360 AAAEs look bland vs PS3 AAAEs

[QUOTE="Stevo_the_gamer"][QUOTE="Odrec"]NGS2 is also vastly different from NGII and MLB09s versions are vastly different in their baseball game kind of way according to IGN.Odrec

They are allowing you to bring proof in. If they weren't open to the idea of changing it, they would just argue against you and not listen.

You simmply cannot supply what we've asked for, and seemn to be content moving in circles with your debate.

Please don't tell me you're being serious.. lol. I hope not, people I know speak highly of you.

Cicatraz_ESP

[QUOTE="Stevo_the_gamer"][QUOTE="falldogout"] Uhh he said HIGH scoring. so obviously he ment AAAEOdrec

[QUOTE="Odrec"][QUOTE="Stevo_the_gamer"]Prove it then.lundy86_4

They are allowing you to bring proof in. If they weren't open to the idea of changing it, they would just argue against you and not listen.

You simmply cannot supply what we've asked for, and seemn to be content moving in circles with your debate.

I have argued this extensibly several times with them. No matter what differences I give they say is not enough.Odrec

[QUOTE="Odrec"][QUOTE="Stevo_the_gamer"]High scoring is so vague and ambiguous that it could easily mean AAs as well.Stevo_the_gamer

[QUOTE="Odrec"]I have argued this extensibly several times with them. No matter what differences I give they say is not enough.Stevo_the_gamer

And 13C and me vastly proved how MLB and NGS2 are vastly different and we don't need to expand why. See how that works?Odrec

[QUOTE="lundy86_4"]

[QUOTE="Odrec"] To whom? to you and Casey? :lol: I know how that works already. As you can see there are several people here who think the classifications are bogus probably as many as the ones who think otherwise so don't bring that up. I and others have given enough prove and to make things simpler is better to consider GRAW exlcusive which I do.Odrec

They are allowing you to bring proof in. If they weren't open to the idea of changing it, they would just argue against you and not listen.

You simmply cannot supply what we've asked for, and seemn to be content moving in circles with your debate.

Then it isn't enough. If Casey weren't open to the idea, he could just lock the topic for getting so ridiculously off topic.

[QUOTE="Odrec"][QUOTE="lundy86_4"]

They are allowing you to bring proof in. If they weren't open to the idea of changing it, they would just argue against you and not listen.

You simmply cannot supply what we've asked for, and seemn to be content moving in circles with your debate.

lundy86_4

Then it isn't enough. If Casey weren't open to the idea, he could just lock the topic for getting so ridiculously off topic.

[QUOTE="lundy86_4"]

[QUOTE="Odrec"] I have argued this extensibly several times with them. No matter what differences I give they say is not enough.Odrec

Then it isn't enough. If Casey weren't open to the idea, he could just lock the topic for getting so ridiculously off topic.

no. that would be trolling.

this is your chance and you are blowing it.

[QUOTE="lundy86_4"]

[QUOTE="Odrec"] I have argued this extensibly several times with them. No matter what differences I give they say is not enough.Odrec

Then it isn't enough. If Casey weren't open to the idea, he could just lock the topic for getting so ridiculously off topic.

How can their be an "objective official party", that's why things are generally decided on via a majority vote.

You can't, because it's decided on System Wars that it is exclusive, if you say it is multiplat it can be seen as trolling (and already has), which will just get you modded.

Yeah because what they consider enough or not is their opinion. There is no official decision made by an objective official party. That's why I can talk about GRAW not being exclusive if I like, it's my opinion.Odrec

Edit: And what casey and lundy said too. xD

[QUOTE="Jamiemydearx3"]

[QUOTE="Luther_10"]

This thread has no charts and no numbers :), and its just my opinion

360 AAAEs

1. Forza Motorsport 2
2. Forza Motorsport 3
3. Halo 3
4. Halo 3 ODST
5. Gears of War 2
6. Perfect Dark Zero

PS3 AAAEs

1. Metal Gear Solid 4
2. Uncharted 2 Among Thieves
3. Demon's Souls
4. Infamous
5. Killzone 2
6. Resistance 2
7. Little Big Planet

RyanShazam

I agree with this guy... Most of the 360 exclusives i still play today after have already beat them, and the PS3 games i only played once and never touched again.

