If you could pick one QB......

..to lead your team, who would it be? Forget championships, we are talking pure QB skills. I would take Elway. He had the cannon arm, he was mobile, and could grasp victory in the final seconds time and time again. Dan Fouts and Warren Moon get a nod.

Joe Montana

If we're talking current players it's Tom Brady

Any other pick means you're thinking about something other then winning

petyon. he is just the best.

Accuracy, power, smarts, everything. i don't even know why they have a OC

LebronX360PS3AMD05

[QUOTE="X360PS3AMD05"]LebronM_1_A_M_I

Peyton Manning, because he is the most clutch QB of all time.

Peyton Manning, because he is the most clutch QB of all time.

theone86

Did you happen to watch the last Superbowl?

[QUOTE="theone86"]

Peyton Manning, because he is the most clutch QB of all time.

Jaysonguy

Did you happen to watch the last Superbowl?

[QUOTE="Jaysonguy"]

[QUOTE="theone86"]

Peyton Manning, because he is the most clutch QB of all time.

i5750at4Ghz

Did you happen to watch the last Superbowl?

And how many picks has he thrown in the clutch? How many late game comebacks has he had in his career? How many times has he been at his own 10 or 20 and put on a passing attack that goes for a touchdown? The man is clutch, he can orchestrate a comeback at any time.

Peyton Manning.

Peyton Manning, because he is the most clutch QB of all time.

theone86

[QUOTE="theone86"]

Peyton Manning, because he is the most clutch QB of all time.

monkeytoes61

And how many picks has he thrown in the clutch? How many late game comebacks has he had in his career? How many times has he been at his own 10 or 20 and put on a passing attack that goes for a touchdown? The man is clutch, he can orchestrate a comeback at any time.

theone86

I seriously find it amazing that last season people were calling him the greatest QB of all time, then he throws one pick at a bad time and suddenly he's not so great anymore.

[QUOTE="theone86"]

Peyton Manning, because he is the most clutch QB of all time.

monkeytoes61

[QUOTE="monkeytoes61"][QUOTE="theone86"]

Peyton Manning, because he is the most clutch QB of all time.

i5750at4Ghz

i don't know this question has too many variables. The obvious answer would be joe montana but that's ONLY IF he's quarterbacking those great 49'ers teams of the 80's. What would happen if he wasplaying for the bills "TEAMS" that lost 4 super bowls? Would i want him then? who knows. Some people will just never get it. No matter how "clutch" a qb is, he has to have the "team" around him on all sides of the ball to win. I mean i can argue Marino cause he never had elite players on offense, defense or special teams but yet is still put in the same class as the Montana's and every other "great" qb that has multiple championships. So maybe he would be able to get the best out of the least. I don't know. It's just too loaded of a question

[QUOTE="monkeytoes61"][QUOTE="i5750at4Ghz"] Again go watch the play on you tube. Wr fault not his.i5750at4Ghz

[QUOTE="i5750at4Ghz"][QUOTE="monkeytoes61"] Tracy Porter, 74 yards, touchdown, 31-17 Saints. Yeah, real clutch :roll:monkeytoes61

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GJFOBI1cZaM

LOOK AT THIS AND STOP TALKING PLZ.

Either Montana or Unitas.

Elway gets an honorable mention for his 4th Quarter comebacks.

[QUOTE="i5750at4Ghz"][QUOTE="monkeytoes61"] Doesn't matter whose fault it is, that is subjective and unprovable anyways. The point is, with the game on the line, Peyton Manning threw and interception.monkeytoes61

[QUOTE="monkeytoes61"]

[QUOTE="i5750at4Ghz"] Again go watch the play on you tube. Wr fault not his.i5750at4Ghz

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GJFOBI1cZaM

LOOK AT THIS AND STOP TALKING PLZ.

[QUOTE="i5750at4Ghz"][QUOTE="monkeytoes61"] Doesn't matter whose fault it is, that is subjective and unprovable anyways. The point is, with the game on the line, Peyton Manning threw and interception.monkeytoes61

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GJFOBI1cZaM

LOOK AT THIS AND STOP TALKING PLZ.

Porter caught the interception, Lewis dropped it. They're both legendary QBs who made 1 mistake, 1 got punished and is somehow all of a sudden a choker, the other one got lucky and got away with it and is somehow the most clutch QB of all-time.

Kanye west: peyton manning is a great quarterback and imma let u finish but terry bradshaw had one of the greatest touchdowns of all time

[QUOTE="i5750at4Ghz"][QUOTE="monkeytoes61"] Doesn't matter whose fault it is, that is subjective and unprovable anyways. The point is, with the game on the line, Peyton Manning threw and interception.monkeytoes61

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GJFOBI1cZaM

LOOK AT THIS AND STOP TALKING PLZ.

It would be split between Favre, Montana and Marino.

[QUOTE="monkeytoes61"][QUOTE="i5750at4Ghz"]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GJFOBI1cZaM

LOOK AT THIS AND STOP TALKING PLZ.

Darth_Revan_666

Porter caught the interception, Lewis dropped it. They're both legendary QBs who made 1 mistake, 1 got punished and is somehow all of a sudden a choker, the other one got lucky and got away with it and is somehow the most clutch QB of all-time.

THANK YOU. And even if you do put that INT squarely on Manning, the argument that it suddenly makes him not clutch is total crap anyways. Is there really a QB who has ever played that can say they've never thrown a pick on a drive where they needed a score? No, they've all made mistakes from time to time. One pick, ONE, out of the multiple times that Manning has driven his team from inside his own ten or twenty to score is frankly nothing. When the Colts need a score, nine times out of ten he gives it to them no matter how much time is left or how far he has to go. You seriously cannot sit there with a stratight face and say that just because it's nine times out of ten instead of ten out of ten he isn't a clutch QB anymore, it's a completely invalid argument.

michael vick...he was just become that passer everybody wanted to see then boom the dog fighting case.

[QUOTE="Darth_Revan_666"]

[QUOTE="monkeytoes61"] What does this prove exactly? Look this thread wasn't supposed to be a huge argument about Peyton Manning. So I will say this, and nothing more. It does not matter why or how it happened. Montana didn't throw the INT and Manning did. theone86

Porter caught the interception, Lewis dropped it. They're both legendary QBs who made 1 mistake, 1 got punished and is somehow all of a sudden a choker, the other one got lucky and got away with it and is somehow the most clutch QB of all-time.

THANK YOU. And even if you do put that INT squarely on Manning, the argument that it suddenly makes him not clutch is total crap anyways. Is there really a QB who has ever played that can say they've never thrown a pick on a drive where they needed a score? No, they've all made mistakes from time to time. One pick, ONE, out of the multiple times that Manning has driven his team from inside his own ten or twenty to score is frankly nothing. When the Colts need a score, nine times out of ten he gives it to them no matter how much time is left or how far he has to go. You seriously cannot sit there with a stratight face and say that just because it's nine times out of ten instead of ten out of ten he isn't a clutch QB anymore, it's a completely invalid argument.