I prefer Madden. You can afford to lose a few games during the season, while you'll lose your National Championship hopes in NCAA. NCAA makes it that much more challenging. One thing in Madden i like is that you can fully develop your NFL squadover the years. Just my opinions.
Yeah, I usually end up getting Madden just cuz I don't watch a lot of college football (just the bowl games pretty much), and I do agree that Madden usually seems half a step ahead as far as gameplay goes.
I prefer Madden. You can afford to lose a few games during the season, while you'll lose your National Championship hopes in NCAA. NCAA makes it that much more challenging. One thing in Madden i like is that you can fully develop your NFL squadover the years. Just my opinions.bluezy
pretty much what i was guna say that its an actual franchise where NCAA is u just pick guys and their gone and u cant focus on one guy at all
Madden is always the better overall game. I do like NCAA but it always seems to be a year behind with features and gameplay. So yeah, Madden for me.nickdastick
[QUOTE="nickdastick"]Madden is always the better overall game. I do like NCAA but it always seems to be a year behind with features and gameplay. So yeah, Madden for me.geaux321
I've always felt the opposite.
On the old systems Madden always had the new features a year before NCAA like hit stick, hot routes, etc. NCAA is always fun but gameplay-wise they usually always have less than Madden.
[QUOTE="nickdastick"]Madden is always the better overall game. I do like NCAA but it always seems to be a year behind with features and gameplay. So yeah, Madden for me.nickdastick
I've always felt the opposite.
On the old systems Madden always had the new features a year before NCAA like hit stick, hot routes, etc. NCAA is always fun but gameplay-wise they usually always have less than Madden.
Obviously the features were a year behind, but in the game I felt NCAA was always better.
I've always enjoyed ncaa football more than madden but they dissapointed me playing at 30fps on the ps3, rather than 60 like the xbox360.I'm hoping madden won't make the same mistake on the ps3.
NCAA is for the big college football fans, I've always felt college football isbetter because every single game counts where as NFL and madden if you lose one game it's no big deal but if you lose 1-2 games in NCAA you're out of the national championship, the gameplay for NCAA football for last gen systems were great ncaa football 04-06 but for the 360 it has been disappointing
People are too focused on the pros/superstars in Madden since NCAA has college players. Yet if you take that aspect away, even with the features being introduced later, NCAA is always better in terms of gameplay. I just can never understand why two games from the same company turn out to be so different. If the gameplay from both were identical, then this thread wouldn't exist. Well there would be a silly thread asking if you prefer the NFL stars vs. no name college players.
NCAA 07 hadmuch better gameplay than Madden 07. I am hoping that this year's Madden will be differentthis year. We'll find out in 8 days!
Log in to comment