This thread has no charts and no numbers :), and its just my opinion

360 AAAEs

1. Forza Motorsport 2
2. Forza Motorsport 3
3. Halo 3
4. Halo 3 ODST
5. Gears of War 2
6. Perfect Dark Zero

PS3 AAAEs

1. Metal Gear Solid 4
2. Uncharted 2 Among Thieves
3. Demon's Souls
4. Infamous
5. Killzone 2
6. Resistance 2
7. Little Big Planet

Luther_10

[QUOTE="Odrec"][QUOTE="lundy86_4"]

Then it isn't enough. If Casey weren't open to the idea, he could just lock the topic for getting so ridiculously off topic.

lundy86_4

How can their be an "objective official party", that's why things are generally decided on via a majority vote.

You can't, because it's decided on System Wars that it is exclusive, if you say it is multiplat it can be seen as trolling (and already has), which will just get you modded.

[QUOTE="Odrec"][QUOTE="lundy86_4"]

Then it isn't enough. If Casey weren't open to the idea, he could just lock the topic for getting so ridiculously off topic.

CaseyWegner

no. that would be trolling.

this is your chance and you are blowing it.

Disagree with opinion and its trolling. :x Where is the hard evidence that this game isnt muiltiplate.

[QUOTE="Odrec"][QUOTE="lundy86_4"]

Then it isn't enough. If Casey weren't open to the idea, he could just lock the topic for getting so ridiculously off topic.

CaseyWegner

no. that would be trolling.

this is your chance and you are blowing it.

GRAW on Xbox "Looks and feels like a watered-down port" (GS review) and in the review, the review mentions "Too many compromises in the gameplay design, and sloppily integrated assets and ideas from the Xbox 360 version of the game drag this version down into mediocrity."

So because of that^ this game is exclusive to Xbox 360?

But Dead Rising on Wii and 360is considered multiplat, even considering the massive watering downon graphics and gameplayfor the Wii version of the game?

Someone want to explain this to me?

[QUOTE="lundy86_4"]

[QUOTE="Odrec"] Yeah because what they consider enough or not is their opinion. There is no official decision made by an objective official party. That's why I can talk about GRAW not being exclusive if I like, it's my opinion.Odrec

How can their be an "objective official party", that's why things are generally decided on via a majority vote.

You can't, because it's decided on System Wars that it is exclusive, if you say it is multiplat it can be seen as trolling (and already has), which will just get you modded.

If it was dismissed, it was dismissed on the basis that insufficient proof was given, and that the party arguing its multiplat status provided enough proof.

I wasn't talking about strictly System Wars when addressing the majority vote, as many things in life are decided as such.

[QUOTE="CaseyWegner"]

[QUOTE="Odrec"] Yeah because what they consider enough or not is their opinion. There is no official decision made by an objective official party. That's why I can talk about GRAW not being exclusive if I like, it's my opinion.13C

no. that would be trolling.

this is your chance and you are blowing it.

Disagree with opinion and its trolling. :x Where is the hard evidence that this game isnt muiltiplate.

GRAW on Xbox "Looks and feels like a watered-down port" (GS review) and in the review, the review mentions "Too many compromises in the gameplay design, and sloppily integrated assets and ideas from the Xbox 360 version of the game drag this version down into mediocrity."

So because of that^ this game is exclusive to Xbox 360?

But Dead Rising on Wii and 360is considered multiplat, even considering the massive watering downon graphics and gameplayfor the Wii version of the game?

Someone want to explain this to me?

NVIDIATI

Gamespot explains it perfectly:

"Ghost Recon Advanced Warfighter for the Xbox continues the disturbing trend of releasing games on different platforms that have the same name but offer vastly different gaming experiences. If you were wondering if Advanced Warfighter for the Xbox might offer something similar to the superb tactical shooter of the same name on the Xbox 360, you can stop wondering now. It doesn't, and it's not even close."

Yeah because what they consider enough or not is their opinion. There is no official decision made by an objective official party. That's why I can talk about GRAW not being exclusive if I like, it's my opinion.Odrec

no. that would be trolling.

this is your chance and you are blowing it.

[QUOTE="13C"]

[QUOTE="CaseyWegner"]

no. that would be trolling.

this is your chance and you are blowing it.

Odrec

Disagree with opinion and its trolling. :x Where is the hard evidence that this game isnt muiltiplate.

Opinions are allowed, hence why we see IMO, IMHO or any variation in pretty much every thread.

When having a set list, of what is exclusive and non-exclusive, we can't have people go round saying IMO, because then the list means nothing. The list is used to decide on System Wars.

[QUOTE="NVIDIATI"]

GRAW on Xbox "Looks and feels like a watered-down port" (GS review) and in the review, the review mentions "Too many compromises in the gameplay design, and sloppily integrated assets and ideas from the Xbox 360 version of the game drag this version down into mediocrity."

