1UP gives UT3 a 6/10, GS gives 8.5/10 to PS3 version

[QUOTE="Dante2710"]i guess its true what hermits say.....higher standards :?CaseyWegner

don't you feel ashamed for ever doubting them?

Downgrade confirmed. Can't wait till the completed version is out for the 360.

ReverseCycology

hahahaah its going to have less maps and possibly no mods... how is that the completed version?

They gave the PC version 6.0...

They gave the PS3 version 8.0

Thread FAILED

asdasd

Fisson mailed!

With a couple mods the PC version will be what UT2004 was.trizzle_a

With a few mods you could give Unreal Tournament 2004 UT3 quality graphics. I think that would be more worthwhile.

http://n4g.com/pc/News-93894.aspx

http://n4g.com/ps3/News-93900.aspx

but teh GS is biased

discuss!

Mad_Rhetoric

R&C got a 7.5

Mass Effect got a 8.5

Zelda TP got a 8.8

Pretty much everyone else that matters gave these games AAA.

This should tell you something.

Gamespot and 1up like the shockeffect.

[QUOTE="Mad_Rhetoric"]

http://n4g.com/pc/News-93894.aspx

http://n4g.com/ps3/News-93900.aspx

but teh GS is biased

discuss!

GabeBlack

R&C got a 7.5

Mass Effect got a 8.5

Zelda TP got a 8.8

Pretty much everyone else that matters gave these games AAA.

This should tell you something.

Gamespot and 1up like the shockeffect.

1up Sucks! Spoiler heaven.

1up Sucks! Spoiler heaven.

Shomb22

GS lost it's best reviewer Jeff. I for one depended on Jeff's reviews cause he don't let anything slide and he saved me tons of money on bad games.

It is a well known fact that Sony pays GS money for scores.DaysAirlines

there goes cows conspiracy theorys. what's next, "bubu teh scores are hacked"?

Okay, and as you know PC version is the one to get.

PS: GS scores mean next to nothing anymore.
Saturos3091

Um no not really. The game that has that speed and that many people in one game is simply a pointless fragfest they should have slowed downt he pace some it really is a little ridiculous.

The PC version is superior and this is gamespot not 1up.-wii60-

LOL no its really not. Playing both the game simply feels better on a console.

[QUOTE="-wii60-"]The PC version is superior and this is gamespot not 1up.Polaris_choice

LOL no its really not. Playing both the game simply feels better on a console.

PC version is better, but whatever helps you sleep :lol:

[QUOTE="Polaris_choice"]

[QUOTE="-wii60-"]The PC version is superior and this is gamespot not 1up.100Gamer

LOL no its really not. Playing both the game simply feels better on a console.

PC version is better, but whatever helps you sleep :lol:

Uh thats why the PS3 version is getting rated either the same or higher but you have never touched a PS3 in your life while I have played on both platforms . In other words you dont even need to be speaking on the matter.

[QUOTE="Saturos3091"]Okay, and as you know PC version is the one to get.

PS: GS scores mean next to nothing anymore.
Polaris_choice

Um no not really. The game that has that speed and that many people in one game is simply a pointless fragfest they should have slowed downt he pace some it really is a little ridiculous.

you can make the ps3 version superfast with mutators. I played an online game at hyperspeed. Everything was moving stupid fast, and the weapons fire was ridiculously fast. It was a good time. Speed is what UT games are all about. Its not pointless at all, but it is tons of fun. You just have to be good at the game to cope with it.

[QUOTE="100Gamer"][QUOTE="Polaris_choice"]

[QUOTE="-wii60-"]The PC version is superior and this is gamespot not 1up.Polaris_choice

LOL no its really not. Playing both the game simply feels better on a console.

PC version is better, but whatever helps you sleep :lol:

Uh thats why the PS3 version is getting rated either the same or higher but you have never touched a PS3 in your life while I have played on both platforms . In other words you dont even need to be speaking on the matter.

[QUOTE="100Gamer"][QUOTE="Polaris_choice"]

[QUOTE="-wii60-"]The PC version is superior and this is gamespot not 1up.Polaris_choice

LOL no its really not. Playing both the game simply feels better on a console.

