just picked up MNR AND RDR

Good choice, traded in infamous and heavy rain.... beat both

Trading in Heavy Rain is inexcusable. MNR looks hit and miss to me. RDR was an excellent choice. All in all I give your purchase a 6/10.

Trading in Heavy Rain is inexcusable. MNR looks hit and miss to me. RDR was an excellent choice. All in all I give your purchase a 6/10.

GingerDeadMan

Well, truth be told, Heavy rain is really a once-only experience. Sure, you can try to play the game from different angles and discover all the possible endings, but once you know who the origami killer is, you kind of lose interest in the game

thats what i was saying.

Congrats? I loved Heavy Rain, so I would never trade it in to be honest. But hey, it's your decision. Enjoy MNR and RDR.

Ive had RDR since it came out but didn't jump right into it. Last night i actually gave it a good few hours and wow so fun. i did however let 2 cows run off the cliff :(

sad

RDR is epic, can't say the same for MNR though