MAdden OR 2K Football?

If EA is bringing back the offline multiplayer then most definitely Madden.shawn7324

I'm buying all three games (Madden, APF, and NCAA).nickdastick

same

I cant beleive madden is puttin out the same trash. It looks the same sounds the same the only new thing is the icons under the players. ea needs 2 fire every one that works on this game and get some true fans 2 help the new developers with ideas 4 next years madden. Everyone at ea should embarrassed.

Madden and NCAA

[QUOTE="shawn7324"]If EA is bringing back the offline multiplayer then most definitely Madden.NetYankEagle

i think hes sayin like 2 v 2 or 4 players on one team

[QUOTE="NetYankEagle"][QUOTE="shawn7324"]If EA is bringing back the offline multiplayer then most definitely Madden.Magna_Man109

i think hes sayin like 2 v 2 or 4 players on one team

Yeah, they put it back into the game so you can do more than just 1 v 1 which is pretty pathetic for a football game since you could do 2 v 2 on the older systems!

madden of course but i'm gonna check out all pro, it's got montana and rice but alas no young (right?).rabidwolf86

It doesn't have Young?

MADDEN, ALWAYS MADDEN! they have madden tournaments not 2K tourneys

Who will buy the 2k football game? I will have to buy both.If 2k football has the same presentation like it did 3 years ago then I think it will be no denying which one of the two will be the best this year. Even if Madden is better this year I think this should stillgive thedevelopers at EA some fire under themto do a little bit more with that exclusive rights they have with the NFL.dblock137

I will get neither. I'm only buying NCAA this yearBadAndy642

same here

yeah after Madden 07 i'm leaving this years alone until i borrow someone elses and see how it plays

2k's Retirement Football league is just a no..

so yeah NCAA 08 it is

That's where you are wrong! You obviously didn't play NCAA otherwise you would have never made that statement!

I played both NCAA 07 and Madden 07. I thought the same way you did when I bought NCAA last year. I sold it to get the bigger brother Madden, thinking that it was going to have the same gameplay. I regret ever giving up my NCAA 07!! NCAA was a completely different game to Madden. NCAA had faster gameplay, different features,and was much more fun than Madden. I never understood how two games from the same company can be so different. I will get NCAA and Madden this year and not make that same mistake again. I will also check out APF 2K8

I don't know what the point of getting NCAA football is unless you are a big college fan. It is the same thing as Madden but watered down in some areas.nygiants1080

[QUOTE="rabidwolf86"]madden of course but i'm gonna check out all pro, it's got montana and rice but alas no young (right?).Renegade_Fury

It doesn't have Young?

I saw a video where a QB wearing #8 threw the ball with his left hand to Jerry Rice... so I'm hoping that is Young. He is my fave QB and that's why I have been trying to find a list of the players but I have yet to find it... Young has to be in it though!

[QUOTE="Renegade_Fury"]

[QUOTE="rabidwolf86"]madden of course but i'm gonna check out all pro, it's got montana and rice but alas no young (right?).nickdastick

It doesn't have Young?

I saw a video where a QB wearing #8 threw the ball with his left hand to Jerry Rice... so I'm hoping that is Young. He is my fave QB and that's why I have been trying to find a list of the players but I have yet to find it... Young has to be in it though!

Yeah, Young is my favorite too. I know what Joe did (I've seen virtually every documentary covering him and have multiple 49ers history DVDs), but I was too young to see most of it for myself. The only games I vividly remember Joe playing in were SB XXIII (my very first memory of ever watching football) and SB XXIV. Even though I know Joe is probably the greatest qb of all time, Steve is the guy I grew up watching. I even remember playing as Young in the very first NFL 2K game for DC, so he has just got to be in this game!

[QUOTE="nickdastick"][QUOTE="Renegade_Fury"]

[QUOTE="rabidwolf86"]madden of course but i'm gonna check out all pro, it's got montana and rice but alas no young (right?).Renegade_Fury

It doesn't have Young?

I saw a video where a QB wearing #8 threw the ball with his left hand to Jerry Rice... so I'm hoping that is Young. He is my fave QB and that's why I have been trying to find a list of the players but I have yet to find it... Young has to be in it though!