So because of that^ this game is exclusive to Xbox 360?

But Dead Rising on Wii and 360is considered multiplat, even considering the massive watering downon graphics and gameplayfor the Wii version of the game?

Someone want to explain this to me?

Gamespot explains it perfectly:

"Ghost Recon Advanced Warfighter for the Xbox continues the disturbing trend of releasing games on different platforms that have the same name but offer vastly different gaming experiences. If you were wondering if Advanced Warfighter for the Xbox might offer something similar to the superb tactical shooter of the same name on the Xbox 360, you can stop wondering now. It doesn't, and it's not even close."

[QUOTE="Stevo_the_gamer"]

[QUOTE="NVIDIATI"]

GRAW on Xbox "Looks and feels like a watered-down port" (GS review) and in the review, the review mentions "Too many compromises in the gameplay design, and sloppily integrated assets and ideas from the Xbox 360 version of the game drag this version down into mediocrity."

So because of that^ this game is exclusive to Xbox 360?

But Dead Rising on Wii and 360is considered multiplat, even considering the massive watering downon graphics and gameplayfor the Wii version of the game?

Someone want to explain this to me?

NVIDIATI

Gamespot explains it perfectly:

"Ghost Recon Advanced Warfighter for the Xbox continues the disturbing trend of releasing games on different platforms that have the same name but offer vastly different gaming experiences. If you were wondering if Advanced Warfighter for the Xbox might offer something similar to the superb tactical shooter of the same name on the Xbox 360, you can stop wondering now. It doesn't, and it's not even close."

Wasn't Dead Rising exclusivity given up by Lemmings? I may be mistaken, but I remember something to that effect.

Yeah so? He was complaining about graphics for a chunk of the review, and he actually said "watered-down port." One of the reasons this game did so well on the 360 according to gamespot was for the graphics. And you look at a game like Dead rising on 360 vs Wii. The Wii version has no camera, massive downgrade in graphics, less effects and objects you can use (EXAMPLE: 360 version you can drive a car wii version you cannot), and the AI is even stupid for zombies. So all of those changes = multiplat? and the GRAW 360 is exclusive? NVIDIATI

Yeah, so? He just flat out said the game is vastly different than the Xbox 360 counterpart. If one to play the Xbox version and then play he Xbox 360 version. It's night and day. They're entirely different experiences. That's why we consider the 360 version to be multiplatform--yes, it shares the same name but the substance -- which matters most -- between the games is nearly entirely 100% different. How th game is player, the level and mission design itself, the AI, the multiplayer, sound design, the list of differences could go on and on and on.

These are not just simple run of the mill, your average port differences. They're entirely different games.

Xbox 360 has a plethora of multiplats that the Ps3 can't play...360 wins in a 360 vs. Ps3 debate.

[QUOTE="NVIDIATI"]Yeah so? He was complaining about graphics for a chunk of the review, and he actually said "watered-down port." One of the reasons this game did so well on the 360 according to gamespot was for the graphics. And you look at a game like Dead rising on 360 vs Wii. The Wii version has no camera, massive downgrade in graphics, less effects and objects you can use (EXAMPLE: 360 version you can drive a car wii version you cannot), and the AI is even stupid for zombies. So all of those changes = multiplat? and the GRAW 360 is exclusive? Stevo_the_gamer

Yeah, so? He just flat out said the game is vastly different than the Xbox 360 counterpart. If one to play the Xbox version and then play he Xbox 360 version. It's night and day. They're entirely different experiences. That's why we consider the 360 version to be multiplatform--yes, it shares the same name but the substance -- which matters most -- between the games is nearly entirely 100% different. How th game is player, the level and mission design itself, the AI, the multiplayer, sound design, the list of differences could go on and on and on.

These are not just simple run of the mill, your average port differences. They're entirely different games.

Wasn't Dead Rising exclusivity given up by Lemmings? I may be mistaken, but I remember something to that effect.

lundy86_4

And this is multiplat? NVIDIATI

[QUOTE="lundy86_4"]

Wasn't Dead Rising exclusivity given up by Lemmings? I may be mistaken, but I remember something to that effect.

Stevo_the_gamer

Yeah, I remember it being brought up in that thread. It was so long ago, and the thread was so long, that I forget most of it.

It was pretty awesome though :lol:

Yeah, I remember it being brought up in that thread. It was so long ago, and the thread was so long, that I forget most of it.