PC version is better, but whatever helps you sleep :lol:

Uh thats why the PS3 version is getting rated either the same or higher but you have never touched a PS3 in your life while I have played on both platforms . In other words you dont even need to be speaking on the matter.

because pc has higher standard kiddo :|

[QUOTE="CaseyWegner"]

[QUOTE="Dante2710"]i guess its true what hermits say.....higher standards :?Dante2710

don't you feel ashamed for ever doubting them?

can't say you don't deserve it.

[QUOTE="CaseyWegner"]

[QUOTE="Kahuna_1"]What? Last time I checked gamerankings GS was at the bottom being beaten only by gamersTM and a few other unknown sites.Kahuna_1

for a few games? how compelling.

Nah just for the 1st party titles...which are a few games I suppose...Sony shoulda cut a few checks :lol:.

great. you're going to perpetuate another anti-sony myth. join the club, i guess. :?

[QUOTE="-wii60-"]The PC version is superior and this is gamespot not 1up.Polaris_choice

LOL no its really not. Playing both the game simply feels better on a console.

[QUOTE="Mad_Rhetoric"]

http://n4g.com/pc/News-93894.aspx

http://n4g.com/ps3/News-93900.aspx

but teh GS is biased

discuss!

GabeBlack

R&C got a 7.5

Mass Effect got a 8.5

Zelda TP got a 8.8

Pretty much everyone else that matters gave these games AAA.

This should tell you something.

Gamespot and 1up like the shockeffect.

you picked three examples. i can give you a bunch of examples where their reviews matched most others. what are you trying to do? :?

They probably just don't want to get fired...Lazy_not_fat

i'm sure many, many gamers are thinking the same thing..

gs' reviews just aren't credible anymore.... imo.... (had to add the "imo" for fear of being banned for having an opinion, again)

IGN = Nintendo Biased (one of the editor's wife works for nintendo)

1up /EGM= Microsoft Biased (Official Games for Windows Magazine, and if you notice they rate Xbox 360 games higher than other websites/magazines. Also they were the only ones to give Halo 3 a 10)

Gamespot = Advertiser Biased (if you pay to advertise on their website, the scores go up 1 point)

Gamepro = Hype Biased (if a game gets a lot of hype, it'll get a perfect score, if a game gets no hype but is awesome it'll get a low score)

Game Informer = Store Biased (Game Informer is owned by Gamestop, they're trying to sell you everything)

Downgrade confirmed. Can't wait till the completed version is out for the 360.

ReverseCycology

I love how when a PS3 game gets a low score it sucked and GS are tough reviewers, but when it gets a high score, Gamespot scores don't mean anything and they are no longer biased.

"Gamespot is all that matters" until it gives a good score to a game you don't like, amirite? Then it's all about 1up, 1up is the source. Everyone trusts 1up.

1. Gamespot's score is meaningless.

2. The PC version is CLEARLY better then the PS# version.

3. I'll bet you the Xbox 360 verison will score higher then the PS3 version when it comes out.

[QUOTE="ReverseCycology"]

Downgrade confirmed. Can't wait till the completed version is out for the 360.

excelR83

I love how when a PS3 game gets a low score it sucked and GS are tough reviewers, but when it gets a high score, Gamespot scores don't mean anything and they are no longer biased.

"Gamespot is all that matters" until it gives a good score to a game you don't like, amirite? Then it's all about 1up, 1up is the source. Everyone trusts 1up.

exactly, what a load of bull

[QUOTE="Kahuna_1"][QUOTE="100Gamer"][QUOTE="Sony_92"]

[QUOTE="Kahuna_1"]It is a multiplat.......CaseyWegner

Its a 2007 PS3 exclusive. Its a timed exclusive but so what and PC doesnt count cause if if does, then the 360 has like 1 good exclusive.

no such thing as console exclusive, let it go cows, it's getting pathetic.
and 360 has 4 AAAE, you fail :lol:

Yeah my point is that this site is constantly at the bottom when it comes to scores for PS3 exclusives.

gamespot? are you kidding? :|

Why do you feel the constant need to jump to their defense?

