luzarius said:
Okay democrats, leftists, liberals, left wing, socialists, communists or whatever you are now, why do you hate hot, sexy babes in games?
Ask yourself that question in a real life setting with normal people. When they laugh at you for asking stupid questions, finally ask yourself, "am I able to use the cognitive function in my head?" People do have a problem with it. Some of it is stupid, some actually have valid points. Lumping the left-spectrum doesn't make any sense.
Look at Dragon Age Inquisition, Mass Effect Andromeda, Horizon Dawn Zero, Dishonored death of outsider, Hellblade. All the women npcs in these games are extremely ugly.
Seriously? They're ugly? Okay now. Sure......
You remind me of this dude who matched with an attractive girl on tinder, complained that she was actually ugly without make-up (I shit you not) and then takes home a fat chick who couldn't even compare to that attractive girl without makeup on tinder. But then again, beauty is what it is to the beholder so what do I know?
One of the arguments made against over-sexualiziation of women (and men) in videogames is that it sets an unrealistic precedent on how men and women should appear in real life. If you think the main female character from Horizon: Dawn Zero or any of the characters from any other of the games are ugly, I think they have a point and maybe you should stop laying videogames and get back to the real world.
I don't mind game devs adding attractive, sexy NPCS for girl gamers or gay gamers, you guys can have eye candy too.
The day Call of Duty introduces scantily-clad SAS fighting Siberian underwear models from Russia and hot ankle-showing burqa-wearing women from the Middle East is the day I take this thread, or you, seriously than N64DD's posts.
Here are some sample pictures of what I'd like to see more in games:
If you want more of that, you can always buy barbie dolls. Or Bratz but that might be weird. Very weird.
Anyways, TC's OP is dumb but it does introduce an important question as to why scantily-clad characters can be controversial.
Depends on the theme, time and audience
The reason why Quiet from MGS5's outfit didn't make sense is the reason why Valeria from Conan the Barbarian's outfit makes sense, and is the reason why pornos involving scantily-clad actors and actresses makes sense and so does the amount of innuendo from Game of Thrones makes sense (or most of the times). In the end, it comes down to the theme and who your target audience is.
Time is a different manner. What made sense in the 80s may not make sense right now but we still appreciate the quality of the past because it had a good story and theme to back it up at the time. Today, I want to say that the industry is interested in making entertainment interesting with stories that hold on to you, complex characters that you can't absolutely hate or love, and introducing themes that makes you question things. So, in other words, two-dimensional barbie dolls are now outdated because people want interesting and complex female characters. Or sometimes they make nostalgic pieces with an 80s theme that is still fun and perky and still introduce scantily-clad characters because it fits with the theme.
And finally, audience. Who is playing the game? It's also women but also teenagers, families, parents, kids, whoever. Basically, almost everyone is playing videogames and sometimes the ESRB rating doesn't matter anymore (same reason why kids play Halo and CoD and why they don't have scantily-clad barbie dolls).
Again, it has to work for the theme and the time, as well as the audience you're producing it for. Most people don't like scantily-clad women not because they hate beautiful women. It's because it doesn't make that much sense unless it works with the theme of the story. Duke Nukem's scantily-clad women made more sense than Quiet from MGS5 and that's saying a lot.
---
Now as for the arguments against having scantily-clad women, it's a stereotypical and over-used cliche that, and people have argued, can have a negative effect on male gamer's perception on how women should dress and/or act. Similar arguments have been used on why pornos can have the same negative effect.
Overall, those making the argument against having scantily-clad women have valid points but I don't think it has to do with hating on beautiful women in games, just more that it sets an unrealistic precedent by making them most likely 2-dimensional characters with nothing interesting about them.
Now before you say it, and I know you will say it, yes, unrealistic representation of men can also have a negative consequence on men and women alike.
Log in to comment