Keeper, Z, Hexen, System Shock 2.

Good God too many to name!

for me I'd say Vice City is my all time fave

others are :Warcraft 3(both of them)

Halo CE...only bcuz it was my first shooter

Farcry

Soldat (2d multiplayer rules!)

and a cool indie rpg called Laxius Power

mafia

hitman blood money

bioshock

portal

crysis

gta san andreas

Call of Duty 1

yes the first one, if anyone remembers it

Call of Duty 1

yes the first one, if anyone remembers it

Postal_Guy

My favorites:

Half-Life 1 & 2
Counterstrike (old)
Day of Defeat (old)
Starcraft
and Sailor Moon: Vengeance of the Crystal Star