It was pretty awesome though :lol:

lundy86_4

lols. Tis' was a huge thread. Even more awesome to see the cows arguments get refuted by myself, Foxhound and others. :P

Though how long it took for it to be considered multiplatform was not so awesome.

[QUOTE="NVIDIATI"] And this is multiplat? Stevo_the_gamer

[QUOTE="lundy86_4"]Yeah, I remember it being brought up in that thread. It was so long ago, and the thread was so long, that I forget most of it.

It was pretty awesome though :lol:

Stevo_the_gamer

lols. Tis' was a huge thread. Even more awesome to see the cows arguments get refuted by myself, Foxhound and others. :P

Though how long it took for it to be considered multiplatform was not so awesome.

No it certainly took a while. I think I dropped in my opinion once, then just let everybody go at it, and watched from the sidelines :P

[QUOTE="Stevo_the_gamer"][QUOTE="NVIDIATI"] And this is multiplat? NVIDIATI

watched from the sidelines :P

lundy86_4

[QUOTE="NVIDIATI"][QUOTE="Stevo_the_gamer"]In regards to the SystemWars, tis' multiplatform.Stevo_the_gamer

Ugh that's way too much work I guess change will have to wait :(...Also I don't care that much about this to apply such effort :P

NVIDIATI

[QUOTE="NVIDIATI"] Ugh that's way too much work I guess change will have to wait :(...Also I don't care that much about this to apply such effort :P

Stevo_the_gamer

:shock: You seem to have this thought out already :P

NVIDIATI

[QUOTE="mitu123"]It would be better if the cows actually listed the differences between the versions, but they didn't.Odrec

IGN also says Bayonetta for the 360 is "vastly" superior to the PS3 version. I guess Baynetta for the 360 is an AAAE then. :lol:

[QUOTE="Luther_10"]

This thread has no charts and no numbers :), and its just my opinion

360 AAAEs

1. Forza Motorsport 2
2. Forza Motorsport 3
3. Halo 3
4. Halo 3 ODST
5. Gears of War 2
6. Perfect Dark Zero

PS3 AAAEs

1. Metal Gear Solid 4
2. Uncharted 2 Among Thieves
3. Demon's Souls
4. Infamous
5. Killzone 2
6. Resistance 2
7. Little Big Planet

Jamiemydearx3

[QUOTE="Odrec"]Yeah because what they consider enough or not is their opinion. There is no official decision made by an objective official party. That's why I can talk about GRAW not being exclusive if I like, it's my opinion.Stevo_the_gamer

Edit: And what casey and lundy said too. xD

That's the problem. What determines a different characteristic? How many different characteristics does a game need to be exclusive? This is all arbitrary and opinion. Some people set their standards for exlusives lower, which is why there is this whole arguement in the first place. Calling someone a troll (not referring to you, specifically) for having different opinions is, in itself, also trolling.

[QUOTE="mayceV"][QUOTE="Luther_10"]

This thread has no charts and no numbers :), and its just my opinion

360 AAAEs

1. Forza Motorsport 2
2. Forza Motorsport 3
3. Halo 3
4. Halo 3 ODST
5. Gears of War 2
6. Perfect Dark Zero

PS3 AAAEs

1. Metal Gear Solid 4
2. Uncharted 2 Among Thieves
3. Demon's Souls
4. Infamous
5. Killzone 2
6. Resistance 2
7. Little Big Planet

13C

graw isnt exclusive

Neither is LBP then. :lol:

[QUOTE="NVIDIATI"]:shock: You seem to have this thought out already :P

[QUOTE="Stevo_the_gamer"]

[QUOTE="Odrec"]Yeah because what they consider enough or not is their opinion. There is no official decision made by an objective official party. That's why I can talk about GRAW not being exclusive if I like, it's my opinion.red12355

Edit: And what casey and lundy said too. xD

That's the problem. What determines a different characteristic? How many different characteristics does a game need to be exclusive? This is all arbitrary and opinion. Some people set their standards for exlusives lower, which is why there is this whole arguement in the first place. Calling someone a troll (not referring to you, specifically) for having different opinions is, in itself, also trolling.

The only people accused of trolling, were people who were stating that a game known as being exclusive, and set as exclusive in System Wars (until proven otherwise) is trolling.

It wasn't a simple "difference of opinions".

That's the problem. What determines a different characteristic? How many different characteristics does a game need to be exclusive? This is all arbitrary and opinion. Some people set their standards for exlusives lower, which is why there is this whole arguement in the first place. Calling someone a troll (not referring to you, specifically) for having different opinions is, in itself, also trolling.

red12355