Yeah, Young is my favorite too. I know what Joe did (I've seen virtually every documentary covering him and have multiple 49ers history DVDs), but I was too young to see most of it for myself. The only games I vividly remember Joe playing in were SB XXIII (my very first memory of ever watching football) and SB XXIV. Even though I know Joe is probably the greatest qb of all time, Steve is the guy I grew up watching. I even remember playing as Young in the very first NFL 2K game for DC, so he has just got to be in this game!

Yeah, Young was the highest rated QB in NFL 2K for DC I believe. Joe Montana is amazing and I watched him when I was a kid but Steve Young went to BYU which is my fave college and he is left handed and could run with the best of them so he takes the top spot for me. Plus, Steve Young had what is considered by many to be the best season ever by a QB and he has the best QB rating off all time (I think Warner is/was higher but he is still playing and I'm sure it will drop if it hasn't already). I swear it was him in the video though so here's hoping!

I'm gonna play all three, but will just own NCAA and Madden.

I believe you may know this already but Steve Young is in the game. I played with him last night and he's very good. Gold Tier player

[QUOTE="Renegade_Fury"][QUOTE="nickdastick"][QUOTE="Renegade_Fury"]

[QUOTE="rabidwolf86"]madden of course but i'm gonna check out all pro, it's got montana and rice but alas no young (right?).nickdastick

It doesn't have Young?

I saw a video where a QB wearing #8 threw the ball with his left hand to Jerry Rice... so I'm hoping that is Young. He is my fave QB and that's why I have been trying to find a list of the players but I have yet to find it... Young has to be in it though!

Yeah, Young is my favorite too. I know what Joe did (I've seen virtually every documentary covering him and have multiple 49ers history DVDs), but I was too young to see most of it for myself. The only games I vividly remember Joe playing in were SB XXIII (my very first memory of ever watching football) and SB XXIV. Even though I know Joe is probably the greatest qb of all time, Steve is the guy I grew up watching. I even remember playing as Young in the very first NFL 2K game for DC, so he has just got to be in this game!

Yeah, Young was the highest rated QB in NFL 2K for DC I believe. Joe Montana is amazing and I watched him when I was a kid but Steve Young went to BYU which is my fave college and he is left handed and could run with the best of them so he takes the top spot for me. Plus, Steve Young had what is considered by many to be the best season ever by a QB and he has the best QB rating off all time (I think Warner is/was higher but he is still playing and I'm sure it will drop if it hasn't already). I swear it was him in the video though so here's hoping!

Yeah, right when I started making my team, I saw Steve Young on there and was overcome with joy! He wasn't on any list that people have released so I was worried but now I'm good. I like using him because he has a solid arm and is one of the better running QB's on there.

I believe you may know this already but Steve Young is in the game. I played with him last night and he's very good. Gold Tier player

[QUOTE="nickdastick"][QUOTE="Renegade_Fury"][QUOTE="nickdastick"][QUOTE="Renegade_Fury"]

[QUOTE="rabidwolf86"]madden of course but i'm gonna check out all pro, it's got montana and rice but alas no young (right?).mrvic87

It doesn't have Young?

I saw a video where a QB wearing #8 threw the ball with his left hand to Jerry Rice... so I'm hoping that is Young. He is my fave QB and that's why I have been trying to find a list of the players but I have yet to find it... Young has to be in it though!

Yeah, Young is my favorite too. I know what Joe did (I've seen virtually every documentary covering him and have multiple 49ers history DVDs), but I was too young to see most of it for myself. The only games I vividly remember Joe playing in were SB XXIII (my very first memory of ever watching football) and SB XXIV. Even though I know Joe is probably the greatest qb of all time, Steve is the guy I grew up watching. I even remember playing as Young in the very first NFL 2K game for DC, so he has just got to be in this game!

Yeah, Young was the highest rated QB in NFL 2K for DC I believe. Joe Montana is amazing and I watched him when I was a kid but Steve Young went to BYU which is my fave college and he is left handed and could run with the best of them so he takes the top spot for me. Plus, Steve Young had what is considered by many to be the best season ever by a QB and he has the best QB rating off all time (I think Warner is/was higher but he is still playing and I'm sure it will drop if it hasn't already). I swear it was him in the video though so here's hoping!