Now.. do you think MGS4 Deserved the award for game of the year?

For me it did deserve the award, the best PS3 game that came out this year imo and it even let new gamers get interested in it and loved it ( of course there are some who didn't but that can happen to any game)

Yeah, but it wasn't that great.

I mean it was great, but not great to where I'd buy a PS3 just to play it.

The game is excellent and in my case, it was the decisive factor on getting a PS3 over a 360.madsnakehhh

Who's that in your avatar?

She's cute :3

Yeah, but it wasn't that great.

I mean it was great, but not great to where I'd buy a PS3 just to play it.

Scianix-Black

Nope, i don't think it did. Because it was hardly a game, it was a movie. And i can't say it deserves movie of the year, either, because of The Dark Knight.

Yes. It was the main reason I bought the PS3 MGS4 bundle.

It was easily the best game of this year. Gears 2 and Fable 2 didn't surpass their predecessors and Wii, like always, had nothing.hillelslovak

Yeah, but it wasn't that great.

I mean it was great, but not great to where I'd buy a PS3 just to play it.

Scianix-Black

That goes without saying. There's no such thing, for any console. It takes more than one game to make anyone want to buy any console.I don't see how that takes away from MGS4 deserving GOTY or being a great game for that matter.

I don't think it should have been, MGS4 was just good story, good graphics, good voce acting, and good ol' sneaking/shooting(preference).

But, this formula has been done time and time again.

I think Game of the Year should be LittleBigPlanet. It was just so refreshing, it made me remenisce on the times i played Mario Bros. (Gunpei Yokoi).

No Resistance 2, No Fallout 3 and definetly No Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots could ever give me that feeling again, ever.

Exactly why its the best!!!

[QUOTE="samuraiguns]MGS4 was just good story, good graphics, good voce acting, and good ol' sneaking/shooting(preference).]

Exactly why its the best!!!

Blue_Abyss

did you bother to read the rest of my post?

For me it did deserve the award, the best PS3 game that came out this year imo and it even let new gamers get interested in it and loved it ( of course there are some who didn't but that can happen to any game)

Star650

Nope, i don't think it did. Because it was hardly a game, it was a movie. And i can't say it deserves movie of the year, either, because of The Dark Knight.

HaXeR

For me it did deserve the award, the best PS3 game that came out this year imo and it even let new gamers get interested in it and loved it ( of course there are some who didn't but that can happen to any game)

It was excellent, with a very good online mode.Louis_Routledge

looking at other GotY nominees..yes MGS4 deserves it

so why is NHL 09 nominated but not Valkyria Chronicles or Dead Space?

[QUOTE="HaXeR"]

Nope, i don't think it did. Because it was hardly a game, it was a movie. And i can't say it deserves movie of the year, either, because of The Dark Knight.

Silent-Hal

[QUOTE="Silent-Hal"][QUOTE="HaXeR"]

Nope, i don't think it did. Because it was hardly a game, it was a movie. And i can't say it deserves movie of the year, either, because of The Dark Knight.

xX_-X-_Xx

so basically and according to what you're saying, the cutscenes are 15 hours long huh?? well I think that's a little too much for a game but I guess you're wrong so meh.

Splinter Cell > MGS. always has been, always will be. And no it doesnt deserve GOTY.Bauers-Twin

Definetly gameplay wise, but not story.

[QUOTE="xX_-X-_Xx"][QUOTE="Silent-Hal"] Did you play the game? 'Cause this is the kind of ignorant comment that should be banished to System Wars. Saying that there were more cutscenes than gameplay is just wrong. THQ88

so basically and according to what you're saying, the cutscenes are 15 hours long huh?? well I think that's a little too much for a game but I guess you're wrong so meh.

[QUOTE="Bauers-Twin"]Splinter Cell > MGS. always has been, always will be. And no it doesnt deserve GOTY.samuraiguns

Definetly gameplay wise, but not story.

[QUOTE="samuraiguns"]

[QUOTE="Bauers-Twin"]Splinter Cell > MGS. always has been, always will be. And no it doesnt deserve GOTY.Bauers-Twin

Definetly gameplay wise, but not story.

Disagree.

Agree.

[QUOTE="samuraiguns"]

[QUOTE="Bauers-Twin"]Splinter Cell > MGS. always has been, always will be. And no it doesnt deserve GOTY.Bauers-Twin

Definetly gameplay wise, but not story.

[QUOTE="samuraiguns"]

[QUOTE="Bauers-Twin"]Splinter Cell > MGS. always has been, always will be. And no it doesnt deserve GOTY.Bauers-Twin

Definetly gameplay wise, but not story.

[QUOTE="Bauers-Twin"][QUOTE="samuraiguns"]

Definetly gameplay wise, but not story.

raven_squad

But then again my friend, to each his own. unless, opinion is now the new fact.