well this just proves that system wars is full of anti-ps3 fanboys. If you read the thread in one go (like i did) you can see that everyone was for what the TC had said, i saw loads of ps3 bashing about how it was downgraded or inferior. Then after the guy who posted that ps3 version got higher than the pc version, people still continue to bash the ps3 for different reasons, "oh pc has higher standard" (which i think is just plain bull), "can anyone really take 1up seriously". Arjdagr8

That's how SW works. God forbid you speak out in favor of the PS3 because it's "disruptive posting" or "intending solely to annoy other users". On the other hand, if you say "PS3 is a stupid idiot poo poo head console and anyone who owns one is a doo doo brain poopy fart face" your thread will be deemed acceptable, because the mods agree that the PS3 is for poo poo doody stinky heads.

1. Gamespot's score is meaningless.

2. The PC version is CLEARLY better then the PS# version.

3. I'll bet you the Xbox 360 verison will score higher then the PS3 version when it comes out.

Netherscourge

Oh, the irony. Gamespot scores don't mean anything, but you're predicting the 360 version will score higher. Will it mean something if that's the case? I like how you only waited like 10 words to totally contradict yourself. "Gamespot scores don't mean ****, but the 360 version will get a better score, thus proving the superiority of the 360!"

The best part though is the last four words: "When it comes out". Yes, when it finally comes out. Funny how the shoe is on the other foot this time, and UT, a traditionally well-loved game, is suddenly a POS because it's out first on the PS3.

[QUOTE="Arjdagr8"]well this just proves that system wars is full of anti-ps3 fanboys. If you read the thread in one go (like i did) you can see that everyone was for what the TC had said, i saw loads of ps3 bashing about how it was downgraded or inferior. Then after the guy who posted that ps3 version got higher than the pc version, people still continue to bash the ps3 for different reasons, "oh pc has higher standard" (which i think is just plain bull), "can anyone really take 1up seriously". excelR83

That's how SW works. God forbid you speak out in favor of the PS3 because it's "disruptive posting" or "intending solely to annoy other users". On the other hand, if you say "PS3 is a stupid idiot poo poo head console and anyone who owns one is a doo doo brain poopy fart face" your thread will be deemed acceptable, because the mods agree that the PS3 is for poo poo doody stinky heads.

1. Gamespot's score is meaningless.

2. The PC version is CLEARLY better then the PS# version.

3. I'll bet you the Xbox 360 verison will score higher then the PS3 version when it comes out.

Netherscourge

Oh, the irony. Gamespot scores don't mean anything, but you're predicting the 360 version will score higher. Will it mean something if that's the case? I like how you only waited like 10 words to totally contradict yourself. "Gamespot scores don't mean ****, but the 360 version will get a better score, thus proving the superiority of the 360!"

The best part though is the last four words: "When it comes out". Yes, when it finally comes out. Funny how the shoe is on the other foot this time, and UT, a traditionally well-loved game, is suddenly a POS because it's out first on the PS3.

loll haha. yeah. jeez that irony is like...wtf. Yeah ive been noticing that so much, but this thread just proves it.

the game is crap no matter what system it is on (pc or ps3)MikeE21286

Agree more or less...but better than halo serie tho.

[QUOTE="MikeE21286"]the game is crap no matter what system it is on (pc or ps3)aroxx_ab

Agree more or less...but better than halo serie tho.

Are you telling me that UT3 is better than every halo game released?

[QUOTE="CaseyWegner"][QUOTE="Kahuna_1"][QUOTE="100Gamer"][QUOTE="Sony_92"]

[QUOTE="Kahuna_1"]It is a multiplat.......excelR83

Its a 2007 PS3 exclusive. Its a timed exclusive but so what and PC doesnt count cause if if does, then the 360 has like 1 good exclusive.

no such thing as console exclusive, let it go cows, it's getting pathetic.
and 360 has 4 AAAE, you fail :lol:

Yeah my point is that this site is constantly at the bottom when it comes to scores for PS3 exclusives.

gamespot? are you kidding? :|

Why do you feel the constant need to jump to their defense?

careful, if you challenge him you might get banned.