I agree with andyboii, but I'll take it even further. I don't think Starks is in Bowens class as a defender. Starks was 6'5", 190lbs, Bowen is listed as 6'7", 200. Bowen made the 1st team All defense 5 years straight, after making the 2nd team 3 years straight. Starks never made the 1st team, and made the 2nd team once (92-93). I admired Starks's heart/hustle, but he was to small for Jordan at 6'6" 216(probably not his weight the first few years, but at least 200). Starks was more like a Raja Bell type of defender, tough/scrappy/pesky. But Bell is listed as 6'5"/206 and made the 1st team all defense once and 2nd team once. Starks gave good effort but was not as good a match for MJ as Bowen would have been.
I took "hand-checking" into consideration for all the above and below, I just think it's effect is overstated concerning great offensive players. I believe a collasping zone, with no "illegal defense" rule is tougher to play against. Getting by the first man is no problem for a great offensive player hand checking or not, it's the 2nd and 3rd man waiting for you that's the problem. Just my opinion.
As far as a comparison of MJ's and Kobe's defenders: (BTW, Detroit and New York were not the only teams in the NBA in MJ's day. He faced some mediore and bad defensive teams also, including expansion teams. And after a certain point, when MJ really got established, several complained that you were not allowed to lay a hand on him without a whistle. So his whole career was not spent fighting through and conquering great/tough defenses.)
MJ (6'6", 216): Dumars, 6'3/195, Starks, 6'5"/190, Dennis Johnson, 6'4"/185 (but was already in the NBA 8-9 years before MJ and probably not at his atheletic/defensive best), Paul Pressy, 6'5"/185, Sidney Moncrief, 6'3"/180, Alvin Robertson, 6'3"/185,... Michael Cooper, 6'5"/170, Derek Harper, 6'4"185, Nate McMillian, 6'5" (Cooper, Harper and McMillian all were excellent defenders but played mostly in the west and didn't face MJ that much), Bobby Phills, 6'5"/226
Kobe(6'6", 205): Bruce Bowen, 6'7"/200, Raja Bell, 6'5"/206, Shane Battier, 6'8"/220, Thabo Sefalosa, 6'7"/215, Ron Artest, 6"7"/260 really!, Doug Christie, 6'6"/200, Matt Barnes, 6'7"/226, Rueben Patterson, 6'5"/224,.....Gary Payton could go on either list but played in the west so didn't face MJ much (shame cause he could D MJ up), but probably didn't face Kobe much either playing the point. Also Rueben Patterson (6'5"/224) didn't make a All Defensive list but was a pesky defender against Kobe (but not a "Kobe Stopper"!)
I may have missed some guys on either side. But none of MJ's defenders (on this list) were 200+lbs, and of his primary defenders in the east all were 6'5" or below, yes they could hand check.
All of Kobe's primary opponents on D were 6'5" or more and all were 200+ lbs, hand-checking or not they were all physical and would get up in his jersey(Bowen, Bell, Battier, Sefalosa, Artest, Christie, Barnes. Those guys were bigger, bulkier, and still atheletic enough to be very good defenders, as good if not better in some cases than MJ faced. But you be the judge.
Kobe on that 05 team was no more of a "ball hog" than MJ would have been
Log in to comment