360 vs PS3 '08 exclusives scores (so far)

I really don't care about GS scores but still good thread for people who do.ganon546

ok, this has not been done a million times.LoZonedOut

[QUOTE="LoZonedOut"]ok, this has not been done a million times.hopesfall2own

[QUOTE="LoZonedOut"]ok, this has not been done a million times.hopesfall2own

The search function does suck. I always end up using Google to search GameSpot, which is somewhat sad.

Lost Oddyssey got 7.5. And you could include Siren, it coming out on disc soon.

Edit: OK, you did include Siren, I didn't see it.

I'll do this with no bias, so let's look:

PC/360:

C&C 3: 7.5
Universe at War: 6.5
Supreme Commander: 5


Any changes or additions let me know. Remember this just the EXCLUSIVES for 2008.hopesfall2own

For reference, could I have you definition of exclusive?

Edit: I see you also have Duke Nukem on there. Er...

Lost Oddyssey got 7.5. And you could include Siren, it coming out on disc soon.Floppy_Jim

[QUOTE="hopesfall2own"]I'll do this with no bias, so let's look:

PC/360:

C&C 3: 7.5
Universe at War: 6.5
Supreme Commander: 5


Any changes or additions let me know. Remember this just the EXCLUSIVES for 2008.Kickinurass

For reference, could I have you definition of exclusive?

Edit: I see you also have Duke Nukem on there. Er...

I'll do this with no bias, so let's look:

360:

Fable 2: 8.5
Viva Pinata 2: 8.5
Tales of Vesperia: 8.5
Ninja Gaiden 2: 8
Lost Odyssey: 7.5
Infinite Undiscovery: 6.5




PS3:

Metal Gear Solid 4: 10
Little Big Planet: 9




Any changes or additions let me know. Remember this just the EXCLUSIVES for 2008.hopesfall2own

games I care about

[QUOTE="hopesfall2own"]I'll do this with no bias, so let's look:

PC/360:

C&C 3: 7.5
Universe at War: 6.5
Supreme Commander: 5


Any changes or additions let me know. Remember this just the EXCLUSIVES for 2008.Kickinurass

For reference, could I have you definition of exclusive?

There is a such thing as console exclusive, despite what these forums say. I think that is what he was going for and I am sure you know that. This thread is comparing what one console has over the other just bc a game is on the pc does not mean you can't play on a 360. Nor does it mean you can play it on a ps3, either way this thread is good for those who care about scores.

Wow , look at the PSN content that scored under an 8 :o

[QUOTE="hopesfall2own"][QUOTE="LoZonedOut"]ok, this has not been done a million times.SpruceCaboose

The search function does suck. I always end up using Google to search GameSpot, which is somewhat sad.

Yeah, It is sad. :lol:

If you're going to include PC games (which is weak imo) , then you should include MLB The Show 08 - 8.5 to at least be consistent.

2 small corrections-

Wipeout HD scored 7.5.

Pixeljunk Monsters scored 7.5.

[QUOTE="Kickinurass"]

[QUOTE="hopesfall2own"]I'll do this with no bias, so let's look:

PC/360:

C&C 3: 7.5
Universe at War: 6.5
Supreme Commander: 5


Any changes or additions let me know. Remember this just the EXCLUSIVES for 2008.hopesfall2own

For reference, could I have you definition of exclusive?

Edit: I see you also have Duke Nukem on there. Er...

There is a such thing as console exclusive, despite what these forums say. I think that is what he was going for and I am sure you know that. This thread is comparing what one console has over the other just bc a game is on the pc does not mean you can't play on a 360. Nor does it mean you can play it on a ps3, either way this thread is good for those who care about scores.

Grady420

Of course. It was just funny seeing the word exclusive, and then seeing PC/360 games is all. I don't really care for scores, I just thought it was worth a chuckle.

Anyway, this discussion is pretty positive so I'll stop being so negative.:P

Edit: Gamespot kept cutting off my post.

If you're going to include PC games (which is weak imo) , then you should include MLB The Show 08 - 8.5 to at least be consistent.

Nike_Air

[QUOTE="Kickinurass"]

[QUOTE="hopesfall2own"]I'll do this with no bias, so let's look:

PC/360:

C&C 3: 7.5
Universe at War: 6.5
Supreme Commander: 5


Any changes or additions let me know. Remember this just the EXCLUSIVES for 2008.Grady420

For reference, could I have you definition of exclusive?

There is a such thing as console exclusive, despite what these forums say. I think that is what he was going for and I am sure you know that. This thread is comparing what one console has over the other just bc a game is on the pc does not mean you can't play on a 360. Nor does it mean you can play it on a ps3, either way this thread is good for those who care about scores.

No MLB: The Show.

I think thats what its called.

2 small corrections-

Wipeout HD scored 7.5.

Pixeljunk Monsters scored 7.5.

Floppy_Jim

No MLB: The Show.

I think thats what its called.

sam280992

[QUOTE="Floppy_Jim"]

2 small corrections-

Wipeout HD scored 7.5.

Pixeljunk Monsters scored 7.5.

hopesfall2own

Oh right, I was looking at Pixeljunk Eden by mistake. What about MLB: The Show? Not technically exclusive but it's not on the 360. Otherwise, this is a good list.

