2010: The Results (PC=Wii>>>>360>PS3)

The fact that the Wii gets almost none of the AA, AAA, multiplats is a killer for the system. Like it or not its a fact.

Nintendo has become almost secluded to itself in the gaming industry nowdays, somewhat seperate from the games that are being released on the 360, PS3, and PC platforms. Its just not the same. To say that if you could have only one device to play video games on, you would choose the Wii would seem like madness.

evilross

1. There is proof that GS is kind of biased in favor of the 360 for scoring.kuraimen

Wait.......people think Kinect games shouldnt be counted? there full games no? Its like not counting Majoras Mask because you need the expansion pack to play it.

1- Wii = 36 As

2- PC = 34 As

3- PS3 = 18 As

4- 360 = 16 As

I guess thats how you should count it, it's Quality over Quantity.

1- Wii = 36 As

2- PC = 34 As

3- PS3 = 18 As

4- 360 = 16 As

I guess thats how you should count it.

Kashiwaba

BTW! what about DS and PSP which one won 2010?

Just the way I like it. Nintendo and PC at the top 8)

[QUOTE="kuraimen"]1. There is proof that GS is kind of biased in favor of the 360 for scoring.IronBass

MGS4 (AAAA) and Resistence2 (AAA) should be enough to prove him wrong....;)

[QUOTE="Kashiwaba"]

1- Wii = 36 As

2- PC = 34 As

3- PS3 = 18 As

4- 360 = 16 As

I guess thats how you should count it.

themyth01

Indeed!

Still 360 would win that one in 2011 :P

This is the most stupidest list, why bother counting the A titles?XenogearsMaster

[QUOTE="XenogearsMaster"]This is the most stupidest list, why bother counting the A titles?Dibdibdobdobo

So can every game regardless of score, or whether it's a multiplat. Tropico 3 on 360 is B scored multiplat, that's also one of my favourite games. I don't have any point here really, ignore my ramblings :)

Oh sweet, another exclusives battle. This should really be interesting.

[QUOTE="XenogearsMaster"]This is the most stupidest list, why bother counting the A titles?Dibdibdobdobo

[QUOTE="Dibdibdobdobo"][QUOTE="XenogearsMaster"]This is the most stupidest list, why bother counting the A titles?locopatho

So can every game regardless of score, or whether it's a multiplat. Tropico 3 on 360 is B scored multiplat, that's also one of my favourite games. I don't have any point here really, ignore my ramblings :)

[QUOTE="Dibdibdobdobo"][QUOTE="XenogearsMaster"]This is the most stupidest list, why bother counting the A titles?XenogearsMaster

[QUOTE="XenogearsMaster"][QUOTE="Dibdibdobdobo"] Because they can be played and can be found enjoyable by many people.Dibdibdobdobo

[QUOTE="Dibdibdobdobo"][QUOTE="XenogearsMaster"] Because I thought winning something means you would require quality not some average game. Quality > Quantity.blue_hazy_basic

[QUOTE="kuraimen"]1. There is proof that GS is kind of biased in favor of the 360 for scoring.IronBass

The sheet that proves GS bias

360 got

Mass Effect 2 (GOTY)

Halo Reach (GOTY)

Alan Wake (GOTY)

Splinter Cell

Limbo

RDR (GOTY)

Bayonetta (GOTY)

Fable 3

Fallout Vegas

so by default wins over anything, it is the only one to have4 GOTY games and the best versions of RDR, Bayonetta, Vegas in consoles

http://neogaf.net/forum/showthread.php?s=ffcdb82a33bc3a68717200a7adc658f4&t=415766

Current standings...

Red Dead Redemption - 6 (best version on xbox 360)
Mass Effect 2 - 4 (only on 360/PC)
Super Mario Galaxy 2 - 4
Alan Wake - 1 (xbox 360)
Assassin's Creed: Brotherhood - 1
Bayonetta - 1 (best version on 360)
BioShock 2 - 1 (best version on 360)


So, 360 > PC >>> Wii >>>>>>>>>> PS3

[QUOTE="IronBass"][QUOTE="kuraimen"]1. There is proof that GS is kind of biased in favor of the 360 for scoring.kuraimen

The sheet that proves GS bias

[QUOTE="kuraimen"]

