madden or 2k8

i am trying to decide which game to get i have bolth 2k7 and maddne 07 and am looking to upgrade either one or the other which has had a bigger improvement

heard its crap and am canadien are u

heard its crap and am canadien are u

i bought madden 08 and it was really really bad. the ps2 version is so much better because it runs smoothly. on the ps3 its so slow and laggy, i cant explain it. it just stops you from enjoying the game. i think the xbox 360 version has a better frame rate than the ps3 version for some reason. i bought mine from costco and returned it 2 weeks later. i got the ps2 version later and its sooooo much better.

besides the frame rate issue, the game itself is the same exact game from last with an updated roster so its just not worth buying at all.

APF 2k8 was really fun when i played the demo, i didnt buy it yet because i didnt wanna spend $60. The 2k gameplay is so much better than madden's gameplay. when i was playing nfl 2k it was so much fun and every year it was worth buying because there were so many improvements, it was playing a completely different game. Thanks to the guy who gave the link to apf for 9.99, thats a great deal, im getting it.