[QUOTE="Nike_Air"]

If you're going to include PC games (which is weak imo) , then you should include MLB The Show 08 - 8.5 to at least be consistent.

Couth_

[QUOTE="hopesfall2own"][QUOTE="Floppy_Jim"]

2 small corrections-

Wipeout HD scored 7.5.

Pixeljunk Monsters scored 7.5.

Floppy_Jim

Oh right, I was looking at Pixeljunk Eden by mistake. What about MLB: The Show? Not technically exclusive but it's not on the 360. Otherwise, this is a good list.

[QUOTE="Couth_"][QUOTE="Nike_Air"]

If you're going to include PC games (which is weak imo) , then you should include MLB The Show 08 - 8.5 to at least be consistent.

hopesfall2own

Yea dude...its a full game with over 60 cars,tons of tracks and online.And you missed on Wipeout HD.The most underrated game of this fall.

Hot Shots Golf Out of Bounds - 7.5

[QUOTE="hopesfall2own"][QUOTE="Couth_"][QUOTE="Nike_Air"]

If you're going to include PC games (which is weak imo) , then you should include MLB The Show 08 - 8.5 to at least be consistent.

lesner87

Yea dude...its a full game with over 60 cars,tons of tracks and online.And you missed on Wipeout HD.The most underrated game of this fall.

Hot Shots Golf Out of Bounds - 7.5

Nike_Air

I'll do this with no bias, so let's look:

360:

Ninja Gaiden 2: 8

PC/360:

PS3:

Metal Gear Solid 4: 10
Little Big Planet: 9


XBLA:

Braid: 9.5

PSN:

Echochrome: 8
Ratchet & Clank QfB: 7.5
The Last Guy: 7.5
Wipeout HD: 7.5
Siren Blood Curse: 7

Any changes or additions let me know. Remember this just the EXCLUSIVES for 2008.hopesfall2own

Games i'm interested in...

Exclusive disc games -

Gamespot

• 9.0 - Gears of War 2
• 8.5 - Fable 2
• 8.5 - Tales of Vesperia
• 8.5 - Viva Pinata TiP
• 8.0 - Ninja Gaiden 2

-

• 10 - Metal Gear Solid Guns of The Patriots
• 9.0 - LittleBigPlanet
• 9.0 - Resistance 2
• 8.0 - Motorstorm Pacific Rift

Gamerankings - needs 20 reviews to qualify

• 94 - Gears of War 2
• 89 - Fable 2
• 83 - Tales of Vesperia
• 83 - Viva Pinata TiP
• 82 - Ninja Gaiden 2

-

• 95 - LittleBigPlanet
• 93 - Metal Gears Solid 4
• 83 - Singstar
• 82 - Hot Shots Golf
• 81 - Disgaea 3
• 81 - Buzz Quiz TV
• 80 - Motorstorm 2
• 80 - GT5 Prologue

Updated

TC, there is no VIVA 2.

The Newest Viva is the exact same game, with some more Pinata's in it.

This is one of those things to do to re-expose a good game to a market, again.

TC, there is no VIVA 2.

The Newest Viva is the exact same game, with some more Pinata's in it.

This is one of those things to do to re-expose a good game to a market, again.

SolidTy

Lets revist this when Resistance 2 and Gears of War 2 reviews are in .

Retail:

360 has 72 points in total. PS3 has 70 points. Ohh, 360 just edges past the PS3.

Lets revist this when Resistance 2 and Gears of War 2 reviews are in .

ExtremeOne316

Retail:

360 has 72 points in total. PS3 has 70 points. Ohh, 360 just edges past the PS3.

-DrRobotnik-

I don't understand the color coding for the scores that you have...or are they colored just to look pretty?EXLINK

If you add all the scores together, not counting 360/PC games :

360 = 53

Ps3 = 70

__________________

XBLA = 82.5

PSN = 73.5

Then if you add the scores of downloadable plus retail games :

360 = 135.5

Ps3 = 143.5

Ps3 is teh current winnar.

Ps3 is teh current winnar.

angelkimne

[QUOTE="angelkimne"]

Ps3 is teh current winnar.

hopesfall2own

You could have 10 billion 9.5 games on one console versus a console with one 10 game and the console with the AAAA would still win.

[QUOTE="hopesfall2own"][QUOTE="angelkimne"]

Ps3 is teh current winnar.

angelkimne

You could have 10 billion 9.5 games on one console versus a console with one 10 game and the console with the AAAA would still win.

Why is Gran Turismo 5 Prologue: 7.5, Ratchet & Clank QfB: 7.5 ,Siren Blood Curse: 7 on the PSN list and not Socom.

All of them have a Retail version.

Are you including games like Africa and Aqua?

Why is PC/360 included and not a PC list?

Street Fighter alpha (PSN) did it get reviewed? Is it considered exclusive?

Is Burnout: paradise PSN exclusive?

If you are including PC /360 games as exlusive to 360, why not include 360 /last gen games as XBL exlusive?

Rez HD ?

edit : Some people don't know the meaning of "exclusives".