I'd love to see it.IronBass

The sheet that proves GS bias

[QUOTE="kuraimen"]

The sheet that proves GS bias

[QUOTE="kuraimen"]

[QUOTE="IronBass"] I'd love to see it.Bigboi500

The sheet that proves GS bias

[QUOTE="IronBass"][QUOTE="kuraimen"]1. There is proof that GS is kind of biased in favor of the 360 for scoring.kuraimen

The sheet that proves GS bias

[QUOTE="Bigboi500"]

[QUOTE="kuraimen"]

The sheet that proves GS bias

h575309

[QUOTE="IronBass"][QUOTE="kuraimen"]1. There is proof that GS is kind of biased in favor of the 360 for scoring.kuraimen

The sheet that proves GS bias

[QUOTE="h575309"][QUOTE="Bigboi500"]Another thing that proves GS is bias towards the 360 is our profiles, when you type in your gamertag, it automatically shows up on your profile, but when you type in your PSN ID, only your PSN ID name shows up, not your PSN card.

[QUOTE="Bigboi500"]

[QUOTE="h575309"] So this confirms that the reviewers will give lower scores to PS3 games eh? I think this is what we call grasping for straws.blue_hazy_basic

GameSpot is bias towards Western systems and Western st Y le games in general because it's a Western site, but it's no big deal unless people took what GS says as the Holy word, and thankfully most knowledgeable people don't.

So expansions now equal a game?:roll:

Sure are alot of those expansions in the PC lineup to make it look like the pc tied..

The wii won this year plain and simple..

[QUOTE="IronBass"][QUOTE="kuraimen"]1. There is proof that GS is kind of biased in favor of the 360 for scoring.kuraimen

The sheet that proves GS bias

[QUOTE="blue_hazy_basic"][QUOTE="Bigboi500"]It just shows where GSs head is at, and which system they give more thought to in general.

GameSpot is bias towards Western systems and Western st Y le games in general because it's a Western site, but it's no big deal unless people took what GS says as the Holy word, and thankfully most knowledgeable people don't.

[QUOTE="blue_hazy_basic"][QUOTE="Bigboi500"]It just shows where GSs head is at, and which system they give more thought to in general.

Bigboi500

GameSpot is bias towards Western systems and Western st Y le games in general because it's a Western site, but it's no big deal unless people took what GS says as the Holy word, and thankfully most knowledgeable people don't.

I'd love to see it.IronBass

The sheet that proves GS bias

What system won GOTY last year again?blue_hazy_basic

GameSpot is bias towards Western systems and Western st Y le games in general because it's a Western site, but it's no big deal unless people took what GS says as the Holy word, and thankfully most knowledgeable people don't.

[QUOTE="Bigboi500"]

[QUOTE="blue_hazy_basic"] What system won GOTY last year again?blue_hazy_basic

GameSpot is bias towards Western systems and Western st Y le games in general because it's a Western site, but it's no big deal unless people took what GS says as the Holy word, and thankfully most knowledgeable people don't.

[QUOTE="blue_hazy_basic"][QUOTE="Bigboi500"]That's just Kevin being....Kevin. :P He's the one who gave NMH a 9.0, and Assassin's Creed a 9.0 also.

GameSpot is bias towards Western systems and Western st Y le games in general because it's a Western site, but it's no big deal unless people took what GS says as the Holy word, and thankfully most knowledgeable people don't.

laughable that god of war 3 and halo reach got AAA's. Reach has major problems, and deserved an 8.5-campaign in comparison to 3 and 1 was pretty mediocre. God of war 3's 2nd half was embarrasingly bad i wanted to turn it off. the gaming review industry gotta love it :lol:Microsoft1234

360 also had deadly preminition, limbo. if you count amesia, a digital download game only, limbo should be counted too i think. then you'd have to go over all the arcade games for ps3 and xbox360 though.

[QUOTE="kuraimen"]

[QUOTE="IronBass"] I'd love to see it.IronBass

The sheet that proves GS bias

Every site will differ, that's not the point, the point is how they differ. In GS case they differ in favor of the 360 and against the PS3 mostly in a significant way which shows bias.kuraimen

The definition of "biased" is not "different from Metacritic", is "unfairly prejudiced".

If the only thing you can prove is that GS scores differentiate from Metacritic (something we all know), then you simply have no proof at all.